FM15 Deal or No Deal thread: Please use when asking if you should buy player x or y

[xtremeRED]

Player : Bernardo Silva
My Club : Blackburn
Buying Club : PSG
Offered Price : Total is £55m, with £40m guaranteed and 30% profit sell on
Year : 2018/19

Sell, and invest some of that money buying 4-5 young Portuguese kids from Porto or SLB or Sporting!

 

[Cookie1]

Aboubakar is at ManCity and they are not willing to sell. I personally dont like Munir because he takes too many long shots. Shaarawy, Calhanoglu and Meyer are good but I am looking for World Class signings and in my opinion these three players are not World Class.

 

[Cookie1]

wage demands? I'd take Bale from these 3, he's class, albeit a bit injury prone, but better value signing than the others..

also, look at Max Meyer, Calhanoglu, Shaarawy, Aboubakar, Munir etc for attacking options...

Aboubakar is at ManCity and they are not willing to sell. I personally dont like Munir because he takes too many long shots. Shaarawy, Calhanoglu and Meyer are good but I am looking for World Class signings and in my opinion these three players are not World Class.

 

[dc321]

Player: Munir
My club : Barca
buying club: bayern
offer: 34million pounds + 50% future transfer
year: second season january transfer deadline day
help asap!!!

 

[TheJonJim]

I've sold Munir for about 70m with 25% sell on clause before so you can definitely get more.

Player : Gabriel Barbosa
My Club : Tottenham
Selling Club : Dortmund
Offered Price : 25m but his agent wants 58m for his share
Year : 2019/2020

So, basically, is Gabriel Barbosa worth 83m? I'm seriously leaning towards no but I need a good striker that is young and will last awhile. I doubt I'd be able to make a profit on him thanks to that astronomical agent share so it's a bit iffy.

 

[aramis]

I didn't want to buy Barbosa not even when his agent was asking for 17m and Bayern wanted just 5m... 83m is a LOT of money ... in 2020 maybe you could sign a better regen then Barbosa? My opinion.

 

[Pulssqt]

Just won CL and Bundesliga with Bayern Munchen, year is 2016, i have some money to spend and was thinking about buying Neymar, price is somewhere around 85m + 17mil bonuses(thats all i have), wages are 18m per year.
Now everyone would say, sign him dont even think about it, but i bought Douglas Costa last season as Left IF, and he is amazing(37matches, 24goals, 21assists, 7.81 rating), and im kinda sad to put him as my 2nd choice.

Neymar is probably best ingame for that position, and he is still young.

What should i do ?


This is my squad atm.
Form is 4-2-3-1 Wide

Lewandowski
D.Costa Gotze Muller
Pogba J.Rodriguez
Bernat Balanta Laporte Lahm
Neuer

Res: Badstuber, Boateng, Rafael, Gaudino, Hojbjerg, Tielemans, Odegaard, Barbosa

 

[xtremeRED]

Just won CL and Bundesliga with Bayern Munchen, year is 2016, i have some money to spend and was thinking about buying Neymar, price is somewhere around 85m + 17mil bonuses(thats all i have), wages are 18m per year.
Now everyone would say, sign him dont even think about it, but i bought Douglas Costa last season as Left IF, and he is amazing(37matches, 24goals, 21assists, 7.81 rating), and im kinda sad to put him as my 2nd choice.

Neymar is probably best ingame for that position, and he is still young.

What should i do ?


This is my squad atm.
Form is 4-2-3-1 Wide

Lewandowski
D.Costa Gotze Muller
Pogba J.Rodriguez
Bernat Balanta Laporte Lahm
Neuer

Res: Badstuber, Boateng, Rafael, Gaudino, Hojbjerg, Tielemans, Odegaard, Barbosa

Neymar would undoubtedly be an upgrade over Costa, and as such, it would make sense to sell Costa and replace with Neymar, and look to buy another second choice winger for the spot- Bilal Ould Chikh, Jack Grealish etc..
Your attack would become lethal and phenomenon once you have Neymar as well.. He is world class, and amazing in the left wing role!

 

[ManUnited20]

Player: Mario gotze
Club you're managing: Manchester United
Club who are buying: Arsenal/Tottenham
Price: 47 mil pound
Year: August 2018
Should i sell or keep him ? only paid 15 mil for him

 

[Pulssqt]

Player: Mario gotze
Club you're managing: Manchester United
Club who are buying: Arsenal/Tottenham
Price: 47 mil pound
Year: August 2018
Should i sell or keep him ? only paid 15 mil for him

Keep him. Just give him some time, he's insane.

Player: Adnan Januzaj
Club you're managing: Bayern Munchen
Club who are selling: Man Utd
Price: 44m. 20m initial, 13m over 12 months, 16,5m after 30 league apps, 80k per league app(50)
Year: October 2016
He is a beast but i already got Meyer, Odegaard, Gotze, Muller, Neymar and D.Costa for those positions. Should i go for it and keep him because i will maybe sell Costa/Meyer and keep Januzaj as a replacement for Muller who is 27 atm.