LFCMarshall's FM13 Suggestion Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Went throught the database and noticed Ivan Turina is still on the game. He passed away earlier this year and AIK has replaced him with Christian Frealdson (Akropolis i think)
 
Hey LFCMarshall. Just downloaded the update and i wanted to start a game with West Ham. Saw that you made the stadium change to the olympic stadium, which is cool but how will it affect the game you think? What about the economy of the club? did you take in mind that they are going to pay "rent" for it or what? Appreciate it, thanks!
 
Hello Marshall, appreciate the update and the work you do. One thing I wonder is, has nobody made the suggestion or have you considered at all putting fixated PA instead of -9, at least for the bigger young talents. I always thought this would be a great solution, because -9 can be extremely random, and I see you already gave some players like Varane, Thiago, Gotze, Isco, Wilshere etc their PA. For example, I just started a game, and a certain Jherson Vergara has 180 PA, while Nastasic has 158. Or another example, Hector bellerin has it at 177, while Mattia De Sciglio has 162. Or Jese and Deulofeu both having only 165 PA. I understand keeping it at -9 for the some of them, because you can't know how they will turn out, but having players who have already proven themselves (I think of the first two), to turn out that average and that much worse than a "luckier" -9 player, just isn't fair. Before this turns into a wall of text, what I am trying to say is give these four I mentioned 172-180 PA. Sorry for rambling and thanks again.
 
Okay, Celtic changes:

James Forrest deserves a fitness and balance increase, he looks extremely naked and as though he was just thrown together, rather than had someone actually scout him to see that he's a very underrated player with lots of potential. He's 22 as well now, and doing well and showing more maturity on the pitch, so I would suggest the following changes too: Creativity - 14. Crossing - 15. Flair - 16. Technique - 14. But that's it, everything looks well enough to be in place to develop correctly on their own. He's a great wee player, but he's not exactly up there with your Adam Johnson's or your Gareth Bales.

Lassad has left. His contract was mutually terminated. I heard about this a few weeks ago, I don't think it's been properly confirmed for anyone to clarify online.

Samaras can do with the following changes - CA/PA 10 higher on both, I would maybe make them both 165. He's always been a very reliable player and is a giant when it comes to looking for getting the job done when the rest of the team are struggling. Most of his attributes are spot on, but as I said a PA/CA could do him justice. Heading - 17. Finishing - 14. Long shots - 13. Marking - 12. Bravery - 14. Composure - 12. Concentration - 15. Decisions - 14. Influence - 15.

I tried this before when I went to update my Celtic side, and I made everyones CA/PA 20 higher and Manchester United were coming in for Commons, very unrealistic, so I took it down to 10 and Scott Brown, Joe Ledley and Charlie Mulgrew in particular's attributes were that of a ******* monster, like Hamsik or Moutinho. So if you leave them the way they are they'll be just fine. Whilst everyone else could do with a 5 - 10 increase.

Adam Matthews also is in need of some changes, he's only 21 and got bags of potential, which already shows in the game, but some attributes are off now that the season has been complete: Passing - 15. Composure - 14. Concentration - 13. Creativity - 15. Decisions - 14. Flair - 15 and Balance 13.

The following youth prospects should be taken a look at, their attributes and CA/PA are just ridiculous and have found it difficult to bring said players into the first time over time because their attributes aren't correctly matching their position on the field.

Marcus Fraser, he's considered a star of the future, deffo needs a CA/PA change. Marking, Concentration, Natural Fitness, Anticipation, Decision Making, Composure and Influence all needing set right, I would say between 10 - 13 for each. In my current game, Marcus, Paul George, Lewis Kidd, Tony Watt, James Forrest, Adam Matthews, Dylan Mcgeouch, Filip/Patrik Twardzik, Calum McGregor, Jackson Irvine, Tom Rogic, Joe Chalmers and Paddy McNally I have set their CA/PA to 121/175. Patrik could sit at 111/145, as his brother is the better of the two. Joe Chalmers you needent touch attribute wise as this boost compliments the player he's been showing signs to be. Tom Rogic and Dylan I would make their passing 14 and that's it.

Also, some system changes, we should have 20 in passion, loyality and influence as you don't need a genius to tell you we have the best fans and home and away atmosphere on the planet! Also our training facilities should be all 20 as we have state of the art facilities and always have, we're always producing the best youth prospects (if we manage to keep them, introduce them to the first team and not sell) This era under Neil Lennon we will see that, the past years not so much.

