Literally? My word, I didn't know Ferguson had resorted to heavy artillery in order to win matches.
FM 2011 Worst version yet ?
- Thread starter maccaattack
- Start date
- Replies 69
- Views 7K
- Status
Literally? My word, I didn't know Ferguson had resorted to heavy artillery in order to win matches.
didn't win - i think Mike was reffering to 2005 FA cup final - most one sided 0-0 you'll ever see and arsenal won on pensLiterally? My word, I didn't know Ferguson had resorted to heavy artillery in order to win matches.
if that game had gone the way of United then Wenger would have won nothing since the unbeatable season
Dynamo_ZahnZee
Member
- Joined
- Jan 17, 2010
- Messages
- 4,043
- Reaction score
- 2
- Points
- 36
Why is FM11 being dificult a bad thing?
I've never once heard a professional managing in the real world say that his job is easy so personally applaud SI for getting the game bang on in this regard.
You say the game is all about stats. Yes and No.
While having players with decent stats is a key factor in how your season plays out, having the RIGHT players is far more important. A team of rejects who all fit into a working system, 9 time out of 10 (in my experience) will beat a group of world class players with completely contrasting styles of play.
I have invested 150-200 hours myself, and while alot of it has been far from fun (sometimes bring me to the verge of tears) that sense of satisfaction of lifting a trophy you worked hard for is what Football Manager is all about!
I've never once heard a professional managing in the real world say that his job is easy so personally applaud SI for getting the game bang on in this regard.
You say the game is all about stats. Yes and No.
While having players with decent stats is a key factor in how your season plays out, having the RIGHT players is far more important. A team of rejects who all fit into a working system, 9 time out of 10 (in my experience) will beat a group of world class players with completely contrasting styles of play.
I have invested 150-200 hours myself, and while alot of it has been far from fun (sometimes bring me to the verge of tears) that sense of satisfaction of lifting a trophy you worked hard for is what Football Manager is all about!
^^ As you can see I've posted on this subject before...
You say you analyse the stats, but you only talk about shots and target and missed 1v1's really, and then go on to moan about the number of eqaully easy chances that the AI puts away with aplomb.
Can i say I've rarely experienced this, sure every so often an average AI striker will have a stormer and my 20 million pound man will have a shocker (just like real life) but to say it's scripted is ridiculous.
In fact you say the game never used to be like this. Well until some of the later CM games, the game WAS actually scripted. The results were pre determined before kick off based on a calculation of stats, weather, form, and other variables. Once the game kicked off you were unable to influence the final result through substitutions or tactical changes. This has now changed, tactical changes substitutions, injuries, refereeing decisions etc etc all now have a dynamic effect during a match, so the game is now less scripted than ever before...
So many people are quick to blame the game rather than look at themselves.
You say you domiante the shots on target statistics, but have you considered the types of shot your players are taking? My Nan could take 100 shots and get 100 on target under the correct circumstances, but I'll bet my house she'll never score.
My advise to those who beleive that the game is rigged due to this 1v1 'problem' is to adapt the way they set up their teams.
There are many things to try:
1. Some people have found success by increasing the time wasting slider, not the intended use for it, but players seem to take more time over their 1v1 rather than blasting it straight at the keeper.
2. Tactical shouts like 'work ball into the box' help to reduce the sort of park football end to end breakaways that result in missed 1v1's
3. Try a slower tempo, with shorter passing, a patient build up with the ultimate goal of creating the type of chance that requires your striker to finish instinctively, rather than running on goal for a 1v1 where he has a lot of time to think about his shot and fluff it.
4. Try some PPM's, if the player is good enough you can asking him to lob the keeper. Other useful ones are go round the keeper, and place shots into corner of net.
5. Try using traditional wingers, get some crosses into the box and finish of some chances that way, rather than relying on 1v1's. And that doesn't mean headers either, Used correctly, wingers can create all sorts of different chances for your striker and themselves.
6. Take less long shots, i sense that you are probably taking too many meaningless long shots, which is distorting your shots on target statistics. Remember that telling a player to take long shots rarely doesn't mean he will. If his creative freedom slider is high he will ignore your instructions. Creative freedom is best used sparingly, and allowed to be high for only one or two players within the team.
There are many other things to try, but its 530am and my brain is fried.
