Most overrated player on FM 11?

[Jakebcfcsotv]

Steven N'zonzi, Ben Foster, Yakubu, Amauri.

BEN FOSTER? What medication are you on? What ever it the dose is too much.

 

[Athe~]

Funes Mori by a country mile.

 

[AmunRa]

Puyol is an amazing defender hands down. Admittedly he does not come close to the likes of Beckenbaer or other all time greats but they where gods. He practically played Ronaldo out of the game in the CL semi final last year, which is no easy thing to do. Some of the other guys mentioned like Hulk and Pastore ARE that good IRL in the leagues they play in so in the game, when they move to a better league, they don't tend to struggle as much as they would IRL, same goes for the GK's mentioned and Albiol is mistake prone in my Real Madrid save.
Confidence is also a factor as is form.

 

[clockworkorange]

Adriano 100%.

agreed. doesn't look like the hippopotamus we saw in rome last season

 

[joalbrito]

Definitely Lionel Messy and Cristiano Ronaldo. Also Hans Jorg ****.

 

[NeedForSpeed]

Definitely Lionel Messy and Cristiano Ronaldo.

Which world are you in?

 

[joalbrito]

Which world are you in?

They are made far better than they actually are. If these were their real abilities they would be the two best players in history, and they are nowhere near the top 20 or even 50 players in history.

CR7:
Determination: 19 - WTF? This is the player who cannot play in big games, and who can score 40 goals in a season against some amateurs but when he plays against real teams and the match i hard and his team concedes he just dissapears from the field. The same applies to Messi, who did not score a single goal for Argenitna in the WC. His job in Barca could be done just as good by a mediocre poacher.

CR7: Pace - 18/19; Acceleration 16, Agility 16 - How come? I wonder if overmars played today what would be his quickness attributes in comparison to CR7's ones. In order to be realistic they would have to be at least 25 each...

The long shots of the two players are also very far from reality, they should be somewhere around 13/14. I can't think of may Messi goals scored from more than 25m. The same applies to Ronaldo.

Messi's crossing is also not that good - it should be around 14.

Cristiano's free kicks deserve no more than 14. Else Juninho, Basler and Roberto Carlos should have had 23-25 on this attribute.
And the list just goes on and on.

 

[Germaniac]

They are made far better than they actually are. If these were their real abilities they would be the two best players in history, and they are nowhere near the top 20 or even 50 players in history.

CR7:
Determination: 19 - WTF? This is the player who cannot play in big games, and who can score 40 goals in a season against some amateurs but when he plays against real teams and the match i hard and his team concedes he just dissapears from the field. The same applies to Messi, who did not score a single goal for Argenitna in the WC. His job in Barca could be done just as good by a mediocre poacher.

CR7: Pace - 18/19; Acceleration 16, Agility 16 - How come? I wonder if overmars played today what would be his quickness attributes in comparison to CR7's ones. In order to be realistic they would have to be at least 25 each...

The long shots of the two players are also very far from reality, they should be somewhere around 13/14. I can't think of may Messi goals scored from more than 25m. The same applies to Ronaldo.

Messi's crossing is also not that good - it should be around 14.

Cristiano's free kicks deserve no more than 14. Else Juninho, Basler and Roberto Carlos should have had 23-25 on this attribute.
And the list just goes on and on.

True, Messi in Barcelona have good teammates that give nice pass to him

 

[brayoz]

joalbrito - i see that you are a Messi fan boy ;] Messi is also overrated, how he can be the best player every year from 2011 to 2022?

 

[Germaniac]

joalbrito - i see that you are a Messi fan boy ;] Messi is also overrated, how he can be the best player every year from 2011 to 2022?

He say Messi is overrated, or is it just me?...

 

[Foss]

Else Juninho, Basler and Roberto Carlos should have had 23-25 on this attribute.

Roberto Carlos' free kicks weren't that much reliant on accuracy.

 

[joalbrito]

joalbrito - i see that you are a Messi fan boy ;] Messi is also overrated, how he can be the best player every year from 2011 to 2022?

Messi and Ronaldo are probably the players who I hate the most because they are extremelly overrated my many so-called specialist, who compare them to players like Maradona, Basten and company which is very annoying because it has nothing to do with reality. They are also overrated in FM. And I agree with you that Messi is extremelly overrated. he didn't diserve to be best player for 2010 in real life either. they are far from being the best wingers in the past 15 years, let alone being one of the best players in history.