But yeah, this is my honest and unbiased opinions on the changes needed to be made. We're the top team in the league, yet in some games we're being tipped to draw with Aberdeen, wtf?! Also, a reputation update would be good too. I know everyone believes their club to be the best, with the best history, fans, players and facilities, and that doesn't ring across on FM, but Celtic are a special club, always have been and always will, we're up there with Barcelona in terms of how we treat our players, how we enter games, the passion and commitment we show, our reputation speaks for us ALONE! (Just be stingy on the transfer funds, we've got an owner keen on never spending big bucks on anyone) and this game makes us look full on *****, and unrealistic and a genuine part of the rest of Scottish football.

Ain't no body got time for seeing big Samaras play to colossal measures in the Champions League, to see him struggle against a 35 year old winger for Falkirk, no ******* way!
 
Muhamed Subasic bosnian NT player from Dynamo Dresden to Leuven (Belgium) to 2015.
Gonzalo Higuain from Real M. to Napoli to 2018.
 
Okay, Celtic changes:

James Forrest deserves a fitness and balance increase, he looks extremely naked and as though he was just thrown together, rather than had someone actually scout him to see that he's a very underrated player with lots of potential. He's 22 as well now, and doing well and showing more maturity on the pitch, so I would suggest the following changes too: Creativity - 14. Crossing - 15. Flair - 16. Technique - 14. But that's it, everything looks well enough to be in place to develop correctly on their own. He's a great wee player, but he's not exactly up there with your Adam Johnson's or your Gareth Bales.

Lassad has left. His contract was mutually terminated. I heard about this a few weeks ago, I don't think it's been properly confirmed for anyone to clarify online.

Samaras can do with the following changes - CA/PA 10 higher on both, I would maybe make them both 165. He's always been a very reliable player and is a giant when it comes to looking for getting the job done when the rest of the team are struggling. Most of his attributes are spot on, but as I said a PA/CA could do him justice. Heading - 17. Finishing - 14. Long shots - 13. Marking - 12. Bravery - 14. Composure - 12. Concentration - 15. Decisions - 14. Influence - 15.

I tried this before when I went to update my Celtic side, and I made everyones CA/PA 20 higher and Manchester United were coming in for Commons, very unrealistic, so I took it down to 10 and Scott Brown, Joe Ledley and Charlie Mulgrew in particular's attributes were that of a ******* monster, like Hamsik or Moutinho. So if you leave them the way they are they'll be just fine. Whilst everyone else could do with a 5 - 10 increase.

Adam Matthews also is in need of some changes, he's only 21 and got bags of potential, which already shows in the game, but some attributes are off now that the season has been complete: Passing - 15. Composure - 14. Concentration - 13. Creativity - 15. Decisions - 14. Flair - 15 and Balance 13.

The following youth prospects should be taken a look at, their attributes and CA/PA are just ridiculous and have found it difficult to bring said players into the first time over time because their attributes aren't correctly matching their position on the field.

Marcus Fraser, he's considered a star of the future, deffo needs a CA/PA change. Marking, Concentration, Natural Fitness, Anticipation, Decision Making, Composure and Influence all needing set right, I would say between 10 - 13 for each. In my current game, Marcus, Paul George, Lewis Kidd, Tony Watt, James Forrest, Adam Matthews, Dylan Mcgeouch, Filip/Patrik Twardzik, Calum McGregor, Jackson Irvine, Tom Rogic, Joe Chalmers and Paddy McNally I have set their CA/PA to 121/175. Patrik could sit at 111/145, as his brother is the better of the two. Joe Chalmers you needent touch attribute wise as this boost compliments the player he's been showing signs to be. Tom Rogic and Dylan I would make their passing 14 and that's it.

Also, some system changes, we should have 20 in passion, loyality and influence as you don't need a genius to tell you we have the best fans and home and away atmosphere on the planet! Also our training facilities should be all 20 as we have state of the art facilities and always have, we're always producing the best youth prospects (if we manage to keep them, introduce them to the first team and not sell) This era under Neil Lennon we will see that, the past years not so much.

But yeah, this is my honest and unbiased opinions on the changes needed to be made. We're the top team in the league, yet in some games we're being tipped to draw with Aberdeen, wtf?! Also, a reputation update would be good too. I know everyone believes their club to be the best, with the best history, fans, players and facilities, and that doesn't ring across on FM, but Celtic are a special club, always have been and always will, we're up there with Barcelona in terms of how we treat our players, how we enter games, the passion and commitment we show, our reputation speaks for us ALONE! (Just be stingy on the transfer funds, we've got an owner keen on never spending big bucks on anyone) and this game makes us look full on *****, and unrealistic and a genuine part of the rest of Scottish football.