Last edited:
This is definitely not the worst game. It's a good challenge and gets you thinking
Although I will admit that I fear the game could become stale over the next couple of years as they have added so much to it so you really need to ask yourself how much more can they possibly add to a game when they have less than a year to develop it. I'd even go as far as suggesting that they take a year off from releasing a new game and just release a patch that can be bought to update the current version, that way they can have 2 years to develop a game that can potentially be the best in terms of features and a lack of bugs. It's kind of the same scenario that games like PES and FIFA are in and I know alot of people are getting fed up with having to pay £40 each year for a game that has very little improvement from the previous year and alot more bugs
Although I will admit that I fear the game could become stale over the next couple of years as they have added so much to it so you really need to ask yourself how much more can they possibly add to a game when they have less than a year to develop it. I'd even go as far as suggesting that they take a year off from releasing a new game and just release a patch that can be bought to update the current version, that way they can have 2 years to develop a game that can potentially be the best in terms of features and a lack of bugs. It's kind of the same scenario that games like PES and FIFA are in and I know alot of people are getting fed up with having to pay £40 each year for a game that has very little improvement from the previous year and alot more bugs
safcstaples
Member
- Joined
- Dec 13, 2009
- Messages
- 65
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 6
personally fm 2008 was my favourite,but all the others have still been mint
maccaattack
Member
- Joined
- Jun 22, 2009
- Messages
- 73
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 6
You assume so much to suit your own arguments just like the rest of these fan boys. The long shots within FM games are a real pain when it comes to long shots, far to many which ever settings you choose. I did not or want tactic advise i would have used the tactics forum.. We can all pick a real game where the results are lucky for one side this happens and within the game I would expect it to happen as well but not as often as it does. SI have admitted the pre-set tactics are pretty much useless so if you want to play the game you need to come up with your own tactic if you want to win anything. I make my own tactics and will still do but its a lot harder when you cant trust the stats which the game is all about.
I think It's the most realistic by far, with the in depth tactics, player conversations, private chats. They managed to get rid of all the ****** corner bugs, which is a bonus.
I'm finding myself wanting to play if more due to how hard it has become, It's no longer just a walk in the park, you've got to pay full attention to what's going on with the team you're managing, or it can all go down the pan.
So, I'd say this is the best FM so far, but in my eyes they always do one better each year.
The game will become a lot more interesting if story's get brought back onto this site, and some more challenges that people can get stuck into.
I'm finding myself wanting to play if more due to how hard it has become, It's no longer just a walk in the park, you've got to pay full attention to what's going on with the team you're managing, or it can all go down the pan.
So, I'd say this is the best FM so far, but in my eyes they always do one better each year.
The game will become a lot more interesting if story's get brought back onto this site, and some more challenges that people can get stuck into.
So because some people actually like the game, thus having a different opinion than you, means they are fan boys? Brilliant argument... :S
That is not really supporting your argument that this is the worst CM/FM. If people like it, and many do ('fan boys' as you call them), then I can't be nearly as bad as you make it out to be.
Last edited:
BlackSamba
Member
- Joined
- Dec 15, 2010
- Messages
- 176
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 0
Boo Hoo, your just **** and your having a tantrum. Dominating matches and losing CAN happen knobby. Check the stats for last nights game Man citeh vrs everton....
Anyway, since when does playing CM back in the day constitute you having the ability to make a more respected opinion?
Pointless thread, why have we given it our time when he doesn't provide constructive criticism.
Average Joe
Member
- Joined
- May 25, 2009
- Messages
- 7,420
- Reaction score
- 13
- Points
- 38
To be fair its still the player that decides what hes doing in game, and theres hundreds of things that will affect his decision making. E.g distance from goal, clear line of sight, closeness of defenders. Thats all without taking into account PPMs, personality traits and his overall attributes.
If you want a player to do every kick you want, buy Fifa 11 and play manager mode and controll the team :S
I agree with the OP that this game of FM 2011 is disappointing, however not for his reasons.
1) Its not too hard, I have played games with Everton, Basingastoke and Aston Villa and had similar success that I normally have on older versions
2) The 3D match engine never bothers me, I never use it because I know its retarded, I use only commentary and 2D match when I focusing more during poor form patches.
i'm annoyed with this one because I think the new features have not added anything, and are just a hindernace. Things like
1) Player conversations are still retarded, most the time players get really upset over nothing, like they have PMT. the options you have are VERY limited meaning your responses are pretty much to cave in to what the player wants, or say I'm the manager **** off.
For example I drop a player to the reserves because he needs match fitness, he goes apeshit and in conversations I cannot say hes only their to gain match fitness.
Also its annoying on conversations you do reslove you keep having to have the same ******* conversation every other month that ends the same way to keep the player happy.
2) Press Conferences - No different to 2009, and I thought they were a gimmick then but there still here and only slightly improved.
It does affect morale but no drastically, and they are again repetitive as you always get asked the same questions.
