Fm14 Deal or No Deal thread: Please use when asking if you should buy player x or y

[LDPLFC]

Team: Liverpool fc
Buying: Ben Arfa/ 15million, Pedro Obiang 11m, Ward Prouse 17m

are these players worth it?

 

[mersk]

Team: Liverpool fc
Buying: Ben Arfa/ 15million, Pedro Obiang 11m, Ward Prouse 17m

are these players worth it?

IMO Ben Arfa is not worth 15m in the game. You can easily find just as good options who are not injury prone, and probably cheaper too.

Obiang for 11m sounds like a good deal, I'd say yes. Man Utd paid ?26m for him in 2016 in my game, and he has very good allround attributes.

I just bought Ward-Prowse myself (also managing LFC) for a measly ?2.3m. He has good attributes, is English, young and promising - but for ?17m I'd still say no.

This is based on me assuming you're in the first transfer window, and have ?15-20m to spend.

 

[ijoinedforfm]

Player: Morgan Schneiderlin
Team you are managing: Manchester City
Team who are selling: Southampton
Offer: ?13mil
Year: 2015/16

 

[The Icelander]

Player: Ramires
Team you are managing: Chelsea
Team who are buying: Real Madrid
Offer: 37 mil
Year: Summer window 2014

 

[tommyd150]

sign hes amazing

 

[denfu]

Player: Morgan Schneiderlin
Team you are managing: Manchester City
Team who are selling: Southampton
Offer: ?13mil
Year: 2015/16

Definitely worth the money. Lack a bit of physical power but otherwise he's amazing.

 

[Dezy]

Player: Antony Knockaert
Team you are managing: Wigan
Team who are selling: Leicester
Offer: ?5.75M
Year: 2013/2014

 

[No7Lukeee]

Player: Julian Draxler
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are selling: Schalke
Offer: ?39M
Year: 2015/2016
Other: Wants 160k per week, Would be 100k more than my highest paid players wages, As I'm trying to keep my financial side perfect.

 

[Newcastleeffect]

Player: moussa sissoko
Team who are buying: PSG
Team who are selling: Newcastle
Year: 2014/2015
Offer: 30m (up front)
Other: he's value is up to 16.5 after a very good 13/14, any recommended replacements

 

[Nando9]

Player: Florenzi
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are selling: Roma
Offer: 13mil
Year: July 14

Player: Verratti
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are selling: PSG
Offer: 12.5mil
Year: July 14

Player: Ander Herrera
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are selling: Bilbao
Offer: 22mil
Year: July 14

Which one would be the best replacement for Lucas Leiva

 

[cmh9090]

Player: Antony Knockaert
Team you are managing: Wigan
Team who are selling: Leicester
Offer: ?5.75M
Year: 2013/2014

nothing much can go wrong at 5.75m as you can probably profit from him later and his stats are decent as well. you might also like to try for tom ince.

Player: Julian Draxler
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are selling: Schalke
Offer: ?39M
Year: 2015/2016
Other: Wants 160k per week, Would be 100k more than my highest paid players wages, As I'm trying to keep my financial side perfect.

try looking for regens instead. i'd say no deal.

Player: moussa sissoko
Team who are buying: PSG
Team who are selling: Newcastle
Year: 2014/2015
Offer: 30m (up front)
Other: he's value is up to 16.5 after a very good 13/14, any recommended replacements

deal. you can go for fernando (should be about 28 in your game but is pretty solid), marco verratti, morgan schneiderlain, james ward-prowse, jonathan dos santos, andrea poli. some of them may be overpriced though.

Player: Florenzi
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are selling: Roma
Offer: 13mil
Year: July 14

Player: Verratti
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are selling: PSG
Offer: 12.5mil
Year: July 14

Player: Ander Herrera
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are selling: Bilbao
Offer: 22mil
Year: July 14

Which one would be the best replacement for Lucas Leiva

i'd go for verratti if height isnt an issue.

 

[867stevo]

Player: Will Hughes
Team you are managing: Wolves
Team who are buying: Arsenal
Offer: 13m
Year: August 2016

 

[mersk]

Player: Will Hughes
Team you are managing: Wolves
Team who are buying: Arsenal
Offer: 13m
Year: August 2016

If I understand correctly Hughes is your player and Arsenal are bidding 13m for him? If that's the case, no deal. I have him at Liverpool in 2017 and he's worth over 30m.

 

[littlewoulf]

Player: david luiz
Team you are managing: liverpool
Team who are selling: chelsea
Offer: 20m
Year: august 2013

Player: Su?rez
Team you are managing: liverpool
Team who are buying: arsenal
Offer: ramsey, podolski & giroud(trade)
Year: august 2013

 

[St Requiem]

Player: Gaston Ramirez
Team you are managing: Southampton
Team who are buying: Man City
Offer: 17m
Year: June 2014

 

[cmh9090]

Player: david luiz
Team you are managing: liverpool
Team who are selling: chelsea
Offer: 20m
Year: august 2013

Player: Su?rez
Team you are managing: liverpool
Team who are buying: arsenal
Offer: ramsey, podolski & giroud(trade)
Year: august 2013

no deal for luiz, but deal for suarez as the offer is very attractive and other than sturridge and aspas (in game), liverpool does not seem to have any more good strikers. for the cb position, you might want to scout subotic (quite cheap in most games), balenta, and kyriakos papadopoulos etc instead.

Player: Gaston Ramirez
Team you are managing: Southampton
Team who are buying: Man City
Offer: 17m
Year: June 2014

no deal as he's becomes quality (in game)

 

[Scotty98TR]

Player: david luiz
Team you are managing: liverpool
Team who are selling: chelsea
Offer: 20m
Year: august 2013

Player: Su?rez
Team you are managing: liverpool
Team who are buying: arsenal
Offer: ramsey, podolski & giroud(trade)
Year: august 2013

I'd say no deal for either. Luiz isn't great, and there is better for ?20m & his wages.

Suarez is fantastic on this game, whereas although Ramsey has good potential, and Giroud is a decent DLF/Target man, Giroud isn't much of a scorer and podolski isn't great. Seen Suarez been sold for ?70m after a season and a half.

 

[Scotty98TR]

Player: Gom?s
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who are buying/selling: Lyon
Offer: ?1.7m (Agent and loyalty fees) to join at end of contract
Year: January 2014

He's top scorer in the Champions League, and I need another striker as backup to Scocco/Giroud. I also have Vela, along with Werner in the U19s

 

[silvela]

Player : Aleksandar Mitrovic
Team managing : FM Base (from the challenge thread)
Team buying : AC Milan Bayern and Others
Offer : ?40M ?39M
Year :2016(July)
Transfer listed on request .. signed him season before for 9M ..he got injured so featured sparingly with Damiao and Rescaldani were ahead of him...

 

[mersk]

Player: Gom?s
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who are buying/selling: Lyon
Offer: ?1.7m (Agent and loyalty fees) to join at end of contract
Year: January 2014

He's top scorer in the Champions League, and I need another striker as backup to Scocco/Giroud. I also have Vela, along with Werner in the U19s

Vela is great, but you should play Werner instead of any of those. He becomes top class, just sold him to Milan for 62m. For that low a fee there's no financial risk in signing him, but personally I'd give that playing time to Werner.