 

[Fraz100]

Messi and Ronaldo are probably the players who I hate the most because they are extremelly overrated my many so-called specialist, who compare them to players like Maradona, Basten and company which is very annoying because it has nothing to do with reality. They are also overrated in FM. And I agree with you that Messi is extremelly overrated. he didn't diserve to be best player for 2010 in real life either. they are far from being the best wingers in the past 15 years, let alone being one of the best players in history.

View attachment 184689

 

[NeedForSpeed]

Messi and Ronaldo are probably the players who I hate the most because they are extremelly overrated my many so-called specialist, who compare them to players like Maradona, Basten and company which is very annoying because it has nothing to do with reality. They are also overrated in FM. And I agree with you that Messi is extremelly overrated. he didn't diserve to be best player for 2010 in real life either. they are far from being the best wingers in the past 15 years, let alone being one of the best players in history.

thread is not about players you hate

 

[joalbrito]

View attachment 184689

What exactly do you disagree with?
About messi winning best player for 2010?
About the fact that messi is nowhere near Maradona?
or about the fact that I can think of at least 3 wingers better than Messi and CR7 in the past 15 years?
What exactly?

 

[Mads2506]

They are made far better than they actually are. If these were their real abilities they would be the two best players in history, and they are nowhere near the top 20 or even 50 players in history.

CR7:
Determination: 19 - WTF? This is the player who cannot play in big games, and who can score 40 goals in a season against some amateurs but when he plays against real teams and the match i hard and his team concedes he just dissapears from the field. The same applies to Messi, who did not score a single goal for Argenitna in the WC. His job in Barca could be done just as good by a mediocre poacher.

CR7: Pace - 18/19; Acceleration 16, Agility 16 - How come? I wonder if overmars played today what would be his quickness attributes in comparison to CR7's ones. In order to be realistic they would have to be at least 25 each...

The long shots of the two players are also very far from reality, they should be somewhere around 13/14. I can't think of may Messi goals scored from more than 25m. The same applies to Ronaldo.

Messi's crossing is also not that good - it should be around 14.

Cristiano's free kicks deserve no more than 14. Else Juninho, Basler and Roberto Carlos should have had 23-25 on this attribute.
And the list just goes on and on.

Lol at this. What exactly makes you think you can compare, let's say, Ronaldo's speed with Overmars'? Or compare Messi with Maradona? Have you seen themk play against each other? Did you even live when Maradona played??!!

 

[joshr100]

Christian Benitez is overated on the game. Scores at least 20 goals a season in the Prem with ANY team (even my west brom save).

 

[Germaniac]

Messi and Ronaldo are probably the players who I hate the most because they are extremelly overrated my many so-called specialist, who compare them to players like Maradona, Basten and company which is very annoying because it has nothing to do with reality. They are also overrated in FM. And I agree with you that Messi is extremelly overrated. he didn't diserve to be best player for 2010 in real life either. they are far from being the best wingers in the past 15 years, let alone being one of the best players in history.

I agree, they're overrated, I also hate them, I didn't see why people say player with good ability is much better than player that have good teamwork, in reality teamwork is better, we see in 2010 WC Germany 4-1 England and Germany 4-0 Argentina, that time I'm laughing at my friends because they're sure Germany will lose, Germany really underrated, it's why I love them (I love all underrated players and clubs)

 

[joalbrito]

Lol at this. What exactly makes you think you can compare, let's say, Ronaldo's speed with Overmars'? Or compare Messi with Maradona? Have you seen themk play against each other? Did you even live when Maradona played??!!

‪Overmars VS Cristiano Ronaldo en velocidad‬‏ - YouTube
This makes me think I can compare the 33 year old overmars (not at his peak definitely) with Cristiano
And yeah, I was really young when Maradona was in his decline, but it is obvious that he was way better than Messi.

 

[Mads2506]

‪Overmars VS Cristiano Ronaldo en velocidad‬‏ - YouTube
This makes me think I can compare the 33 year old overmars (not at his peak definitely) with Cristiano
And yeah, I was really young when Maradona was in his decline, but it is obvious that he was way better than Messi.

Cristiano Ronaldo was on the outside and Overmars was on the inside and he used to strength to push Ronaldo away.