The Rate My Tactic Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sam
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 102
  • Views Views 10K
Status
Not open for further replies.
Name of Tactic: The 4-4-2 Custom
Acheivments with Tactic: npower League 1 3rd place, and Playoff winners. (Have only played the one season so far, so see sig for results in other comps. They weren't too good as I fielded my reserve side for all 3! :))
Team played with: Southampton
Instructions: Get Ball Forward, Hassle Opponents, Work Ball into Box
Extra: This is a simple 4-4-2 formation, which should work well with any strong Championship/L1/L2 teams. Centre Halfs Defensive, Full Backs Auto, Centre Mids Support, Wingers Attack, Forwards Attack. Should be scoring plenty, but be sure to have 2 strong CB's on as they do all of the defensive work on they're own!
Link: http://www.filefront.com/17603554/4-4-2_Custom_(Southampton,_Jul_2010).tac

bit of a cue but will do in a bout half an hour
 
Give up on this thread, complete waste of time.
 
If you used Fabregas in the ACM role it'd would have worked so much better. You must've done something wrong tbh.

What team did you put out?
 
Almunia
Sagna Vermaalen Squillaci Clichy
Alex Song
Fabregas Nasri
Arshavin
Chamakh Santa Cruz (Signing)
 
a) You actually need a decent keeper.
b) Where is Robin van Persie?
c) Fabregas needs to be in the CAM role.
d) Arsenal have very good wingers. This formation would obviously not work for them.
e) You've got one of Fabregas or Nasri in the ball-winning midfielder role. That's going to work isn't it.

If you change those things, you'd get results.
 
a) You actually need a decent keeper.
b) Where is Robin van Persie?
c) Fabregas needs to be in the CAM role.
d) Arsenal have very good wingers. This formation would obviously not work for them.
e) You've got one of Fabregas or Nasri in the ball-winning midfielder role. That's going to work isn't it.

If you change those things, you'd get results.

right ok can i use spurs
 
Could work with Spurs, I suppose.

Gomes

Hutton/Corluka - Gallas - Dawson - BAE

Huddlestone

Palacios - Modric/VDV

VDV/Modric

Crouch - Defoe
Would work.​
 
Name of Tactic: Jack's 4-4-2 *the 4-4-2 at its very best*
Acheivments with Tactic: Finished 3rd first season with everton
Team played with: Everton
Instructions: Standard pitch, choose a team with a good strong target man who is good in the air
Link: attached as thumbnail, try and choose a mid table/ lower prem. not uploaded it to FM-BASE yet as i am still tweaking, just looking for some feedback
 
Name of Tactic: ParkThePlane 4-3-1-2 v2
Acheivments with Tactic: Sunderland reaching Europe in Season 1, Valencia winning La Liga, Inter Milan winning the treble.
Team played with: Sunderland, Valencia, Inter.
Link: http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/downloads.php?do=file&id=3412

Results:
View attachment 116998

Rating: 8/10
If every game was as good as the friendlies then it would get 10/10 but it wasnt we started to pick up form later in the test with good results against middle class teams which is good. Van Der Vaart really thrived under this Tactic, so people who use spurs get this tactic. Crouch didnt do to well in this tactic but he doesnt play well in any tactics so that didnt really matter to me. To get the best out of this tactic you need to have a Palacios or a Jon Obi Mikel so the ball wining instruction works( thats why arsenal didnt work)
 
Results:
View attachment 116998

Rating: 8/10
If every game was as good as the friendlies then it would get 10/10 but it wasnt we started to pick up form later in the test with good results against middle class teams which is good. Van Der Vaart really thrived under this Tactic, so people who use spurs get this tactic. Crouch didnt do to well in this tactic but he doesnt play well in any tactics so that didnt really matter to me. To get the best out of this tactic you need to have a Palacios or a Jon Obi Mikel so the ball wining instruction works( thats why arsenal didnt work)

You were coming 8th with tottenham, 8/10? i dont think so...
 
Any chance you can screenie the team you used?

And yeah, I don't think you're going to get much accuracy about how good a tactic is from a month.
 
I had to rush a bit cos of alot of requests but i feel results dont reflect how good it was, it was quite good, screenie comin soon
 
I am gonna close the thread because I don't have time to thoroughly test the tactic, and clearly I am not a tactical mastermind due to feedback if anyone wants to take on the idea of thread feel free :-)
 
You won't be satisfied mate I reallyam sorry but I couldn't do much but what I will say is it is a potentially good tactic just needs a few tweaks :-( sorry m8
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top