Fm14 Deal or No Deal thread: Please use when asking if you should buy player x or y

Player: Luis Suarez
Managing: Barcelona
Team selling: Liverpool
Offer: 75 mil E
Year: 2015-16
Other: He handed a Transfer Request and now me and Real are going for him.
Not worth it, it's better to buy Mitrovic, Benteke or Volland.
 
Player: Luis Suarez
Managing: Liverpool
Team selling: Liverpool
Offer: £64 Million (£12.75 up front)
Year: 2015-16

Not sure whether to sell or not as he is now 28...
 
Player: Kevin Grosskreutz
Managing: Chelsea
Team selling: Dortmund
Offer: £21m
Year: 2013-14 July

Good mentals and versatility but worth this much?
 
Player: Michy Batshauyi
Managing: Chelsea
Team selling: Standard
Offer: £6.75
Year: 2013-14 July

OR

Player: Wilfried Bony
Managing: Chelsea
Team selling: Swansea
Offer: £17m
Year: 2013-14 July
 
Player: Theo Walcott
Managing: Arsenal
Team Buying: Man City
Offer - 35m
Year: January 2014

&

Player: Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain
Managing: Arsenal
Team Buying: Man City
Offer: 30m
Year: January 2014

I do have Alexis Sanchez at AMR but do I sell both Theo and the Ox? I might target James Rodriguez but on deadline day this might be tough.
 
Player: Emre Can
Managing: Southampton
Team Buying: Bayer Leverkusen
Offer: £6.5m
Year: January 2015
View attachment 357136

Player: Hector Herrera
Managing: Southampton
Team Buying: Porto
Offer: £7m
Year: January 2015
View attachment 357135

Player: Grant Xhaka
Managing: Southampton
Team Buying: Monchengladbach
Offer: £10m
Year: January 2015
View attachment 357134

All wages are between £30k and £50k, money not a problem, a quick reply would be great!
 
Player: Emre Can
Managing: Southampton
Team Buying: Bayer Leverkusen
Offer: £6.5m
Year: January 2015


Player: Hector Herrera
Managing: Southampton
Team Buying: Porto
Offer: £7m
Year: January 2015


Player: Grant Xhaka
Managing: Southampton
Team Buying: Monchengladbach
Offer: £10m
Year: January 2015


All wages are between £30k and £50k, money not a problem, a quick reply would be great!

No1:Can
No2:Xhaka
No3: Herrera
 
Player: James Rodriguez
Team you are managing: Arsenal F.C.
Team who are selling: AS Monaco
Offer:
£38m (a new minimum fee release clause that is there because of his new contract)
Year: June 2015

View attachment 355097
 
Player: Jesus Navas
Team you are managing: Roma AS
Team who are selling: Man City
Offer: 13 mil pounds - 9 mil upfront
Year: First summer transfer window
 
Player: Petr Cech
Team you are managing: Chelsea
Team who are buying/selling: Barcelona
Offer: £17M
Year: 2013/2014

Other Info: Been offered Casillias for £13.75M. Is Cech worth selling and bringing him in to replace him? or should I keep Cech.
 
Player: Petr Cech
Team you are managing: Chelsea
Team who are buying/selling: Barcelona
Offer: £17M
Year: 2013/2014

Other Info: Been offered Casillias for £13.75M. Is Cech worth selling and bringing him in to replace him? or should I keep Cech.

Is Courtois still on loan? If not sell Cech and don't get Casillas as Thibaut is a beast and is your first team starter for 10+ years.
 
Player: Alen Halilovic
Team you are managing:
Barcelona
Team who are selling:
PSG
Offer:
£32.5M [Updated: £27.5M now, but I don't have the money anyway, I'll try again at end season]
Year:
December 2017

That's the cheapest they go. Too much I suppose, but can I find another equally good player with same age?

Edit: Also this:

Player: Emre Can
Team you are managing:
Barcelona
Team who are selling:
Leverkusen
Offer: £19M [Updated: Gave up on him, I added some more leagues, I'll try to find better regens]
Year:
December 2017

He seems much better than my starting DMC Sven Bender, only exception being Mental, which can improve since he's 5 years younger.
 
