The 'Rate my Photoshop work' Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Max
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 1K
  • Views Views 345K
strikerv9dutch said:
More of my recent work

AJAX.png


DosSantoscopy.png


Van.png
Click to expand...

Very good mate

View attachment 77156

Ratings please, and how to improve
 
hiphopahol101 said:
O.k instead of just giving a 2/10 how about some constructive critisism? How can it improve?
Click to expand...

Oh, I thought you said 'please rate'. Not 'please rate and give me some constructive criticism'. That being said I'm in an alright mood so I suppose I could throw a couple of things your way.

Firstly, I don't like the fact that you have the same render three times on the background, simply with different effects on each one. i.e. the different opacity on each and the 'mirrored effect'.

Secondly, there is a real lack of using the effects that Photoshop provides. Aside from moving the Opacity slider, I can't pick out many options that you have fiddled with to make this background much more than a couple of renders plastered on the stock of a crowd. Also, it is notable that on the largest render, his body just cuts off - that is seriously unattractive on a piece of photoshop work.
 
Redrup said:
Oh, I thought you said 'please rate'. Not 'please rate and give me some constructive criticism'. That being said I'm in an alright mood so I suppose I could throw a couple of things your way.

Firstly, I don't like the fact that you have the same render three times on the background, simply with different effects on each one. i.e. the different opacity on each and the 'mirrored effect'.

Secondly, there is a real lack of using the effects that Photoshop provides. Aside from moving the Opacity slider, I can't pick out many options that you have fiddled with to make this background much more than a couple of renders plastered on the stock of a crowd. Also, it is notable that on the largest render, his body just cuts off - that is seriously unattractive on a piece of photoshop work.
Click to expand...
Thanks and you are right there are no effects used. The casillas render cut of the picture(The crowd is the original(sp) Backround). I Agree with the biggest render not fitting in. I Regreted putting it there but it was too late to change.

Thanks anyway.
 
It looks good Mike and Rvp is my favourite player! (H)
 
first attempt... i know its not amazing... any ideas on how to improve it?? i try to follow tutorials but i get bored and just mess about with it in the end =/
 
Put this up on DA a while back, just found it on my dekstop computer, couldnt find any good renders so used this 3 times :/:
 
Mike said:
Took a big gamble on this I think. Not a great piece of art, but meh. Any ways I can improve it?

Click to expand...

5/10

jose22 said:
first attempt... i know its not amazing... any ideas on how to improve it?? i try to follow tutorials but i get bored and just mess about with it in the end =/
Click to expand...

2/10

Irish Scouse said:
Put this up on DA a while back, just found it on my dekstop computer, couldnt find any good renders so used this 3 times :/:
Click to expand...

7/10

Now don't take it personally if you don't get the response you wanted. After all I'm not amazing at this kind of stuff anyway.

I would provide further feedback but instead I will just say 'Use tutorials guys... Keep it up!'
 
hiphopahol101 said:
New WallPaper! Please Rate.
Click to expand...
This would be better if the Casillas wasn't the wrong way round. I understand why you've done it, but i think it ruins the overall effect imo. 4/10 for me. If the namewas the right way round then 8/10

---------- Post added at 11:44 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:42 PM ----------

Irish Scouse said:
Put this up on DA a while back, just found it on my dekstop computer, couldnt find any good renders so used this 3 times :/:
Click to expand...
really like this. Love the circles around "Javier" 9/10

---------- Post added at 11:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:44 PM ----------

Mike said:
Took a big gamble on this I think. Not a great piece of art, but meh. Any ways I can improve it?

Click to expand...
Good. Almost very good imo.
8/10 as it stands.
If the foreground pic of van persie was slightly larger, and faded a tiny bit i think this could be perfect.


By the way i am by no means a pro at photoshop, but i still like looking at others work.
 
Ratings for my signature please ..................

---------- Post added at 01:43 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:42 AM ----------

mjt12 said:
View attachment 78266

Ratings and constructive criticsm please.

It's basic I know
Click to expand...
A basic piece of work however I like the colour of the text and what you have done to the image
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top