So far not going well for my side. Have won title for past 4 years, using Il Devasto tactic. So it's basically same as yours but more attacking. Given the fact I was letting in a lot of goals I thought I would give this tactic a try. Unfortunately it has not been going well. I am using the TC version, set match prep to high and defensive positioning.
View attachment 195126
Pre-season was encouraging, won all but 1 game. But when it starts to count, I did not won any match so far and I also am letting in at least 1 goal/match. We are getting crushed, we barely have any chances and the opposition has tons of chances. This tactic does the opposite of what was promised so far.
When compared to last season this is terrible:
View attachment 195127
Note: the times I lost previous season were all in CL. In the league did not lost the first 25 games.
View attachment 195134
Couple games further in the game and as you can see, got a couple straight wins but very lucky to be honest. Than again 2 defeats.. Clearly something is wrong...? I have the same players as last year only changed tactic... I have over 16 goals against me, and I thought this tactic would allow me to score the same amount or a bit less goals than previous years but really strenghten my defends so I would not get so many goals against my team.. Very frustrating to say the least. And note that all these teams I lost to are **** teams. They are fighting against relegation while I am a title contender every year, in fact I won the title very year so far (4 times in a row, I won the supercup 4 times and the cup 1 time).. This is the worst season so far in my career..
I just can't believe everybody is having such great success with this tactic but I am not. lol
Update:
Just played another couple matches. I won both my CL matches... But I lost a ton more league matches. I am already over 10 points behind on the leaders. I can hardly believe anybody is able to get decent results with this tactic unless you have top players.