The Deal or No Deal thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Raikan007
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 2K
  • Views Views 453K
Player : Fernandinho
Team I managing : AC Milan
Team who are selling : Shakhtar
Offer: 25 million $
Season 2012/2013


or

Player : Roberto Firmino
Team I manage : AC Milan
Team who are selling : Hoffenheim
Offer :36 millions $
Year :2012/2013
Other info : who i got to choose ?

I have great experience with Fernandinho so I would pick him.
 
Player : Gylfi Sigurdsson
Team I manage : Man U
Team who are selling : Wolves
Offer : 11.25M
Year : 2013/2014
Other info : Götze and Neymar are wanting to leave their clubs...I don't really need a new MC/AMC but when these players arrive at the transfer list, one should not ignore their availability and quality.
 
Last edited:
Player : Gylfi Sigurdsson
Team I manage : Man U
Team who are selling : Wolves
Offer : 11.25M
Year : 2013/2014
Other info : Götze and Neymar are wanting to leave their clubs...I don't really need a new MC/AMC but when these players arrive at the transfer list, one should not ignore their availability and quality. Gylfi is a top quality player.

Deal if you want added cover for your squad in the center of the park. Frankly, I'd take him for his set piece abilities.


Juan Manuel Mata
Offer from Barcelona (ESP)
Offer: £4.9m initial + £21m over 21 months + £2.8 after 10 league games (£28.7m total)
Year: Winter 2012/13 season
Info: Utilized as a left winger. Avg rating around 7.25 over last two seasons. Still use Malouda as backup and Kakuta as young rotation. Hazard or Neymar potential replacements but both will cost well more than the fee received from this transfer. It's a nice sum, but wondering if I could hold out until summer or beyond for an extra £5-10m more.
 
Deal if you want added cover for your squad in the center of the park. Frankly, I'd take him for his set piece abilities.


Juan Manuel Mata
Offer from Barcelona (ESP)
Offer: £4.9m initial + £21m over 21 months + £2.8 after 10 league games (£28.7m total)
Year: Winter 2012/13 season
Info: Utilized as a left winger. Avg rating around 7.25 over last two seasons. Still use Malouda as backup and Kakuta as young rotation. Hazard or Neymar potential replacements but both will cost well more than the fee received from this transfer. It's a nice sum, but wondering if I could hold out until summer or beyond for an extra £5-10m more.

I'd say Deal, in 2013/2014 season he is worth much more than you are paying.
 
Player : Mario Götze
Team I manage : Man U
Team who are selling : Dortmund
Offer : 100M
Year : 2013/2014
Other info : He was offered to me since he is requesting transfer listed. First I thought it was April Fools...but 100M...I am willing to pay Max 30M.
 
Player : Mario Götze
Team I manage : Man U
Team who are selling : Dortmund
Offer : 100M
Year : 2013/2014
Other info : He was offered to me since he is requesting transfer listed. First I thought it was April Fools...but 100M...I am willing to pay Max 30M.

I'd say no deal. 100 mil on any player is nuts, unless you don't need anything and can afford to splash out! since you are willing to pay Max 30m you wouldn't get him anyway ^^. He is unbelieveable, but that's just a crazy amount of money!
 
I'd say no deal. 100 mil on any player is nuts, unless you don't need anything and can afford to splash out! since you are willing to pay Max 30m you wouldn't get him anyway ^^. He is unbelieveable, but that's just a crazy amount of money!

He is requesting to be transfer listed and they won't transfer list him at 100M + I am the only one that has the money and interest, lets see what happens and I will post it :)
 
Player: Andre Schurrle
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are selling: Leverkusen
Offer: 26.5m
Year: 2014/15
Other Info: Need a good left winger, and I've got ~37m to burn. Don't want to spend too much though.
 
Player: Andre Schurrle
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are selling: Leverkusen
Offer: 26.5m
Year: 2014/15
Other Info: Need a good left winger, and I've got ~37m to burn. Don't want to spend too much though.

