The Deal or No Deal thread

ref end · Feb 17, 2012

Player: Chris Samba
Team you are managing: Blackburn
Team who are buying/selling: Man City
Offer: £20M
Year: 2011/12
Other Info: Could use the money to strengthen squad, but he is good player

mrloser · Feb 17, 2012

Player: Oscar Cardozo
Team you are managing: Everton
Team who are buying/selling: SLB
Offer: £10M
Year: 2011/12
Other Info: Need world class striker to qualify Champion League

Lol_101 · Feb 17, 2012

ref end said:
Player: Chris Samba
Team you are managing: Blackburn
Team who are buying/selling: Man City
Offer: £20M
Year: 2011/12
Other Info: Could use the money to strengthen squad, but he is good player

Deal. possible replacements : David Asatroi, mateo musacchio, nicolas otamendi, jan verthogen

Yago69 said:
Player: Bacary Sagna
Team: Arsenal
Team buying: Man. City
Offer: around 20 million
Year: Summer 2012 (he's 30 yo now)
Other info: I've got Vrsaljko as backup.

Deal. play Sime all day long. if you really need someone, then search out for romario (vitoria) or sebastian corchia

StephenMUFC said:
Player: Mamadou Sakho
Team: PSG
Team Buying: Man City
Offer: 17.2 Million + 20% profit of next sale.
Year: Summer 2012

Player: Dedryck Boyata
Team: PSG
Team Selling: Man City
Offer: 5 Million
Year: Summer 2012

NO for Sahko, ask for a higher amount (like 25m). he's probably the best CB you have atm.
some replacements can be David Asatroi, mateo musacchio, nicolas otamendi, jan verthogen, or gerigo chellini

Yes for Boyata

Lol_101 · Feb 17, 2012

mrloser said:
Player: Oscar Cardozo
Team you are managing: Everton
Team who are buying/selling: SLB
Offer: £10M
Year: 2011/12
Other Info: Need world class striker to qualify Champion League

Always a YES all day long. he is class. play him as a target man.

hugochelsea · Feb 17, 2012

Lol_101 said:
Sow should be less than 7m imo. depends on which season you are in.

I only have 5m to spend though might try yaya sanogo

duca · Feb 17, 2012

julianchelmsford said:
Player: Gerard Deulofeu
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are buying/selling: Barca
Offer: Free
Year: Summer 2014
Other Info: Have Nani, Valencia, and want to promote Januzaj next year. Obviously I dont want 4 AMR's, so I will have to sell Nani/Valencia, and maybe convert Januzaj to AMC. Or should I just stick with what i have?

Buy and sell Valencia

duca · Feb 17, 2012

hugochelsea said:
I only have 5m to spend though might try yaya sanogo

Try Brown Ideye from Dinamo Kiev

Yago69 · Feb 18, 2012

Player: David Silva
Team managing: Arsenal
Team selling: City
Offer: 12,5 million euros = something like 10 million pounds I think.
Year: Summer 2012
Other info: They offered him for that price. It'll probably be a bit more, 15 or 17 million, but even that's very cheap for a player with his qualities. I'd instantly buy him in most other cases. But now, I already have Eden Hazard, Willian, Gaitan, Wilshere, Eriksen... And Neymar if I play him on the left. (still have v. Persie). So, I'm pretty stuffed with talent already...

Lol_101 · Feb 18, 2012

Yago69 said:
Player: David Silva
Team managing: Arsenal
Team selling: City
Offer: 12,5 million euros = something like 10 million pounds I think.
Year: Summer 2012
Other info: They offered him for that price. It'll probably be a bit more, 15 or 17 million, but even that's very cheap for a player with his qualities. I'd instantly buy him in most other cases. But now, I already have Eden Hazard, Willian, Gaitan, Wilshere, Eriksen... And Neymar if I play him on the left. (still have v. Persie). So, I'm pretty stuffed with talent already...

NO deal. you already have alot of talent in the wings and midfield.

Yago69 · Feb 18, 2012

OK then. Pity though

Followed your advise and sold Sagna for 21 million btw.

