Aston Villa Vs Man Utd - Carling Cup Final

JDY

Member
Dec 7, 2008
3,441
0
36
Currently 1-1

Milner with the first from the penalty spot, Vidic should have been sent off but his foul went unpunished.

Mistake from Dunne allowed Berbatov to go through on goal, but Dunne's last ditch tackle fell straight to Owen who finishes cooly.
 

bcfc

Shizz has changed...
Nov 3, 2009
3,529
0
0
I hate both of these :)

Never ending penalty shoot out please XD
 

JDY

Member
Dec 7, 2008
3,441
0
36
The only reason i think he didn't send him off is because he didn't want to spoil the game with what, only 4 minutes into the match? Definate red i think.
 

Dunc

Keyboard Warrior
Dec 3, 2009
10,690
0
36
I dont get why Vidic wasn't sent off?! maybe beacuse it was so early in the match.. should have gone.

Can see Rooney coming on and scoring the winner in the 97th min :)
 

WesleyLUFC

Member
Dec 12, 2009
212
0
0
The referee is so biased to United, he couldnt not give the penalty but Vidic should have been sent off - he was the last man.
There should be no difference in the rules in the 3rd minute, the 63rd minute or the 93rd minute - if a player commits a foul worthy of a red card he should go whatever time it is
It is his fault if he gets sent off and Man U have to play the whole match with 10 men
 

CJACKO11

Member
Dec 16, 2009
15,889
0
0
32
I thought by fifa rules you was only allowed to field 11players because utd have this fellow called phil dowd playing. Vidic should have gone simple as that i feel utd will win now but i hope villa will.
 

satanasangel

Member
Apr 28, 2009
331
0
0
I agree Vidic should be off definately. How he is still on the pitch I don't know. Only thing I can think of is that Agbonlhor took a touch that wasn't forward but more holding it up, but yet again that was only because Vidic was man handling him. Is very strange from the ref, time on the clock probably helped Vidic.

I wonder if James Collins who dumped Owen when being last man and whizzing past him for pace and heading towards the box. Albeit quite far out, is that not a red card to...had Vidic been sent off?

Also Milner's handball in the box is as much a penalty if Arsenal handball was yesterday was anything to go by.
 

GUNNER500

Member
Dec 22, 2008
1,420
0
36
44
that ref is rubbish another manu fan under the black shirt! vidic should have gone and hes only booking villa players ?? not right! same old manu always cheating!!
 

Jamie F

Surprise *****!
Jun 16, 2009
2,149
0
0
26
Nice header. 7 out of his last 8 goals have been headers and 9 in total this year. Only had 4 headed goals before this season

Oooh. Rooney again with a header hits the post
 

Max

Member
Apr 14, 2009
10,063
0
0
Valencia is an assist machine, deserves so much more credit than he gets in my opinion.

Can't see Villa coming back now.
 

Matty

Member
Feb 9, 2009
3,224
0
0
UNITED UNITED UNITED UNITED UNITED

i would usually follow this with "S**T S**T S**T" :p
but on days like today, and only on days like today, that all changes :)

"Chim chimeny chim chimeny, chim chim cherooo, I HATE THOSE B******S IN CLARET AND BLUE!"

enjoy the trip back up to Brum ;), and thats to Man Utd fans too <)
 

Max

Member
Apr 14, 2009
10,063
0
0
Feel sorry for Villa, worked really hard to get to the final.

Better luck next time, although Vidic should of been sent off which would of probably made the result a completely different one.
 
Top