This. Some fans were trying to justify his loss to Villareal with "oh, he didn't have options on the bench". The amount of mediocrity being masked as "progress" is just hilarious to watch.
Also, I'm not so sure if him being in his last year would create uncertainties because
1. There are no big clubs that's knocking on his doorstep
2. He loves united and would probably be able to wait out an offer.
Ideally, I would've stalled any new contract talks until let's say, midway through the next season.
There's every chance we could be battling for top 4 midway through the season and If that's the case, he's failed and we need to move on.