Scouseinthehouse
Member
- Joined
- May 1, 2015
- Messages
- 22,458
- Reaction score
- 5,197
- Points
- 113
I think its blasphemy to have Ali in the same tier as Seaman. Never a more overrated keeper. Let alone Ederson and De Gea. Also, Ali clears all that you've mentioned and is in the upper echelons with Buffon/Neuer.And this Brighton goal is the reason why I rate Czech, Schmeichel and VdS above Alisson. I'd put him in the 2nd tier with the likes of De Gea, Ederson, Seaman.
I consider Seaman as a PL legend. It is hard to rank any players, goalkeepers especially, but as much as you count in pure talent ( on which Alisson is among the best), you need other perspective and those are accolades. When you add everything up, in my book, he's behind those three. A lot can change, but I feel he'll always have that one "stupid" moment in him. Risk/reward, I get it. That's why I like TAA so much. I feel he offers so much offensively that he can be excused some times in defense.I think its blasphemy to have Ali in the same tier as Seaman. Never a more overrated keeper. Let alone Ederson and De Gea. Also, Ali clears all that you've mentioned and is in the upper echelons with Buffon/Neuer.
My bet is that he wants and will be manager coming years in Saudis for some club. No need to say badly.Gareth Southgate ‘not understanding’ why Henderson got abuse and boos last night tells you all you need to know about Gareth Southgate.![]()
My bet is that he wants and will be manager coming years in Saudis for some club. No need to say badly.
Get that cash