Last edited:
Player: Alen Halilovic
Team you are managing:
Barcelona
Team who are selling:
PSG
Offer:
£32.5M
Year:
December 2017

That's the cheapest they go. Too much I suppose, but can I find another equally good player with same age?

dont buy dat niqqa, check out sume regen
 
Is Courtois still on loan? If not sell Cech and don't get Casillas as Thibaut is a beast and is your first team starter for 10+ years.

No I have Courtois back from loan I was thinking of rotating Courtois and Cech If I sell Cech and don't sign Casillas than I'm only left with Thibaut and Schwarzer
 
Player: Raphael Varane
Team you are managing: Chelsea
Team who are selling: Real Madrid

Offer: £38M

Year: 2013/2014


or

Player: William Carvalho
Team you are managing: Chelsea
Team who are selling: Sporting Lisbon

Offer: £15M

Year: 2013/2014
 
A lot of those players you tried buying are over priced to be honest

Has anyone got better deals for the following players on day 1?

Player: Fabricio Coloccini
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Roma
Offer: ?6.5m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Vernon Anita
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Liverpool
Offer: ?10.75m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Davide Santon
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Arsenal, Tottenham
Offer: ?15.0m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Yohan Cabaye
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: PSG
Offer: ?30.0m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Hatem Ben Arfa
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Man Utd
Offer: ?29.0m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Mike Williamson
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Crystal Palace
Offer: ?2.8m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Cheick Tiote
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Liverpool
Offer: ?3.8m + ?9.0m monthly installments
Year: 2013/14

Player: Gabriel Obertan
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Crystal Palace
Offer: ?6.0m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Jonas Guttierez
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Udinese
Offer: ?5.25m
Year: 2013/14

These are the only players I could get to sell - if you found any other outgoing deals possible I'd appreciate sharing the info!

Here is a list of deals I could agree for incoming players, looking for advice on them as well:

Player: Gaitan
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Benfica
Offer: ?6.5m (loyalty bonus and agent fee not included)
Year: 2013/14

Player: Sheamus Coleman
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Everton
Offer: ?8.5m (loyalty bonus and agent fee not included)
Year: 2013/14

Player: Nathaniel Clyne
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Southampton
Offer: ?13.0m (loyalty bonus and agent fee not included)
Year: 2013/14

Player: Jean-Marie Dongou
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Barcelona
Offer: ?3.3m + ?12.75m over 48 months + ?125k lb + ?625k af
Total 1st budget cost: ?6.09m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Kurt Zouma
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: ASSE
Offer: ?4.1m + ?13.25m over 48 months
Total 1st budget cost: ?6.25m (loyalty bonus and agent fee not included)
Year: 2013/14

Player: Ilsinho
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Shakhtar Donetsk
Offer: ?250k + ?1.2m over 48 months
Total 1st budget cost: ?450k (loyalty bonus and agent fee not included)
Year: 2013/14

Player: Mario Pugliese
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Atalanta
Offer: ?2.3m + ?5.5m over 48 months + ?15.5k lb
Total 1st budget cost: ?3.2m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Nicola Leali
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Juventus
Offer: ?1.5m + ?5.5m over 48 months + ?40.5k lb
Total 1st budget cost: ?2.42m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Eder Alvarez Balanta
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: River Plate
Offer: ?3.4m + ?11.25m over 48 months + ?300k lb + ?1.0m af
Total 1st budget cost: ?6.33m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Isaac Cuenca
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Barcelona
Offer: ?425k + ?1.7m over 48 months + ?425k lb + ?400k af
Total 1st budget cost: ?1.21m
Year: 2013/14
 
Player: Raphael Varane
Team you are managing: Chelsea
Team who are selling: Real Madrid

Offer: £38M

Year: 2013/2014


or

Player: William Carvalho
Team you are managing: Chelsea
Team who are selling: Sporting Lisbon

Offer: £15M

Year: 2013/2014

No deal for Varane. You can get him a lot cheaper. Signed him for 14m in first season. And Carvalho depends on what update your on. If LFC Marshall then definitely deal as he got a massive upgrade.
 
Deal on Varane, I would buy him everytime i can get him under 50m
 
Top