The Manchester United Thread

Bruce, Pallister, Stam, Silvestre, irwin, neville a fit brown when he was here i all rate over smalling, jones, rojo, rafael and evans. Yes we can sign quality cb's and players you plum.

You really are very thick. It's not FM where you can sign any player you want to but altering the editor. We tried to sign Benatia, Hummles, Vermaelen but they moved elsewhere for whatever reasons. Rating Silvestre over Rafael shows how much you know about players. Silvestre was decent at best.

Yeah now go on and list the players we could have signed, the world class CB.
 
You really are very thick. It's not FM where you can sign any player you want to but altering the editor. We tried to sign Benatia, Hummles, Vermaelen but they moved elsewhere for whatever reasons. Rating Silvestre over Rafael shows how much you know about players. Silvestre was decent at best.

Yeah now go on and list the players we could have signed, the world class CB.

I didn't rate silvestre over rafael but i probably rate him over smalling or current jones depends i'd have to look back on that one and what are you talking about mentioning fm? we just signed di maria yet i get blasted for saying we can sign some good defenders. ******* ****.
 
I though McNair looked good again. He should start next week. Smalling should get nowhere near 1st team again, sell in January. Carrick looked good, hopefully slot in along side blind unless we need him at centre back next week.
Still can't believe how far we have fallen since fergie left though. van gaal will get it right I think. Just need 2/3 strong exsperianced players in January, sell a few duds and keep playing these youngsters either from start or off bench when needed.
 
Midfield looked lost at times.

Seeing a lot of fans saying Fellaini had a good game. Personally I think he was behind the pace of the game. Ditto with Blind.
 
We could easily find cb's to a better standard compared to smalling and jones.

Seriously? Like who, exactly? Mangala was rumoured, but has been rather bad. Vermaelen is more injury-prone than Jones, and that is saying something. Benatia wanted CL football, and moved to Bayern. Hummels didn't want to leave Dortmund in the summer, neither was Dortmund ready to play ball. Pique would've never left Barca in the summer.

Just because there was world-class defenders present, doesn't mean we'll be able to get them. :\
 
Seriously? Like who, exactly? Mangala was rumoured, but has been rather bad. Vermaelen is more injury-prone than Jones, and that is saying something. Benatia wanted CL football, and moved to Bayern. Hummels didn't want to leave Dortmund in the summer, neither was Dortmund ready to play ball. Pique would've never left Barca in the summer.

Just because there was world-class defenders present, doesn't mean we'll be able to get them. :\

You must really rate the current ones we have, we could delve into the depths of eastern europe or south america and find a couple better.
 
Right bored of this: starting coming up with rational discussions or im removing posts. Or go join redcafe.

Jesus.
 
You must really rate the current ones we have, we could delve into the depths of eastern europe or south america and find a couple better.

Yes, I do. I rate Evans and Jones a lot, when and if they're not injured. Never have rated Smalling that much from the beginning. Rojo can be good. Blackett and McNair should already be backup quality, easily.

I'm pretty sure the reason we don't have 'another' CB atm is that 1. we've signed Rojo and 2. we're holding out for a truly WC center-back (a la Hummels) in the summer;; Plus, I don't think anyone (even LvG) would've expected injury crisis to be THIS bad..
 
Right bored of this: starting coming up with rational discussions or im removing posts. Or go join redcafe.

Jesus.

Ohh i'm sorry is not rating smalling, jones, evans and maybe rojo not rational. Have i called them derogatory names? personally insulted them? I'm stating like most united fans and neutrals that i think they aren't good enough maybe one or two can be but it remains to be seen.
 
Seriously? Like who, exactly? Mangala was rumoured, but has been rather bad. Vermaelen is more injury-prone than Jones, and that is saying something. Benatia wanted CL football, and moved to Bayern. Hummels didn't want to leave Dortmund in the summer, neither was Dortmund ready to play ball. Pique would've never left Barca in the summer.

Just because there was world-class defenders present, doesn't mean we'll be able to get them. :\

There are hardly any world class CBs and none of the top class CBs were available for us. It's like some posters are just trolling by repeating the same **** once every week.
 
Balanta from river plate is always a good signing on fm. seriously though, McNair with exsperianced cb like pique, Miranda. I'm sure with van gals knowledge of players through Europe he will have some ideas. We do need to start to put a run of wins together as Europe is a must if we are to really challenge again in the near future.
 
Whether he is past it or not shame vidic never showed more and looked past moyes and stayed, just his leadership alone would help in some games but how i long for the days of a pallister or stam in this side.
 
Midfield looked lost at times.

Seeing a lot of fans saying Fellaini had a good game. Personally I think he was behind the pace of the game. Ditto with Blind.
Our midfield was fine till went down to 10 men, Toure only came into game when that happened.
 
Whether he is past it or not shame vidic never showed more and looked past moyes and stayed, just his leadership alone would help in some games but how i long for the days of a pallister or stam in this side.
Vidic WTF! Have you watched Inter this season, he is a peno and mistake machine for them. Not to mention his regression as an all round defender. No thanks!
 
Our midfield was fine till went down to 10 men, Toure only came into game when that happened.

Our passing was wayward. I think we could have done more to get City on the back foot early on and there were opportunities. Yaya Toure and Fernando both started poorly and if not for more composure with the ball we could have got in the space behind.

Also it seems like we are trying to mould Januzaj into a Bale type winger when he's at his best linking up and getting about the pitch as a playmaker. He's slowing things down on the right hand side.
 
Vidic WTF! Have you watched Inter this season, he is a peno and mistake machine for them. Not to mention his regression as an all round defender. No thanks!

Yeah he has regressed alot like rio, same with jones and smalling tbh they had a spurt and then went backwards.
 
Our passing was wayward. I think we could have done more to get City on the back foot early on and there were opportunities. Yaya Toure and Fernando both started poorly and if not for more composure with the ball we could have got in the space behind.

Also it seems like we are trying to mould Januzaj into a Bale type winger when he's at his best linking up and getting about the pitch as a playmaker. He's slowing things down on the right hand side.

I agree, good chance today to start like a house on fire and get at them like newcastle and west ham did.
 
Ohh i'm sorry is not rating smalling, jones, evans and maybe rojo not rational. Have i called them derogatory names? personally insulted them? I'm stating like most united fans and neutrals that i think they aren't good enough maybe one or two can be but it remains to be seen.

Jesus christ you still havent figured it out. Its not about rating, its about adding more the discussion than just "lets find some randoms from south america like its FM" take that nonsense elsewhere
 
Back
Top