4ntonio · Feb 18, 2012

Player: Fabio Coentrao
Team managing: Real Madrid
Team buying: Man Utd
Offer: 20 million $
Year: Winter 2012
Other info: I need a better defensive Full Back .

JakeBCFC · Feb 18, 2012

4ntonio said:
Player: Fabio Coentrao
Team managing: Real Madrid
Team buying: Man Utd
Offer: 20 million $
Year: Winter 2012
Other info: I need a better defensive Full Back .

Try push them up a bit maybe 25-30m then you could get criscito hes more defensive and should be cheaper

lenzorvic · Feb 18, 2012

Player: Erik Lamela
Team managing: Tottenham Hotspur
Team selling: AS Roma
Offer: 10mil
Year: Winter 2013
Other info: I don't really need him, but I think he might be a good player in the future.

jameshankin · Feb 18, 2012

Player: Arthur Boka
Team managing: Newcastle
Team Selling: Stuttgart
Offer: £3.8m
Year: summer 2011
Other info: need a decent left back. 38,500 wages

Player: Dodo
Team managing: Newcastle
Team selling: Bahia
Offer: £900k
Year: summer 2011
Other info: need a decent left back. wages 8k

needing a left back. got offers in for both of these. which one should i get? quick reply needed please

gordson · Feb 18, 2012

Player: Markus Henriksen
Team managing: Liverpool
Team selling: Lyon
Offer: 37.5million
Year: Pre Season 2014
Other info: Looking replacement for Gerrard. Have Eriksen and Lucas Moura but Moura is more effective as a winger and Eriksen never lasts a full game

Lol_101 · Feb 18, 2012

4ntonio said:
Player: Fabio Coentrao
Team managing: Real Madrid
Team buying: Man Utd
Offer: 20 million $
Year: Winter 2012
Other info: I need a better defensive Full Back .

increase it to 25 or something. then buy criscito or aly cissishko who is a much better defensively

lenzorvic said:
Player: Erik Lamela
Team managing: Tottenham Hotspur
Team selling: AS Roma
Offer: 10mil
Year: Winter 2013
Other info: I don't really need him, but I think he might be a good player in the future.

he's a player for the future. not sure why you want to sell him.

jameshankin said:
Player: Arthur Boka
Team managing: Newcastle
Team Selling: Stuttgart
Offer: £3.8m
Year: summer 2011
Other info: need a decent left back. 38,500 wages

Player: Dodo
Team managing: Newcastle
Team selling: Bahia
Offer: £900k
Year: summer 2011
Other info: need a decent left back. wages 8k

needing a left back. got offers in for both of these. which one should i get? quick reply needed please

Its a Deal for Dodo.

jameshankin · Feb 18, 2012

thanks mate

nikudini · Feb 18, 2012

Player: Andrea Bertolacci
Team managing: Sheffield Wednesday
Team selling: Roma
Offer: £6m
Year: Pre Season 2014-2015
Other info: I've got pretty good midfield players, Verratti, Cairney, Moretti, Labyad. I play with 2 CMs and a DLP or DM at DCM. Do you think I should go for the all Italian midfield? Also he'll be my highest earner.

Catta · Feb 19, 2012

Player: Adam Johnson
Team managing: West Ham
Team selling: West Ham
Team buying: Juventus
Offer: €16.5 mil
Year: summer 2016
Other info: i play him as an AMR Inside forward, hes my best player on that position, Johnson is 29 and its maybe my last chance to make a profit on him, if I sell him, who should i get as a replacement

Lord_Slop · Feb 19, 2012

Catta said:
Player: Adam Johnson
Team managing: West Ham
Team selling: West Ham
Team buying: Juventus
Offer: €16.5 mil
Year: summer 2016
Other info: i play him as an AMR Inside forward, hes my best player on that position, Johnson is 29 and its maybe my last chance to make a profit on him, if I sell him, who should i get as a replacement

Given his age, Deal

The Deal or No Deal thread

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

FMBase

Beta

Resources