Ain't no body got time for seeing big Samaras play to colossal measures in the Champions League, to see him struggle against a 35 year old winger for Falkirk, no ******* way!

unbiased ! Are you suuuuuure!
 
unbiased ! Are you suuuuuure!

Yeah man, if you know anything about Celtic you would say yourself. We're an outstanding team with good youth prospects coming through, is it so bad to want the game to mirror that? Every year I find myself having to update the database to match what we're REALLY like, so frustrating!
 
Bosnian NT player Adnan Zahirovic from Spartak Nalchik to Bochum to 2015.
yup
Went throught the database and noticed Ivan Turina is still on the game. He passed away earlier this year and AIK has replaced him with Christian Frealdson (Akropolis i think)
very sure i retired him, will have a look
Please remove Micah richards' injury.
yep
Hey LFCMarshall. Just downloaded the update and i wanted to start a game with West Ham. Saw that you made the stadium change to the olympic stadium, which is cool but how will it affect the game you think? What about the economy of the club? did you take in mind that they are going to pay "rent" for it or what? Appreciate it, thanks!
Cant change future finances on the editor, so they will move into the olympic stadium then no idea what will happen
Henri Anier signs on loan for Motherwell for 6 months
yep
Hello Marshall, appreciate the update and the work you do. One thing I wonder is, has nobody made the suggestion or have you considered at all putting fixated PA instead of -9, at least for the bigger young talents. I always thought this would be a great solution, because -9 can be extremely random, and I see you already gave some players like Varane, Thiago, Gotze, Isco, Wilshere etc their PA. For example, I just started a game, and a certain Jherson Vergara has 180 PA, while Nastasic has 158. Or another example, Hector bellerin has it at 177, while Mattia De Sciglio has 162. Or Jese and Deulofeu both having only 165 PA. I understand keeping it at -9 for the some of them, because you can't know how they will turn out, but having players who have already proven themselves (I think of the first two), to turn out that average and that much worse than a "luckier" -9 player, just isn't fair. Before this turns into a wall of text, what I am trying to say is give these four I mentioned 172-180 PA. Sorry for rambling and thanks again.
Ill have a look
Okay, Celtic changes:

James Forrest deserves a fitness and balance increase, he looks extremely naked and as though he was just thrown together, rather than had someone actually scout him to see that he's a very underrated player with lots of potential. He's 22 as well now, and doing well and showing more maturity on the pitch, so I would suggest the following changes too: Creativity - 14. Crossing - 15. Flair - 16. Technique - 14. But that's it, everything looks well enough to be in place to develop correctly on their own. He's a great wee player, but he's not exactly up there with your Adam Johnson's or your Gareth Bales.

Lassad has left. His contract was mutually terminated. I heard about this a few weeks ago, I don't think it's been properly confirmed for anyone to clarify online.

Samaras can do with the following changes - CA/PA 10 higher on both, I would maybe make them both 165. He's always been a very reliable player and is a giant when it comes to looking for getting the job done when the rest of the team are struggling. Most of his attributes are spot on, but as I said a PA/CA could do him justice. Heading - 17. Finishing - 14. Long shots - 13. Marking - 12. Bravery - 14. Composure - 12. Concentration - 15. Decisions - 14. Influence - 15.

I tried this before when I went to update my Celtic side, and I made everyones CA/PA 20 higher and Manchester United were coming in for Commons, very unrealistic, so I took it down to 10 and Scott Brown, Joe Ledley and Charlie Mulgrew in particular's attributes were that of a ******* monster, like Hamsik or Moutinho. So if you leave them the way they are they'll be just fine. Whilst everyone else could do with a 5 - 10 increase.

Adam Matthews also is in need of some changes, he's only 21 and got bags of potential, which already shows in the game, but some attributes are off now that the season has been complete: Passing - 15. Composure - 14. Concentration - 13. Creativity - 15. Decisions - 14. Flair - 15 and Balance 13.

The following youth prospects should be taken a look at, their attributes and CA/PA are just ridiculous and have found it difficult to bring said players into the first time over time because their attributes aren't correctly matching their position on the field.

Marcus Fraser, he's considered a star of the future, deffo needs a CA/PA change. Marking, Concentration, Natural Fitness, Anticipation, Decision Making, Composure and Influence all needing set right, I would say between 10 - 13 for each. In my current game, Marcus, Paul George, Lewis Kidd, Tony Watt, James Forrest, Adam Matthews, Dylan Mcgeouch, Filip/Patrik Twardzik, Calum McGregor, Jackson Irvine, Tom Rogic, Joe Chalmers and Paddy McNally I have set their CA/PA to 121/175. Patrik could sit at 111/145, as his brother is the better of the two. Joe Chalmers you needent touch attribute wise as this boost compliments the player he's been showing signs to be. Tom Rogic and Dylan I would make their passing 14 and that's it.

