The Rate My Tactic Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sam
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 102
  • Views Views 10K
Status
Not open for further replies.
ok, i will take the advice into account, and will do a proper report on these tactics, to help me out any1 want to sign up to rate these tactics

---------- Post added at 12:14 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:02 AM ----------

Anyone want to help me rate tactics ?
 
Shahzal said:
Well this is not the best tactic but its my first one on FM11 :)

Put these in the instructions -
Get ball forward
pass into space
work ball into box
push higher up

Thanks and please rate it out of 10 :)
Click to expand...




Dundee:
View attachment 115626

Hamilton:
View attachment 115627

Glentoran:
View attachment 115628

Crusaders:
View attachment 115629

Port Vale:
View attachment 115630

Crewe:
View attachment 115622

Rating:
8/10
Just to prove that using this tactic once doesnt work, this tactic was miles better as my players blended into it. To have success with this tactic you need good wing players which I had loads of with Taraabt, Cook, T. Smith and later on Verratti. Most of my goals came from the midfield due to this tactics only flaw, the striker play way to deeply causing them to be outside the area when a winger is putting a cross in. but as you can see from results, this is a great tactic
 
Last edited:
Results
View attachment 115637

Rating:
9/10
Cant really fault this tactic, except maybe not enough chances scored, but congrats on this tactic it is brilliant, should be top of downloads. You have to have a striker who can really finish too score more and a good amc to provide the goals. As you can see in results, great tactic
 
mkdmkdmkd said:
Dundee:
View attachment 115626

Hamilton:
View attachment 115627

Glentoran:
View attachment 115628

Crusaders:
View attachment 115629

Port Vale:
View attachment 115630

Crewe:
View attachment 115622

Rating:
8/10
Just to prove that using this tactic once doesnt work, this tactic was miles better as my players blended into it. To have success with this tactic you need good wing players which I had loads of with Taraabt, Cook, T. Smith and later on Verratti. Most of my goals came from the midfield due to this tactics only flaw, the striker play way to deeply causing them to be outside the area when a winger is putting a cross in. but as you can see from results, this is a great tactic
Click to expand...

Only the last attachment worked..

Anyways thanks for rating it mate! :D
Glad I got some feedback :)
 
mkdmkdmkd said:
Results
View attachment 115637

Rating:
9/10
Cant really fault this tactic, except maybe not enough chances scored, but congrats on this tactic it is brilliant, should be top of downloads. You have to have a striker who can really finish too score more and a good amc to provide the goals. As you can see in results, great tactic
Click to expand...
Who you talking to there? Maybe give a link to the tactic your rating so if people like the feedback they can download it.
 
Your The Counter Diamond Tactic, sorry really tired

---------- Post added at 02:32 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:31 AM ----------

mvp93 said:
Name of Tactic: Who needs Wingers
Acheivments with Tactic:League cup with chelsea, BSP,BSS,L2 champions L1 2nd place Championship playoff winners
Team played with:Woking and Chelsea
Instructions:N/A
Link:http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/downloads.php?do=file&id=3596
Click to expand...

I will test tonight and give feedback tomorrow m8
 
mkdmkdmkd said:
Dundee:
View attachment 115626

Hamilton:
View attachment 115627

Glentoran:
View attachment 115628

Crusaders:
View attachment 115629

Port Vale:
View attachment 115630

Crewe:
View attachment 115622

Rating:
8/10
Just to prove that using this tactic once doesnt work, this tactic was miles better as my players blended into it. To have success with this tactic you need good wing players which I had loads of with Taraabt, Cook, T. Smith and later on Verratti. Most of my goals came from the midfield due to this tactics only flaw, the striker play way to deeply causing them to be outside the area when a winger is putting a cross in. but as you can see from
results, this is a great tactic
Click to expand...

If you liked this tactic, link is here :
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=115453&d=1290901580

---------- Post added at 02:39 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:37 AM ----------

mkdmkdmkd said:
Results
View attachment 115637

Rating:
9/10
Cant really fault this tactic, except maybe not enough chances scored, but congrats on this tactic it is brilliant, should be top of downloads. You have to have a striker who can really finish too score more and a good amc to provide the goals. As you can see in results, great tactic
Click to expand...

If you liked this tactic link is here:
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=115463&d=1290904688

---------- Post added at 02:40 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:39 AM ----------

Stann said:
Still don't know who's tactic it was. Leaderboard maybe? Just thinking of ways to snazz it up..
Click to expand...

Would you like to help me test these tactics??

---------- Post added at 02:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:40 AM ----------

Anyone else want me to rate a tactic

---------- Post added at 06:05 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:46 AM ----------

Would anyone want to help me rate tactics
 
mvp93 said:
Name of Tactic: Who needs Wingers
Acheivments with Tactic:League cup with chelsea, BSP,BSS,L2 champions L1 2nd place Championship playoff winners
Team played with:Woking and Chelsea
Instructions:N/A
Link:http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/downloads.php?do=file&id=3596
Click to expand...

Results:

View attachment 115846

Rating:
5/10
I chose Blackpool for testing because I thought this tactic needed a bigger challenge, and as you can see from results I was gettin the results from friendlies but it was never satisfying. And in the Prem we couldnt put away enough chances and defence was poor, so not the best tactic
​
 
Mate i did suggest you should use a team with gd wing backs and a creative mid

but fanks anywayz
 
mvp93 said:
Mate i did suggest you should use a team with gd wing backs and a creative mid

but fanks anywayz
Click to expand...

lookin at stats i did, Charlie Adam: Creative Mid, Wing Backs: Maxwell signing and Atouba signing
 
I don't think after two premier league games you can make the assumption that the tactic is average. The tactic won't be perfect in your first few games but if you can see the results near the end will suggest how good the tactic used is.
 
I can't believe you sit there telling people their tactics are average without even testing them properly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top