The Manchester United Thread

[Tyton]

Lol. Lamela presumably?

Have to disagree on Lloris. There's only Neuer I'd put up there with De Gea and I have a hard time separating the two. He's the best 'keeper in England for me.

Neuer is light years ahead of the rest tbh. He's as good as a standard goalkeeper as any of the others, and he doubles as a sweeper. Nobody else is even close.

Lloris is consistently making world-class saves basically every week, I'd have a problem picking who is better, him and De Gea. The only difference is that one plays for big club and the other doesn't. Obviously you can't be world class until you play for a glorious elite club, even though goalkeeper is doing exactly the same **** whether he plays for United or QPR.

 

[Mike.]

De Gea

Darmain Smalling Aldieriweld (sp) Shaw

Schweinsteiger Herrera

Lamela Mata Martial

Kane

 

[Tyton]

If you had a gun to your head and wanted one of De Gea or Lloris you'd have the former.

If I had a gun to my head I'd scream like a little girl and faint to avoid the question.

 

[zzeezzy]

I'd still take Lamela.

Really? Lamela turns it on about as much as Depay does and Young is more consistent than both of them.

 

[Scouseinthehouse]

Really? Lamela turns it on about as much as Depay does and Young is more consistent than both of them.

Young would certainly take the honours off a diving board. (H).

 

[zzeezzy]

De Gea

Darmain Smalling Aldieriweld (sp) Shaw

Schweinsteiger Herrera

Lamela Mata Martial

Kane

I'd replace Herrera with Dele Alli and Schweinsteiger with Schneiderlin.

Not Kane's biggest fan but he's better than Rooney if we count the majority of his form this season. I would say Rashford but that would be taking the **** after just two games, like what I'm seeing though, he brings players like Mata into the game with his movement.

 

[wkdsoul]

Really? Lamela turns it on about as much as Depay does and Young is more consistent than both of them.

Young consistent, since when? He was close to being sold at one point he was that poor. He had a few good months under LVG, but has been hit and miss overall, and is he a much better player now than when Man U and Liverpool started chasing him at Villa? not for me.

and anyone picking Rashford over Kane OR Rooney based on one good Premier League game needs a slap.

 

[zzeezzy]

Young consistent, since when? He was close to being sold at one point he was that poor. He had a few good months under LVG, but has been hit and miss overall, and is he a much better player now than when Man U and Liverpool started chasing him at Villa? not for me.

and anyone picking Rashford over Kane OR Rooney based on one good Premier League game needs a slap.

Young has been one of our best players this season (when not injured) and last season. He has been great under LVG. Plus he has filled numerous positions effectively.

 

[wkdsoul]

Young has been one of our best players this season (when not injured) and last season. He has been great under LVG. Plus he has filled numerous positions effectively.

Youngs record for an AML at Man U is poor for a winger
goals - league 6,0,2,2,0
assists 7,3,1,5,2

even before LVG started moving him to wingback and full back, thats poor for an AML for me, nah i'll take Erikesson or Lamela in the slot

 

[zzeezzy]

Youngs record for an AML at Man U is poor for a winger
goals - league 6,0,2,2,0
assists 7,3,1,5,2

even before LVG started moving him to wingback and full back, thats poor for an AML for me, nah i'll take Erikesson or Lamela in the slot

Eriksen doesn't play on the flank so you're cheating. ^^)

I'd take Depay over Lamela but that's me, I've never rated Lamela or really been impressed with him. Has he ever put in an outstanding performance for Tottenham? Unless I've lived in a cave I guess I missed it.

 

[wkdsoul]

Eriksen doesn't play on the flank so you're cheating. ^^)

I'd take Depay over Lamela but that's me, I've never rated Lamela or really been impressed with him. Has he ever put in an outstanding performance for Tottenham? Unless I've lived in a cave I guess I missed it.

Hes started more games there than anywhere else.

 

[zzeezzy]

Hes started more games there than anywhere else.

oO)

I thought he was a no.10 that played behind the striker? As you can tell I watch Spurs a lot......

 

[Tyton]

Young has been one of best players last 2 years. Especially impressive since he was put into several different positions and always played well. Complete turnaround under LVG.

 

[Legend Incredible]

Eriksen doesn't play on the flank so you're cheating. ^^)

I'd take Depay over Lamela but that's me, I've never rated Lamela or really been impressed with him. Has he ever put in an outstanding performance for Tottenham? Unless I've lived in a cave I guess I missed it.

Remember his rabona goal in the Europe leagur?

Sent from my SM-G900T1 using Tapatalk

 

[Legend Incredible]

Lloris is as good as De Gea, Eriksen is as good as Mata, Kane is better than Rooney/Rashford/whoever else plays up to, Lallana is miles better than Lingard....so yeah.

De gea>lloris but not as much

Eriksen=Mata based on form but top form, Mata all day long

Sent from my SM-G900T1 using Tapatalk

 

[Mike.]

De Gea, Varela, Blind, Rojo, Fosu-Mensah, Herrera, Schneiderlin, Martial, Mata, Depay, Rashford

 

[Puddz]

Glad Rashford is starting even though Martial is back. Rashford deserves it after the 2 games, 4 goals. And Martial is more effective down the wing.

Also glad Memphis is starting. Last two games he's deserved it.

 

[Tyton]

Good lineup. Although, which choice left-back is Fosu-Mensah? 8th in the pecking order?

 

[zzeezzy]

Fosu-Mensah is one of our most versatile and brightest academy players. He can play CB, LB or midfield. Bit like Blind in the way he has been converted more to defence as of late.

 

[Tyton]

Meh I can't find a decent stream tonight.