Chill out dude, you can leave the full defensive mode, no one here is saying that your tactic isn't good with Real Madrid or something, if you don't want people to test it with other teams in other scenarios I'm so sorry I guess.
Yes, I have spent quite some time finding players to fit this tactic, and possibly I've gotten the best players possible for my level so it isn't really a question of finding players who "suit the roles", maybe it's a question of squad strenght but 100% sure it isn't about suiting roles.
~perhaps~ the next time you can be less defensive and try to accept some feedback, I said I was gonna post some more at the end of the season but by now and with the way you've received some results and not even the critics itself I won't even bother on keep trying your tactic, thanks anyways for trying and maybe take things easier next time.
@edit just some more things that i wanted to say, I'm no TBH, raikan or Mr.Hough but I've been using downloaded tactics and creating ones for quite a long time and I can guarantee you I'm not the type of guys who just puts it into the game and complains, it even insults me that you talked to me like I was one.
Did I come across as defensive? Apologies if I did and upset you. When I was talking about the people who just expect plug & play I honestly wasn't referring to you nor did I mean to say that you expected that. But problem is people like that exist and it's problematic. I mentioned it but it wasn't directed at you. But again sorry if my reply seemed a bit on the defensive side or something.
Keep me updated with how it goes though. Are you conceding a lot or is it a matter of not scoring enough?