Fm14 Deal or No Deal thread: Please use when asking if you should buy player x or y

[daisuke]

Player: Luis Suarez
Managing: Barcelona
Team selling: Liverpool
Offer: 75 mil E
Year: 2015-16
Other: He handed a Transfer Request and now me and Real are going for him.

Not worth it, it's better to buy Mitrovic, Benteke or Volland.

 

[iamauser]

Player: Luis Suarez
Managing: Liverpool
Team selling: Liverpool
Offer: £64 Million (£12.75 up front)
Year: 2015-16

Not sure whether to sell or not as he is now 28...

 

[jdenzy]

What's he done for the club so far?

 

[louiscfc]

Player: Kevin Grosskreutz
Managing: Chelsea
Team selling: Dortmund
Offer: £21m
Year: 2013-14 July

Good mentals and versatility but worth this much?

 

[louiscfc]

Player: Michy Batshauyi
Managing: Chelsea
Team selling: Standard
Offer: £6.75
Year: 2013-14 July

OR

Player: Wilfried Bony
Managing: Chelsea
Team selling: Swansea
Offer: £17m
Year: 2013-14 July

 

[iArsenal11]

Player: Theo Walcott
Managing: Arsenal
Team Buying: Man City
Offer - 35m
Year: January 2014

&

Player: Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain
Managing: Arsenal
Team Buying: Man City
Offer: 30m
Year: January 2014

I do have Alexis Sanchez at AMR but do I sell both Theo and the Ox? I might target James Rodriguez but on deadline day this might be tough.

 

[SFolio]

Player: Emre Can
Managing: Southampton
Team Buying: Bayer Leverkusen
Offer: £6.5m
Year: January 2015
View attachment 357136

Player: Hector Herrera
Managing: Southampton
Team Buying: Porto
Offer: £7m
Year: January 2015
View attachment 357135

Player: Grant Xhaka
Managing: Southampton
Team Buying: Monchengladbach
Offer: £10m
Year: January 2015
View attachment 357134

All wages are between £30k and £50k, money not a problem, a quick reply would be great!

 

[damola3]

Player: Emre Can
Managing: Southampton
Team Buying: Bayer Leverkusen
Offer: £6.5m
Year: January 2015


Player: Hector Herrera
Managing: Southampton
Team Buying: Porto
Offer: £7m
Year: January 2015


Player: Grant Xhaka
Managing: Southampton
Team Buying: Monchengladbach
Offer: £10m
Year: January 2015


All wages are between £30k and £50k, money not a problem, a quick reply would be great!

No1:Can
No2:Xhaka
No3: Herrera

 

[Isildur58]

Player: James Rodriguez
Team you are managing: Arsenal F.C.
Team who are selling: AS Monaco
Offer: £38m (a new minimum fee release clause that is there because of his new contract)
Year: June 2015

View attachment 355097

 

[christianms95]

Player: Jesus Navas
Team you are managing: Roma AS
Team who are selling: Man City
Offer: 13 mil pounds - 9 mil upfront
Year: First summer transfer window

 

[hugochelsea]

Player: Petr Cech
Team you are managing: Chelsea
Team who are buying/selling: Barcelona
Offer: £17M
Year: 2013/2014

Other Info: Been offered Casillias for £13.75M. Is Cech worth selling and bringing him in to replace him? or should I keep Cech.

 

[MrKop18]

Yes cash in

 

[louiscfc]

Player: Petr Cech
Team you are managing: Chelsea
Team who are buying/selling: Barcelona
Offer: £17M
Year: 2013/2014

Other Info: Been offered Casillias for £13.75M. Is Cech worth selling and bringing him in to replace him? or should I keep Cech.

Is Courtois still on loan? If not sell Cech and don't get Casillas as Thibaut is a beast and is your first team starter for 10+ years.

 

[Prequel]

Player: Alen Halilovic
Team you are managing: Barcelona
Team who are selling: PSG
Offer: £32.5M [Updated: £27.5M now, but I don't have the money anyway, I'll try again at end season]
Year: December 2017

That's the cheapest they go. Too much I suppose, but can I find another equally good player with same age?

Edit: Also this:

Player: Emre Can
Team you are managing: Barcelona
Team who are selling: Leverkusen
Offer: £19M [Updated: Gave up on him, I added some more leagues, I'll try to find better regens]
Year: December 2017

He seems much better than my starting DMC Sven Bender, only exception being Mental, which can improve since he's 5 years younger.

