Hi all, apologies for bumping this ancient thread and the long post. I know there are still plenty of people out there playing FM17, and I want to share my tweak of this tactic that has worked fantastically for me. 4-3-1-2 is my favourite formation to play with in FM, and I have experimented extensively with Jesaustralia's tactic, the original Gamebreaker by the Reckonist, and my own creations across my various saves. What I liked particularly about Jesaustralia's tactic was that both strikers score lots of goals, and the build up play was full of intent, and not just keeping a hold of possession for possession's sake. I feel that my tweak manages to remain true to these principles while at the same time addressing the 2 biggest problems that I noticed with Jesaustralia's tactic, namely breaking down an opponent that sits deep and narrow, and defensive vulnerability down the flanks.
Team instructions I have kept almost the same as Jesaustralia's except I have changed the defensive line to slightly deeper to mitigate those long balls over the top and also to give my attack a bit more depth, which is important for breaking down defensive teams. Full credit must go to Jesaustralia for bringing us his immensely fun tactic to begin with.
The formation of my tweak looks like this:
As you can see, a few of the roles have been changed. Due to the high number of attacking duties in Jesaustralia's tactic (both strikers and the AMC were set to attack), it struggled against extremely defensive opponents as everyone was trying to make runs into space that simply did not exist. I have changed one of the strikers to a DLF on support to create confusion in the opponent's defensive line and open up space for us to attack. He links up well with the CM-A, who frequently bursts past him into the box, while still getting into dangerous areas himself to score goals. The AMC has also been been changed to a support duty and instructed to move into channels in order to find pockets of space that all the movement around him is generating. He behaves more like a playmaker than in Jesaustralia's system, and uses his passing and vision to unlock opposition defences. While not picking up huge amounts of assists, he is often responsible for the "pass before the assist". The roles and PIs for the 3 central midfielders have not been changed. In defence, I have given the PIs "Dribble less" and "Fewer risky passes" to both fullbacks, as they already play with an inherently high level of risk due to the Attacking team mentality and the last thing I want is for them to lose possession up the pitch and leave my entire flank exposed. The less attacking fullback who was a FB-S in Jesaustralia's tactic has been changed to a WB on defend for 2 main reasons. Firstly, the CM on attack needs more defensive protection on his side of the field to allow him the freedom to constantly bomb forward. Secondly, I wanted him to stay wide but not commit forward too much in order to draw out the opposition winger/wide midfielder/wingback and break open those banks of 4 or 5 defenders that are so hard to break down.
Let me attempt to illustrate this with a sequence of screenshots from a typical build-up move:
In this game, my Atletico Madrid (attacking right to left) faced a Valencia side that turned up with a defensive 4-2-2-2 in order to sit deep and frustrate us before attempting to hit us on the break. In this first screen shot, my AMC Gregor has drifted wide to get involved and pick up possession. One of Valencia's DMs has followed him. Notice how my right WB on defend (number 2) is staying wide and deep, while my left FB on attack (number 3) has already taken up an advanced position on the opposite flank. It is by using this asymmetry between the flanks that I manipulate and create space in the attacking third.
Gregor's movement opens up space in the middle, and he lays it off to Mikami (my MCL who is playing as a support Ball winning midfielder)
Mikami plays it forward to my Advanced forward Moya, who is being closely marked. Notice how the positioning of my right WB (number 2) has got Valencia's left wide midfielder (number 19) occupied enough to prevent him from dropping deeper and narrower to help prevent a potential overload situation developing in the middle. Valencia's number 6 is now having to contend with 2 of my central players running from deep (my number 8 and 18). Meanwhile, my left fullback on attack duty is about to get even more forward and keep Valencia's right fullback and right wide midfielder pinned down on that flank.
Moya waits for support, attracting 3 defenders to close him down in the process. He then lays it off to Grujic, my CM on attack who is running forward from deep. Valencia's number 19 is still keeping an eye on my right WB (number 2), who has largely held his position but could potentially make a burst down the touchline.
Grujic plays it short to my AMC Gregor, who has now found a dangerous amount of space just outside the penalty area that is available because Valencia's number 19 has been caught out wide watching my right wingback (number 2).
Gregor's dribbling and acceleration carries him into the box, and my 2 strikers (number 10 and number 19) are waiting in position for the cutback. Unfortunately, on this occasion Gregor is unable to pick out either of them and the move breaks down.
So as I said, this tweak has come about through many, many seasons of experimentation with various teams. The final version (which is attached) was used for the most recent season (2027/2028) in my journeyman save which was my second season in charge of Atletico Madrid. When I took over, the club was in massive debt and had a wage bill of more than 3.5 million pounds/week, and so at the end of my first season I sold off the club's world class wingers, who were by far the highest earners, to pave the way for me to plug in this 4-3-1-2. I ended up winning the domestic treble (La Liga, Super Cup, Copa del Rey), and lost in the semi-final of the Champions League to Man Utd when I was missing my best striker and most of my first team midfielders due to an injury crisis.
Here was the final league table:
And the transfers this season, which show an overhaul of the squad achieved despite a massive negative net spend:
My 3 main strikers, whom I rotated heavily, all scored over 25 goals each (my 4th choice striker is a youth prospect who I keep around the first team to give the occasional sub appearance or cup start):
Ze Gomes - the main man in attack. Played mostly in the AF position, but sometimes as the DLF when paired with Moya. Was on track to smash the club's record number of goals in a season until injuries in the 2nd half of the season robbed him of momentum and form.
Pedro Sousa - played exclusively in the DLF position.
Derek Moya - played exclusively in the AF position
As you can see, my players are pretty good, but certainly not among the best players in the world in their positions. Here were some of my other key performers this season:
Jose Ruiz (AMC) - probably an above-average La Liga AMC at best, but his flair, vision and movement off the ball were instrumental to opening up opposition defences. A better player in this position would create all sorts of damage.
Marko Grujic (CM attack) - an all-action box-to-box type of player. His fairly average stamina meant he frequently had to be subbed off.
Jose Sangoy (Left FB attack) - bombs forward at every opportunity and takes up attacking positions that wingers would typically occupy. This player needs to have superb physical attributes to allow him to get up and down that flank.
And safe to say this was my best result of the season...