Tried it out with my Fulham save, 1st season and using this tactic in february. Tactic has reached Accomplished:
Man C 5 - 1 Fulham (Cap Cup)
Blackburn 1 - 3 Fulham
Fulham 3 - 3 Derby
QPR 0 - 0 Fulham
Fulham 4 - 2 Charlton
Leeds 2 - 4 Fulham
Well, Im not sure about this tactic so far. I mean, yeah sure the results speak for themselves, a win is a win and all that but personally I hate conceding this much. Leeds even managed to hit the post despite the goal being wide open.
I might continue using it a couple more games to see if there are any improvement in defence but if this is the style of the tactic, this gung-ho-style, then its not for me.