The Deal or No Deal Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lee
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 3K
  • Views Views 409K
LuisPedroWWE said:
Player: Riccardo Montolivo
Team I'm managing: Man City
Team who is selling: Fiorentina
Price: 33M

Player: Nuri Sahin
Team who is selling: Borussia Dortmund
Price: Loan (free)

Player: Paulo Henrique
Team who is selling: Santos
Price: 20M

Player: Vagner Love
Team who's selling: CSKA
Price 20M

Player: Giuseppe Rossi
Team who is selling: Vilarreal
Price: 22M


Second year BTW
Click to expand...

Deal for Sahin, Paulo and Rossi. No deal for the rest.
 
get Seydou Doumbia - CSKA, you can get Vagner for a lot less than that usually mate :) I take it your are City? :)
 
Player: Eden Hazard
Team who I'm managing: Chelsea
Team selling: LOSC Lille Metropole
Fee: 7.5m Euros

Player: Neymar
Team who I'm managing: Chelsea
Team selling: Santos FC
Fee: 17.5m Euros

Player: Javier Pastore
Team who I'm managing: Chelsea
Team selling: Palermo
Fee: 15.25m Euros


Fair deals for all of them?
 
Javier Mascherano
Barca (Me) ------------> Arsenal $35.75M
He is in my opinion the best anchorman in the game. I don't need the money but I do have Busquets if I do sell him.


For the above, I'd buy Hazard and use him as a left winger, Pastore to replace Lampard, but I don't know if Neymar and Torres is the best pair up front. Maybe instead get Babacar or Lukaku or even Wickham.
 
ninad_chelsea009 said:
Player: Eden Hazard
Team who I'm managing: Chelsea
Team selling: LOSC Lille Metropole
Fee: 7.5m Euros

Player: Neymar
Team who I'm managing: Chelsea
Team selling: Santos FC
Fee: 17.5m Euros

Player: Javier Pastore
Team who I'm managing: Chelsea
Team selling: Palermo
Fee: 15.25m Euros


Fair deals for all of them?
Click to expand...

Deal for all but beware of their asking wages and signing fees.
 
BuzzLIte said:
Javier Mascherano
Barca (Me) ------------> Arsenal $35.75M
He is in my opinion the best anchorman in the game. I don't need the money but I do have Busquets if I do sell him.
Click to expand...

No deal. You don't need the money and he is one of the best in the game in that position. You'd only weaken your squad by selling him.
 
Which one is better for DR?

Player: Rafael
Team you are managing: At. Madrid
Team who are buying/selling: Man Utd
Offer: £13m
Year: 2011/12
Other Info: I had him for loan in past two seasons and he got avg. rating of 7,4 in my team. Now I can buy him.

or

Player: Tsotridis
Team you are managing: At. Madrid
Team who are buying/selling: Don't Remember
Offer: £6m
Year: 2011/12
Other Info: He has an avg. rating of 7,6 for past 2 seasons in his team.

Which one will perform better for my At. Madrid in DR role?
 
Player:Neymar
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are buying/selling: Barcelona (buying)
Offer:43 million
Year:aug 2012
Other Info: Currently banging them in left right and center for me,still 20 years old...
 
Player: Christian Eriksen
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are buying/selling: Ajax
Offer: £15 million
Year: 2010/2011
Other Info: I currently have him on loan, and the release clause is 15 million. He's getting great ratings, and bangs in goals for me.
 
hlsaktn said:
Which one is better for DR?

Player: Rafael
Team you are managing: At. Madrid
Team who are buying/selling: Man Utd
Offer: £13m
Year: 2011/12
Other Info: I had him for loan in past two seasons and he got avg. rating of 7,4 in my team. Now I can buy him.

or

Player: Tsotridis
Team you are managing: At. Madrid
Team who are buying/selling: Don't Remember
Offer: £6m
Year: 2011/12
Other Info: He has an avg. rating of 7,6 for past 2 seasons in his team.

Which one will perform better for my At. Madrid in DR role?
Click to expand...

Depends which has better attributes. For me I'd for got Rafael since he's most likely blended with your team mates by being their for 2 seasons. Even thought the price is more than double. But if you have concerns about finance then definetely go for option 2.

Nova91 said:
Player:Neymar
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are buying/selling: Barcelona (buying)
Offer:43 million
Year:aug 2012
Other Info: Currently banging them in left right and center for me,still 20 years old...
Click to expand...

No deal, if he's playing exceptionally well you don't need to sell him at all.

Chokopop said:
Player: Christian Eriksen
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are buying/selling: Ajax
Offer: £15 million
Year: 2010/2011
Other Info: I currently have him on loan, and the release clause is 15 million. He's getting great ratings, and bangs in goals for me.
Click to expand...

Try negotiate for about 13m. Otherwise if all else fails go for the 15m. Deal.
 
Last edited:
So, first season at Man City :) January tranfers. Need RB. Which is better?

Player: Darijo Srna
Team you are managing: Man City
Team who are selling: Schaktar
Offer: £15m
Year: 2010/11

Player: Philip Lahm
Team you are managing: Man City
Team who are selling: Bayern
Offer: £20m
Year: 2010/11
 
Player: lukaku
Team I'm managing: Man utd
Team who is selling: atc
Price: 12.5m
season:2012/13
Addition info:needing a good young(ish) striker that will develop into a excellent striker. (other suggestions would be nice). Also need a good young defender again to turn into an excellent defender...suggestions please?

---------- Post added at 04:40 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:37 PM ----------
klaudys said:
So, first season at Man City :) January tranfers. Need RB. Which is better?

Player: Darijo Srna
Team you are managing: Man City
Team who are selling: Schaktar
Offer: £15m
Year: 2010/11

Player: Philip Lahm
Team you are managing: Man City
Team who are selling: Bayern
Offer: £20m
Year: 2010/11
Click to expand...

philip lahm - deal. younger than srna and looks a little better on the stats
 
jameshankin said:
Player: lukaku
Team I'm managing: Man utd
Team who is selling: atc
Price: 12.5m
season:2012/13
Addition info:needing a good young(ish) striker that will develop into a excellent striker. (other suggestions would be nice). Also need a good young defender again to turn into an excellent defender...suggestions please?

---------- Post added at 04:40 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:37 PM ----------



philip lahm - deal. younger than srna and looks a little better on the stats
Click to expand...

i personally wouldn't buy Lukaku. I'd go for Kadlec or Sanogo who are cheaper or if you can go for Babacar, he turns out amazing
 
jameshankin said:
Player: lukaku
Team I'm managing: Man utd
Team who is selling: atc
Price: 12.5m
season:2012/13
Addition info:needing a good young(ish) striker that will develop into a excellent striker. (other suggestions would be nice). Also need a good young defender again to turn into an excellent defender...suggestions please?
Click to expand...

No deal, Lukaku isn't worth 12.5m, for that you can get better players.
I'd go for Sanago, he's amazing at the age of 20 in my game. Or Babacar if you can afford his price. As for the defender I'd get Galeano as he turns out amazing around 21.
 
Player: Rene Adler
Team I'm managing: West Brom
Team who is selling: Leverkusen
Price: free - end of contract
season:2011/2012 - january
Addition info: so i have Ochoa as GK ... my players think he is key ... i never had Adler as my GK but ive read that hes very good ... so should i sign him? here are both stats ...

Adler - 2shared - download adler.jpg

Ochoa - 2shared - download ochoa.jpg
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top