The Deal or No Deal Fm13 thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Raikan007
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 2K
  • Views Views 409K
Player: Nani
Team you are managing: Spurs
Team who are buying/selling: United
Offer: 18M quid
Year: summer 2015, so he's 28
Other Info: I am thinking about rotating him with Alexis Sanchez on the right wing. However, I have also Raheem Sterling, who is a potential 5* according to my assistant (Gareth Bale is "only" 4* lol).
Loaning Sterling could be a good idea, as long as he plays regularly and has the chance to train in good facilities; btw I will only do this if Nani is good enough, so that's why I'm asking for advices.
Cheers.
 
Player: Falcao
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who are buying/selling: Atletico Madrid
Offer: 25.5 quid
Year: February 2013
Other Info: I currently have Podolski, Giroud and a young Fierro as my striking options. Podolski has just been below par compared to Giroud. Would loan out Fierro, as I'm positive I can't give enough game time for him and keep Giroud as 2nd choice.
 
Oscar is transfer listed in just going into my 3rd season I am currently fourth with. 10 games left in 2nd season with Blackpool I really want him but he doesn't want to come shall I try after I get Ucl?
 
Player: David Santon
Team you are managing: Mancheter United
Team who are selling: Newcastle
Offer: 14M (4.8 Initial, 7 over 4 years, 2.2 after 50 apps )
Year: July 2012
Other Info: Has half a star better in potential rating from a 20-20 scout. This is after scouting them both three or four times. I'm reluctant to train Phil Jones, or Smalling to RB and need a good challenger for Rafael there.

OR

Player: Danilo
Team you are managing: Mancheter United
Team who are selling: FC Porto
Offer: 19.5M (7.5 Initial, 9.5 over 4 years, 2.5 after 50 gols )
Year: July 2012
Other Info: Has half a star worse in potential rating from a 20-20 scout. This is after scouting them both three or four times. Obviously a bit more pricey but I think I conned Porto a bit with the 2.5M clause after 50 goals. If he had a long career then maybe his high long-shots could wipe the smile off my face but I have a feeling he can turn out better than Santon.

Decision?
 
Oozora Tsubasa said:
Player: David Santon
Team you are managing: Mancheter United
Team who are selling: Newcastle
Offer: 14M (4.8 Initial, 7 over 4 years, 2.2 after 50 apps )
Year: July 2012
Other Info: Has half a star better in potential rating from a 20-20 scout. This is after scouting them both three or four times. I'm reluctant to train Phil Jones, or Smalling to RB and need a good challenger for Rafael there.

OR

Player: Danilo
Team you are managing: Mancheter United
Team who are selling: FC Porto
Offer: 19.5M (7.5 Initial, 9.5 over 4 years, 2.5 after 50 gols )
Year: July 2012
Other Info: Has half a star worse in potential rating from a 20-20 scout. This is after scouting them both three or four times. Obviously a bit more pricey but I think I conned Porto a bit with the 2.5M clause after 50 goals. If he had a long career then maybe his high long-shots could wipe the smile off my face but I have a feeling he can turn out better than Santon.

Decision?
Click to expand...

I would say deal for Santon, but bear in mind that Danilo is much more offensive than the Italian (who can play both right of left indifferently).
 
DarklinkCL said:
Player: Nani
Team you are managing: Spurs
Team who are buying/selling: United
Offer: 18M quid
Year: summer 2015, so he's 28
Other Info: I am thinking about rotating him with Alexis Sanchez on the right wing. However, I have also Raheem Sterling, who is a potential 5* according to my assistant (Gareth Bale is "only" 4* lol).
Loaning Sterling could be a good idea, as long as he plays regularly and has the chance to train in good facilities; btw I will only do this if Nani is good enough, so that's why I'm asking for advices.
Cheers.
Click to expand...

No deal for me. I think £18 mil is too much to pay for a 28 year old, and if you've already got Bale, Sterling and Sanchez, another wide man isn't a priority in my opinion. Nani is hardly a 'world class' player at United now, supposedly at the peak of his career, so I don't think he'd be worth a gamble at 28. I reckon it would be a bit of a waste of money.
 
Had an offer for Reina in my second season of 15m and i have Ospina as my second choice, would anyone do the deal?
 
I'm Liverpool..
have okore, coates, agger and skrtel for cb and sw roles.
been offered subotic in first season for 13mill?
should I buy him to replace skrtel or agger?
I compared them and subotic is better than both physically and aerially
 
jonesbilly194 said:
I'm Liverpool..
have okore, coates, agger and skrtel for cb and sw roles.
been offered subotic in first season for 13mill?
should I buy him to replace skrtel or agger?
I compared them and subotic is better than both physically and aerially
Click to expand...

What is your overall transfer budget? I personally tend to only buy players for more than £5 million, who are old enough to make a short-term contribution to the first team, if there is an obvious need for them in the squad. That's either in terms of a lack of depth, or that a player you have blatantly isn't good enough and needs to be got rid of. I think Skrtel and Agger are actually a pretty solid pairing, both at their peak for a defender, so I would look to stick with them.

I think Subotic is a slightly better defender than those two, but by signing him, you'll disrupt the balance of the squad. Because either you'll have 5 centre-backs who will want to be in the first team, unsettling the players in that position, or you'll have to transfer list one of them, which can create problems. I think either of those two options would damage the morale of your team so much, that the increase in quality you'd get by signing Subotic (and for a respectable price I suppose at £13 million) wouldn't quite be worth it. So if it was me, I'd stick with Agger and Skrtel. Hope that helps mate.
 
Im A.C Milan, Got offered £25mil for El Sharaawy. Im heading into my 3rd season.... Sell or keep?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top