I'll scout him now, his Technical Abilities are not really impressive.
Angel Di Maria is a great left winger and comes cheap, I bought him for 15M.
Unsettle Dudu...
If Willian is still with Shaktar, he is Great!
Eden Hazard is also great but if City has him, forget it.
Scout Connar Wickham, good english talent.
Antoine Griezmann is also excellent and cheap.
 
1174_deal_or_no_deal_468_2.jpg


A continuation of Dan's excellent thread from FM 2010.

Please stick to the following template below.

Anyone is free to reply to peoples posts, but don't just reply for the sake of it. Suggesting replacements/alternatives is useful as well. :wub:

Template:

Player: Javi Martinez
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are buying/selling: Athletic
Offer: £15m
Year: 2011/12
Other Info: Need a good Cm to cover for Lucas, plus Mereiles leaving for Chelsea, thank you



Player: Doumbia
Team you are managing:Totenham
Team who are buying/selling:CSKA
Offer:25m euro
Year:2011/2012
 
Player: Doumbia
Team you are managing:Totenham
Team who are buying/selling:CSKA
Offer:25m euro
Year:2011/2012

I would say No Deal, I don't think he is worth 25M, seems expensive, last season 2012/2013 he had an average rating of 7.08 and this season 6.80...
 
Player: demba ba
Team you are managing:Man utd
Team who are buying/selling:Newcastle
Offer:15 mil Euro
Year:2011/2012
 
I'll scout him now, his Technical Abilities are not really impressive.
Angel Di Maria is a great left winger and comes cheap, I bought him for 15M.
Unsettle Dudu...
If Willian is still with Shaktar, he is Great!
Eden Hazard is also great but if City has him, forget it.
Scout Connar Wickham, good english talent.
Antoine Griezmann is also excellent and cheap.

Thanks for the advice! I got James Rodriguez at 14m. He was the best left winger at the 2014 World Cup in my game haha.
 
Player: demba ba
Team you are managing:Man utd
Team who are buying/selling:Newcastle
Offer:15 mil Euro
Year:2011/2012
no deal, to expenssive, and I dubt he will be any better then your current strikers
 
Playing Ajax currently got bids on my 2 top players

Player: Christan Erikkson
Team you are managing: Ajax
Team who are buying: Dortmund
Offer: £11
Year: 2013/14
Other Info: He's my best attacking midfielder, making the most assists last season. Want to have more dutch players.

Player: Jan Vertongen
Team you are managing: Ajax
Team who are buying: Bayern
Offer: £12
Year: 2013/14
Other Info: He's my best defender, but want to have more dutch players.
 
Playing Ajax currently got bids on my 2 top players

Player: Christan Erikkson
Team you are managing: Ajax
Team who are buying: Dortmund
Offer: £11
Year: 2013/14
Other Info: He's my best attacking midfielder, making the most assists last season. Want to have more dutch players.

Player: Jan Vertongen
Team you are managing: Ajax
Team who are buying: Bayern
Offer: £12
Year: 2013/14
Other Info: He's my best defender, but want to have more dutch players.

I assume you mean Christian Eriksen, No Deal, demand more or at least try.
For Jan, No Deal, demand more or at least try.
I think you should at least get 15-20...but that is just me :)
 
Player: Jan Vertonghen
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who are selling: ajax
Offer: 13m usd
Year: 2012 last day of january
Other Info:rotation for first team

Player: XbeastMx
Team you are managing: arsenal
Team who are selling: mu
Offer: free
Year: 2012 january
Other Info: stats jpa 20 jpp20
 
Player: Jan Vertonghen
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who are selling: ajax
Offer: 13m usd
Year: 2012 last day of january
Other Info:rotation for first team

Player: XbeastMx
Team you are managing: arsenal
Team who are selling: mu
Offer: free
Year: 2012 january
Other Info: stats jpa 20 jpp20

Who is xbeastmx?
 
Back
Top