MAN UTD VS LIVERPOOL- discuss here

[Scott]

for JP sake and 19-11-08 and the rest. any liverpool utd discussion here please.

i start one, i think that all of liverpools defenders would strugge to get into utds defence

 

[19-11-08]

I agree. about the liverpool defenders.

 

[Billy]

You don't think Glen Johnson would make it into your starting defense?

 

[Jeffers]

Other than Glen Johnson i agree

 

[19-11-08]

I forgot about him. i guess. maybe. if wes brown was fit and in the form of his 2007-08 season i would not take him but he isn't.

 

[Scott]

nah, johnson cant defend

 

[Max]

Johnson can't defend? Evra can't defend, all he does is attack, so with your theory, you need a new LB

 

[Jeffers]

nah, johnson cant defend

I prefer him at the moment to Brown, Neville or Rafael

 

[Max]

Johnson is twice the player of Neville or Brown, brings something different to the team

 

[Scott]

Johnson can't defend? Evra can't defend, all he does is attack, so with your theory, you need a new LB

hang on evra can defend, very well thank you. he is the best LB in the world

 

[19-11-08]

Johnson can't defend? Evra can't defend, all he does is attack, so with your theory, you need a new LB

Evra can defend. he was immense today. lennon did nowt. excorcised the demons of last year when getting beat by lennon became a hobby for evra.

this thread was a good idea.

 

[Billy]

Currently, I'd also rate Johnson above Brown.

Definitely rate Ferdinand, Vidic and Evra above Carragher, Skrtel and Insua though.

Midfield-wise, hard to compare them, as usually United will field a team including wingers, whereas Liverpool seem to play through the middle, far more centrally.

Forwards? United, purely because Torres doesn't have any real back-up or help.

 

[Scott]

yh, i think liverpools CM are better then utd, but wingers utd are better

 

[Max]

Tbh all this thread is about is so 19-11-08 and scott can boast and brag and have a go every single person that says something against United

 

[Jeffers]

Tbh all this thread is about is so 19-11-08 and scott can boast and brag and have a go every single person that says something against United

No, it's so that they don't interrupt every thread arguing with Liverpool fans

 

[Scott]

not at all, this is because JP sed tht everthing turns into an liverpool, utd argument, so i thought tht it might be a good idea to make a thread, so everythead isnt turned around into a utd liverpool argument. and this is a discussion/debate not attacking people

 

[Anlaby7Hull]

Reina-Vds-Reina better
Johnson-Brown-Johnson better
Aurelio-Evra-Evra better
Carragher-Vidic-Vidic better
Skrtel-Ferdinand-Ferdinand better
Benayoun-Giggs-Benayoun better(now)
Riera-Nani-Nani better
Gerrard-Fletcher-Gerrard better
Mascherano-Anderson-Mascherano better
Torres-Rooney-Torres better
Owen-Voronin-Owen better
Liverpool 6-5 Man Utd

 

[Frank]

not at all, this is because JP sed tht everthing turns into an liverpool, utd argument, so i thought tht it might be a good idea to make a thread, so everythead isnt turned around into a utd liverpool argument. and this is a discussion/debate not attacking people

all uve been doing all day is causing arguments on the forums

 

[19-11-08]

Tbh all this thread is about is so 19-11-08 and scott can boast and brag and have a go every single person that says something against United

When have i ever boasted or bragged?

I defend my team like every other football fan but as i support united who everyone hates i end up defending them a lot.

 

[Scott]

Reina-Vds-Reina better
Johnson-Brown-Johnson better
Aurelio-Evra-Evra better
Carragher-Vidic-Vidic better
Skrtel-Ferdinand-Ferdinand better
Benayoun-Giggs-Benayoun better(now)
Riera-Nani-Nani better
Gerrard-Fletcher-Gerrard better
Mascherano-Anderson-Mascherano better
Torres-Rooney-Torres better
Owen-Voronin-Owen better
Liverpool 6-5 Man Utd

even if i agrred with them, which i dont, how about utd other 13 players good enough for league title, liverpool NOT