 

[ghettoboy]

Player: Alen Halilovic
Team you are managing: Barcelona
Team who are selling: PSG
Offer: £32.5M
Year: December 2017

That's the cheapest they go. Too much I suppose, but can I find another equally good player with same age?

dont buy dat niqqa, check out sume regen

 

[hugochelsea]

Is Courtois still on loan? If not sell Cech and don't get Casillas as Thibaut is a beast and is your first team starter for 10+ years.

No I have Courtois back from loan I was thinking of rotating Courtois and Cech If I sell Cech and don't sign Casillas than I'm only left with Thibaut and Schwarzer

 

[hugochelsea]

Player: Raphael Varane
Team you are managing: Chelsea
Team who are selling: Real Madrid
Offer: £38M
Year: 2013/2014


or

Player: William Carvalho
Team you are managing: Chelsea
Team who are selling: Sporting Lisbon
Offer: £15M
Year: 2013/2014

 

[Will]

A lot of those players you tried buying are over priced to be honest

Has anyone got better deals for the following players on day 1?

Player: Fabricio Coloccini
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Roma
Offer: ?6.5m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Vernon Anita
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Liverpool
Offer: ?10.75m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Davide Santon
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Arsenal, Tottenham
Offer: ?15.0m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Yohan Cabaye
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: PSG
Offer: ?30.0m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Hatem Ben Arfa
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Man Utd
Offer: ?29.0m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Mike Williamson
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Crystal Palace
Offer: ?2.8m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Cheick Tiote
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Liverpool
Offer: ?3.8m + ?9.0m monthly installments
Year: 2013/14

Player: Gabriel Obertan
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Crystal Palace
Offer: ?6.0m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Jonas Guttierez
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Udinese
Offer: ?5.25m
Year: 2013/14

These are the only players I could get to sell - if you found any other outgoing deals possible I'd appreciate sharing the info!

Here is a list of deals I could agree for incoming players, looking for advice on them as well:

Player: Gaitan
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Benfica
Offer: ?6.5m (loyalty bonus and agent fee not included)
Year: 2013/14

Player: Sheamus Coleman
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Everton
Offer: ?8.5m (loyalty bonus and agent fee not included)
Year: 2013/14

Player: Nathaniel Clyne
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Southampton
Offer: ?13.0m (loyalty bonus and agent fee not included)
Year: 2013/14

Player: Jean-Marie Dongou
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Barcelona
Offer: ?3.3m + ?12.75m over 48 months + ?125k lb + ?625k af
Total 1st budget cost: ?6.09m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Kurt Zouma
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: ASSE
Offer: ?4.1m + ?13.25m over 48 months
Total 1st budget cost: ?6.25m (loyalty bonus and agent fee not included)
Year: 2013/14

Player: Ilsinho
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Shakhtar Donetsk
Offer: ?250k + ?1.2m over 48 months
Total 1st budget cost: ?450k (loyalty bonus and agent fee not included)
Year: 2013/14

Player: Mario Pugliese
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Atalanta
Offer: ?2.3m + ?5.5m over 48 months + ?15.5k lb
Total 1st budget cost: ?3.2m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Nicola Leali
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Juventus
Offer: ?1.5m + ?5.5m over 48 months + ?40.5k lb
Total 1st budget cost: ?2.42m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Eder Alvarez Balanta
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: River Plate
Offer: ?3.4m + ?11.25m over 48 months + ?300k lb + ?1.0m af
Total 1st budget cost: ?6.33m
Year: 2013/14

Player: Isaac Cuenca
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying/selling: Barcelona
Offer: ?425k + ?1.7m over 48 months + ?425k lb + ?400k af
Total 1st budget cost: ?1.21m
Year: 2013/14

 

[louiscfc]

Player: Raphael Varane
Team you are managing: Chelsea
Team who are selling: Real Madrid
Offer: £38M
Year: 2013/2014


or

Player: William Carvalho
Team you are managing: Chelsea
Team who are selling: Sporting Lisbon
Offer: £15M
Year: 2013/2014

No deal for Varane. You can get him a lot cheaper. Signed him for 14m in first season. And Carvalho depends on what update your on. If LFC Marshall then definitely deal as he got a massive upgrade.

 

[emman23]

Deal on Varane, I would buy him everytime i can get him under 50m