Most overated player?

  • Thread starter Thread starter francis999
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 72
  • Views Views 8K
i completely disagree with that.. carragher is one of liverpool's star players aswell.
knowing carragher he will die for liverpool just shows you how important he is to liverpool

its like man utd..without rio ferdinand man utd wouldnt be as good they are.
 
Gatid said:
i completely disagree with that.. carragher is one of liverpool's star players aswell.
knowing carragher he will die for liverpool just shows you how important he is to liverpool

its like man utd..without rio ferdinand man utd wouldnt be as good they are.
Click to expand...

Mhmm, I somewhat agree.. My view on Carragher is that his heart makes him a better player than he would be if say, he wasnt so passionate about L'Pool.

He is Pool through and through, which I admire a lot, but he isn't the World Class Player standard that Gerrard and Torres fit.
 
Cardozo and an old San Marino striker i found, his finishing was like 17 and his stats were good but in real life San Marino play worse than someone with one leg
 
IRL Wayne Rooney is massively overrated. Ronaldo is 10 times better (I'm saying this through gritted teeth). The commentators go on as if he is as good as Ronaldo whereas he is knowhere near him. I cannot believe people are saying Gerrard is overrated. He is the best central midfielder in the world (BTW Zinedine Zidane went one better than me, he said he was the best player in the world). Anyway he has everything passing, tackling, long shots, heading and he has played in every position for Liverpool except in goal, and oh I nearly forgot he is probably the most passionate player in the world.

On the game it's between Srna, Cardozo, Palombo and Mandanda.

---------- Post added at 12:37 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:33 PM ----------

Milen1234 said:
nobody thinks Leiva's good

havent u heard him being boo'd by liverpool fans at anfield during announcements

---------- Post added at 09:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:44 PM ----------




It's a fair point.

Gerrard and Torres could play for the best teams in the world where as the rest of the liverpool squad bar a few players like mascherano, alonso and carragher are standard of teams from around 4th-7th in the premiership
Click to expand...

Oh and that's why Real Madrid want Alonso? Mascherano is one of the best holding midfielders in the world and Carragher is the heart of our defence.

Any yeah Lucas is absolutely diabolical although he weren't bad against United.

---------- Post added at 12:40 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:37 PM ----------

AndyCoates said:
I'd totally disagree, even as a ManUTD fan, I'd be lying if I said I didn't enjoy watching Gerrard play, on form... he dominates the field and is the heart and sole of a team that without him, would "sink without a trace".

Liverpool - Gerrard - Torres = Not the force they are.

I'd expect some liverpool fans to disagree with that statement, but I'm sure I dont stand alone in saying Liverpools two top players are LEAGUES above the rest of the team.
Click to expand...

I'm a red an I don't disagree. I don't think we would be the team we are without Gerrard. But we were a top 4 team without Torres! I hate people saying we are a two man team though. That must mean United are a one man team?!?
 
Oh and that's why Real Madrid want Alonso? Mascherano is one of the best holding midfielders in the world and Carragher is the heart of our defence.

Any yeah Lucas is absolutely diabolical although he weren't bad against United.
Click to expand...

Hes bad in all matches!!
 
I'm a red an I don't disagree. I don't think we would be the team we are without Gerrard. But we were a top 4 team without Torres! I hate people saying we are a two man team though. That must mean United are a one man team?!?[/quote]


You cant sayin man u rely on ronaldo as much as liverpool rely on torres and gerrard. Although ronaldo is a great player that doesnt mean man u wouldnt be top of league without him.

Oh and gerrard is a world class player and is definatley not overrated... how many times has he saved liverpool? He would walk into every team in the world and that is coming from a UNITED fan.
 
roque santa cruz is a bit too much on FM09 i think,
that is if man city dont sign him for 25 million and play him once a season
blackburn just havent got the service for him
and he still gets 30 a season
ridiculous.
 
Riquelme, Zhirkov, Vilar and Rivaldo are also overrated
 
Coming from a benfica supporter.. Cardozo

And Miguel Veloso, he is like wtf?!
 
Milen1234 said:
nobody thinks Leiva's good

havent u heard him being boo'd by liverpool fans at anfield during announcements

---------- Post added at 09:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:44 PM ----------




It's a fair point.

Gerrard and Torres could play for the best teams in the world where as the rest of the liverpool squad bar a few players like mascherano, alonso and carragher are standard of teams from around 4th-7th in the premiership
Click to expand...

man mascherano is an awesome destroyer from what Ive seen and alonso plays the ball incredibly for me they're top 4 too.
Most overrated is Van der Vaart, a killing machine in the game and poor son of a b... irl and the wagner love thingy in 9.3 is funny, guy is in CSKA moscow, there are not even rumors about him going to a good team, a joke.
 
Didier Drogba... the only stats he should have are diving and crying to mum about getting bumped
 
vagner love

irl he wouldnt score 20+ goals in the EPL


definitely agree with mufc4life
 
I don't get this, Dzagoevs meant to be a wonderkid but his freaking stats are insane for someone who has only been playing competitive football for around 2 years he was miles better than my best attacking midfielder.....

Also, Rivaldo, fernando morientes,Pavluyuchenko,Pogbrenyak,Srna,Olic,Lugano are too overrated
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top