Also, some system changes, we should have 20 in passion, loyality and influence as you don't need a genius to tell you we have the best fans and home and away atmosphere on the planet! Also our training facilities should be all 20 as we have state of the art facilities and always have, we're always producing the best youth prospects (if we manage to keep them, introduce them to the first team and not sell) This era under Neil Lennon we will see that, the past years not so much.

But yeah, this is my honest and unbiased opinions on the changes needed to be made. We're the top team in the league, yet in some games we're being tipped to draw with Aberdeen, wtf?! Also, a reputation update would be good too. I know everyone believes their club to be the best, with the best history, fans, players and facilities, and that doesn't ring across on FM, but Celtic are a special club, always have been and always will, we're up there with Barcelona in terms of how we treat our players, how we enter games, the passion and commitment we show, our reputation speaks for us ALONE! (Just be stingy on the transfer funds, we've got an owner keen on never spending big bucks on anyone) and this game makes us look full on *****, and unrealistic and a genuine part of the rest of Scottish football.

Ain't no body got time for seeing big Samaras play to colossal measures in the Champions League, to see him struggle against a 35 year old winger for Falkirk, no ******* way!
Some changes i agree with, and i mean only some.... alot of that is very biased

Celtic are not that good.. they may look better because they are playing in a poor league but some of them ratings would make them world beaters in the future
Muhamed Subasic bosnian NT player from Dynamo Dresden to Leuven (Belgium) to 2015.
Gonzalo Higuain from Real M. to Napoli to 2018.
yep
 
i am not see their attribute yet but i will make a suggestion to you


fernandinho
in my opinion his physic is standard but his mental should be high, he is one of the most intelligent player (creativity and flair must be one of his highest attribute). there is no special about his techninal except his great passing and long shot. his adaptability should be high too

jesus navas
his balance and acceleration should be very high 18+

negredo
despite his goalscoring chart last season with 25 goal, he is not an effective goalscorer, when creating a goal he need more shot than another goalscorer. so i think his finishing should be around 14-15. but his first touch should be higher
 
I put the olympic stadium thing in billy. I did take account for rent as best i could, it was tricky ... i know i did something cant remember tho as it was a couple of months ago :)
 
mate thank you for the transfer update... HOWEVER i wanted to manage Panathinaikos and you havent done the new transfer, could you pay more attention in greek superleague please? THANKS AGAIN, FOR YOUR NEW UPDATE, I KNOW YOU WORK HARD
 
When can we expect the update marshall?
it was released this morning
i am not see their attribute yet but i will make a suggestion to you


fernandinho
in my opinion his physic is standard but his mental should be high, he is one of the most intelligent player (creativity and flair must be one of his highest attribute). there is no special about his techninal except his great passing and long shot. his adaptability should be high too

jesus navas
his balance and acceleration should be very high 18+

negredo
despite his goalscoring chart last season with 25 goal, he is not an effective goalscorer, when creating a goal he need more shot than another goalscorer. so i think his finishing should be around 14-15. but his first touch should be higher
ill have a look
I put the olympic stadium thing in billy. I did take account for rent as best i could, it was tricky ... i know i did something cant remember tho as it was a couple of months ago :)
I added the olympic stadium in ages ago, i just didnt do anything to the finances
mate thank you for the transfer update... HOWEVER i wanted to manage Panathinaikos and you havent done the new transfer, could you pay more attention in greek superleague please? THANKS AGAIN, FOR YOUR NEW UPDATE, I KNOW YOU WORK HARD
Greek superleague wont be done fully, but if you suggest certain things in here ill look at them
 
Jose Bosingwa in Trabzonspor to 2016 (Florent Malouda in Trabzonspor too)
 
Yeah man, if you know anything about Celtic you would say yourself. We're an outstanding team with good youth prospects coming through, is it so bad to want the game to mirror that? Every year I find myself having to update the database to match what we're REALLY like, so frustrating!

well think yourself lucky i support Portsmouth and would love to do a successful fun pompey save but guess what i cant as even tho were in a safe financial situation now and out of admin the game thinks no and there is no way to get us out of this quickly even with the editor and for first few months cant buy anyone and can only offer frees £90 so i think you should be happy with what you got :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top