Let's talk about Tactic Testing for FM21

  • Thread starter Thread starter Liam
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 336
  • Views Views 85K
Small suggestion for the developers: when viewing a tactic, if you click the tactic's screenshots on the right side of the page, there appears to be no way to close the image viewer that opens. Tried pressing ESC key, tried clicking outside the image, and there is no "Close" or "X" button either. It's a minor issue that can be solved by forcing a browser refresh, but perhaps something to work on in the future when other higher priority features are completed.
 
Swans said:
Small suggestion for the developers: when viewing a tactic, if you click the tactic's screenshots on the right side of the page, there appears to be no way to close the image viewer that opens. Tried pressing ESC key, tried clicking outside the image, and there is no "Close" or "X" button either. It's a minor issue that can be solved by forcing a browser refresh, but perhaps something to work on in the future when other higher priority features are completed.
Click to expand...

I believe you can close it by just clicking the image ^^
 
We've updated our FM21 Tactic Testing page!
It's cooler now because you can:
  • Filter by formation
  • Filter authors
c229A5B.gif
 
Liam said:
We've updated our FM21 Tactic Testing page!
It's cooler now because you can:
  • Filter by formation
  • Filter authors
Click to expand...

Good job! Almost perfect, please open a new browser window when click on the tactic button so the current sorted results page can remain there otherwise I'll have to redo sorting all over again after clicking on a tactic to view it's detail.
 
antoine79 said:
Good job! Almost perfect, please open a new browser window when click on the tactic button so the current sorted results page can remain there otherwise I'll have to redo sorting all over again after clicking on a tactic to view it's detail.
Click to expand...

@Luigi
 
?
We're working on a solution for this problem that should be slightly more efficient: when you will go back you will return to the same filters as before.

In the meantime you can click the "tactic buttons" using the scroll wheel, or ctrl + click to have the same result :D
 
my tactics still not tested even they have been uploaded for a long time.

problems started after new patch.

my atalanta is still best non winger tactic in game
 
vujevic said:
my tactics still not tested even they have been uploaded for a long time.

problems started after new patch.

my atalanta is still best non winger tactic in game
Click to expand...

We have over 400 tactics in queue... It will takes some days before all of them are gonna be tested :(
Sry about that
 
Luigi said:
We have over 400 tactics in queue... It will takes some days before all of them are gonna be tested :(
Sry about that
Click to expand...
and like 160 of them are knap tactics?

shouldnt it be possible to make tactics upvoteable and sort the queue by votes or sth?
 
fidelitas said:
and like 160 of them are knap tactics?

shouldnt it be possible to make tactics upvoteable and sort the queue by votes or sth?
Click to expand...

When we merge in the new platform, 100% we will do something to optimize the test queue and not do just random.
A little bit of patience since things are still under development?
 
Test should be done in FIFO first in first out and only pick tactic where the author does not already have another tactic in queue. In this way it will be totally fair and it can prevent author with a lot of tactics flooded the queue. Totally random is unfair to those who uploaded early and have lesser tactics and only favorable to those who have uploaded a lot of tactics. This is very unhealthy to fmbase, soon users will fed up with the long wait and no longer want to upload their tactics to fmbase. In fact we already seen some fmbase users are now only uploading their tactics to your competitor's test site instead of fmbase.
 
dginola said:
Test should be done in FIFO first in first out and only pick tactic where the author does not already have another tactic in queue. In this way it will be totally fair and it can prevent author with a lot of tactics flooded the queue. Totally random is unfair to those who uploaded early and have lesser tactics and only favorable to those who have uploaded a lot of tactics. This is very unhealthy to fmbase, soon users will fed up with the long wait and no longer want to upload their tactics to fmbase. In fact we already seen some fmbase users are now only uploading their tactics to your competitor's test site instead of fmbase.
Click to expand...

This solution can bring people into creating multiple users to have their tactics tested.
We will have a fair solution in the future, one that will take into account users upvotes and quantity of tactics uploaded by the user. At the moment, the duality between Xenforo and the new platform doesn't make it easy to implement a "fair queue" with the current setup. We prefer to spend resources in finishing the new platform instead of having to implement complex solutions for a problem we already know how to fix in the future setup.

What I can tell is that we will not add in the queue other tactics until we test the ones in the current queue, so in 7 days you can expect to have mostly all currently queued tactics tested.

Regarding the competitor's test site... ?
 
Luigi said:
?
We're working on a solution for this problem that should be slightly more efficient: when you will go back you will return to the same filters as before.

In the meantime you can click the "tactic buttons" using the scroll wheel, or ctrl + click to have the same result :D
Click to expand...
Clicking with the scroll wheel doesn't open the tactic in a new tab it just activates the scroll with mouse movement.
Control + click just opens the tactic in the current tab.
 
mattyskilz said:
Clicking with the scroll wheel doesn't open the tactic in a new tab it just activates the scroll with mouse movement.
Control + click just opens the tactic in the current tab.
Click to expand...

Ok, the scroll wheel may be only if set up, which OS do you have? With MacOS it's cmd + click.
 
mattyskilz said:
Clicking with the scroll wheel doesn't open the tactic in a new tab it just activates the scroll with mouse movement.
Control + click just opens the tactic in the current tab.
Click to expand...

Ok, the scroll wheel may be only if set up, which OS do you have? With MacOS it's cmd + click.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top