My Huge Tactics Testing Project!!!

  • Thread starter Thread starter a_ilfandy
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 249
  • Views Views 81K
what do you guys think about expanding this project a bit? i mean,if the reason of this forum is finding the best tactic,then we should all test the tactics and report the flaws and the good things about the tactics.What i mean is something just as like what happens in the challenges section. For example, it's decided that Man City(sufficient budget to adapt to any tactic and stronger league in the game) will be the team that we'all are going to use.So,we choose the 10(just example,can me more or less tactics) best tactics here and 3 users will test each tactic for 3 seasons.After each season a report must be made of the good things about the tactic,the bad things,the achievments and the players status at the end of it.Of course that dates will be decided to deliver the reports of the seasons and stuff,for the project to work well.

What do you guys think about this idea?
 
lipecamara said:
what do you guys think about expanding this project a bit? i mean,if the reason of this forum is finding the best tactic,then we should all test the tactics and report the flaws and the good things about the tactics.What i mean is something just as like what happens in the challenges section. For example, it's decided that Man City(sufficient budget to adapt to any tactic and stronger league in the game) will be the team that we'all are going to use.So,we choose the 10(just example,can me more or less tactics) best tactics here and 3 users will test each tactic for 3 seasons.After each season a report must be made of the good things about the tactic,the bad things,the achievments and the players status at the end of it.Of course that dates will be decided to deliver the reports of the seasons and stuff,for the project to work well.

What do you guys think about this idea?
Click to expand...

you got some good points there.. however its not going to be easy to find others who are willing to commit to such project.. its the end of the season for FM 11.. but if there are others willing to do this, then count me in..
 
a_ilfandy said:
you got some good points there.. however its not going to be easy to find others who are willing to commit to such project.. its the end of the season for FM 11.. but if there are others willing to do this, then count me in..
Click to expand...

well,i don't think i've made myself clear enough(i'm not THAT GOOD IN ENGLISH,so i may have been ambiguous),because my idea isn't that everyone test ALL THE TACTICS,is that one person test one tactic for 3 seasons,but 3 different persons for each tactic,so that the results would be more realistic.Therefor,it would be like this(example):

TEAM: "X"

Tactic 1: Three spots,who want to test this one?
Tactic 2: Three spots,who want to test this one?
.....

Kinda like what was done with this challenge here:http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/fm-challenges/60372-blue-square-north-south-champions-league.html

So,do you accept the challenge?
 
my english is not good either but I got what you mean.. loud and clear..
it just that we have to convince people to participate.. at this time, it wont be easy.. we need AT LEAST 3 participants..
and as I said, if others say YES, I'm ready to go!

---------- Post added at 02:29 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:27 PM ----------

and I'll stop my project for this bigger challenge..
as long as people participating and looking serious about it..
 
what stage are we at with this mate? I'd wanna help out but i just cant commit to it
 
continue with your original plan mate, this version the other member suggested is way todrawn out for most of the members here, you will be lucky if you get 1 tester per tactic! trust me....
 
I ran the test TWICE, and somehow the game crashed and closed after about 5-6 matches..
what the heck?? it happened twice.. anyway, i gave my laptop to a friend to check it out..
dunno if the game is too heavy to run 8 teams in 4 leagues..
anyway i still have the other save game for tactics testing (4 teams in 4 leagues)..
if its still not working, i will just run it with that save data..
 
Hi guys. I'm back.. sorry for the wait..
Now, due to some problems I decided to change the plan a bit..
the test is running for 6 tactics, 6 teams in 3 leagues..

Here, take a look..

GOALS GALORE VS IL DEVASTO

osyXx.jpg


MR HOUGH VS RAIKAN

germr.jpg


JP WOODY VS LAFFLES

20YGu.jpg


PS: REFER TO FIRST PAGE FOR CURRENT STANDING!
 
Harriers09 said:
I cry at being dropped :'(
Click to expand...

sorry mate, i ran yours vs Brobs' in ligue 1 before, but the game crashed TWICE..
so i made it 3 leagues only.. dont worry this season will finish in no time..
3 tactics will be out, then yours, Brobs, and xenon are in..
sorry again..

---------- Post added at 01:17 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:59 AM ----------

Champ Leagues Update: after 5 games.

Inter (1st, 15 points)
Milan (1st, 13 points)
man utd (2nd, 7 points)
Chelsea (1st, 13 points) and Madrid (2nd, 8 points) they are in the same group!
barca (2nd, 11 points)

Screenshots coming soon after 6 games!

---------- Post added 05/08/2011 at 10:24 AM ---------- Previous post was 04/08/2011 at 01:17 PM ----------

LATEST UPDATE (30 january 2011)

GOALS GALORE VS IL DEVASTO

yBCN7.jpg


MR HOUGH VS RAIKAN

Am1Ki.jpg


JP WOODY VS LAFFLES

cSh1a.jpg


CHAMP LEAGUE 2ND ROUND MATCH UP!

6LZi4.jpg


CHECK ON THE FIRST PAGE FOR THE SUMMARY!
 
Nice work to still stick with this. Have a feeling that Il Devastato is still going to come out on top :)
 
Steve* said:
Nice work to still stick with this. Have a feeling that Il Devastato is still going to come out on top :)
Click to expand...

Thanks. I just hope people will follow this, if not, no point of sharing..
yeah, il devasto is doing really good, goals galore dump it out of league cup..
il devasto fight back by dumping goals galore from the fa cup..
I'm glad i put these two on the same league..

---------- Post added at 11:33 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:46 AM ----------
.
.
<<< I WILL BE BACK ON MONDAY POSTING THE FINAL STANDING, BY THEN THE NEW TESTING SEASON ALREADY STARTED, 3 LOSING TACTICS OUT, 3 NEW TACTICS IN (BROBS, XENON, HARRIERS) >>>
.
.
 
yeah me too! got really good goal difference on my tactic :) nice!

this has been bookmarked, good job chief!

would be happy with top 3 :)
 
This looks like a good post, are these tactics being played against eachother manually or holidayed?
 
FIRST RUN COMPLETED! CONGRATULATIONS!

WINNERS: LAFFLES, MR HOUGH, IL DEVASTO
LOSE AND OUT: GOALS GALORE, JP WOODY, RAIKAN

MAN UTD (IL DEVASTO, 1ST) 38 games (27-7-4) goals (115-40) 88 points
CHELSEA (GOALS GALORE, 2ND) 38 games (24-5-9) goals (78-36) 77 points

BARCELONA (MR HOUGH, 1ST) 38 games (30-3-5) goals (103-22) 93 points
R.MADRID (RAIKAN, 2ND) 38 games (26-9-3) goals (102-27) 87 points

INTER (LAFFLES, 1ST) 38 games (32-2-4) goals (96-33) 98 points
MILAN (JP WOODY, 2ND) 38 games (23-9-6) goals (70-40) 78 points

CHAMP CUP: BARCELONA (MR HOUGH)

vyam9.png



NEXT TESTING LINE UP:

LAFFLES (CHELSEA) VS HARRIERS (MAN UTD)
IL DEVASTO (MADRID) VS XENON (BARCA)
MR HOUGH (MILAN) VS BROBS (INTER)

CHECK ON THE FIRST PAGE FOR DETAIL SUMMARY AND NEXT TESTING!!!
.
.
.
 
honestly suprised my tac did so well with Inter, seeing as its vastly winger based and inter have no true quality down the wings :L

and then you put me at Chelsea who dont have great wingers either.

Its cause my Tactic owns ;)
 
Interesting thread! Be good to see how mine does against Il Devasto. Looking forward to seeing results.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top