Making the conferences far less frequent, or putting millions of different questions in, or stopping them all together will sort this
First thing I do on my FM save is make my assistant deal with Press Conferences.
And people stop defending the game for the sake of it, its not terrible but its been very frustrating the lack of progress, making me feel like were just playing EA sports games
1) Its not too hard, I have played games with Everton, Basingastoke and Aston Villa and had similar success that I normally have on older versions
2) The 3D match engine never bothers me, I never use it because I know its retarded, I use only commentary and 2D match when I focusing more during poor form patches.
i'm annoyed with this one because I think the new features have not added anything, and are just a hindernace. Things like
1) Player conversations are still retarded, most the time players get really upset over nothing, like they have PMT. the options you have are VERY limited meaning your responses are pretty much to cave in to what the player wants, or say I'm the manager **** off.
For example I drop a player to the reserves because he needs match fitness, he goes apeshit and in conversations I cannot say hes only their to gain match fitness.
Also its annoying on conversations you do reslove you keep having to have the same ******* conversation every other month that ends the same way to keep the player happy.
2) Press Conferences - No different to 2009, and I thought they were a gimmick then but there still here and only slightly improved.
It does affect morale but no drastically, and they are again repetitive as you always get asked the same questions.
Making the conferences far less frequent, or putting millions of different questions in, or stopping them all together will sort this
First thing I do on my FM save is make my assistant deal with Press Conferences.
And people stop defending the game for the sake of it, its not terrible but its been very frustrating the lack of progress, making me feel like were just playing EA sports games
i think this edition has lots of bugs from wht ive seen in these and other forums crash dumps etc but for me personaly ive had no problems with anything like tht,worse thing tht happened to me was when i installed lastest patch and me custom skin wouldnt show up but i soon fixed tht.
game play is much the same as last yrs version but the improvements to the 3D match view is ace,i agree it sometimes feels like the game is against you and your perform bad no matter wht but ussualy it can be down to something simple as 1 playa not being happy and it affecting the whole team which has a knock on effect to match day performance,its a matter of finding the right balance and if you put the effort in ull get the rewards.
only thing im not a fan off is the playa interaction which can be a bit tricky sometimes also having to talk to the press after and b4 each match but its a sim and its wht managers do in real life,but at the moment i let me *** man handle tht side a things ,as long as he has good motivation skills then i find it easy for him to do it.
so my answer would be is no this is far from being the worse Fm to date and agree with others tht CM4 is miles ahead on tht score for being the worse
game play is much the same as last yrs version but the improvements to the 3D match view is ace,i agree it sometimes feels like the game is against you and your perform bad no matter wht but ussualy it can be down to something simple as 1 playa not being happy and it affecting the whole team which has a knock on effect to match day performance,its a matter of finding the right balance and if you put the effort in ull get the rewards.
only thing im not a fan off is the playa interaction which can be a bit tricky sometimes also having to talk to the press after and b4 each match but its a sim and its wht managers do in real life,but at the moment i let me *** man handle tht side a things ,as long as he has good motivation skills then i find it easy for him to do it.
so my answer would be is no this is far from being the worse Fm to date and agree with others tht CM4 is miles ahead on tht score for being the worse
If you want to be taken seriously, you really should stop calling us all "fan boys". You're on a ****** football manager website, of course we're going to be fans. However, "fan boys" has a much more negative connotation, one of immaturity and blind faith. Very few here are like that. We acknowledge the faults within the game just as much as we defend it. I'll happily admit there are quite a few faults still inherent within the match engine, just as I will say that this is still the best CM/FM to date.
Have you considered you might just be rubbish? Honestly wouldn't put it past you.
Er... where did they admit that? Whilst I agree that pre-set tactics aren't going to be as useful as one you made yourself, it's because they're stock tactics. They're just a framework for you to base your team around and tweak. If you just use a pre-set tactic and expect it to work, you're asking for trouble.
You can trust the stats, IMO. There are anomalies, of course there are, but they're just outliers so you ignore them, just like with any set of data.
That is not really true. People just have short memories
IMO FM10 was worse than FM11 at release. Got crash dumps?
There are 3 of us at work playing FM11. One is them is a guy who doesn't really like football (why is he playing this game, who knows, odd I agree) and he doesn't bother much with tinkering with tactics or training much, and has won the quadruple with Spurs in his first season, going the whole season unbeaten. Now us other 2 chaps have obviously accused him of cheating and replaying matches, which he denies strenously. Luck? Or accidental discovery of good tactics? Lets put it this way the game doesn't seem to be "picking" on him.
- Status