If you run a season with Everton and let's say Danilo, Locksmith or Back to Basic, you will understand what kind of tactics I'm looking for. A gd of only +25 with Everton shows a sign of luck that you got 3rd place, and the tactics I want to test are the ones that has no problems winning the league with teams of that quality, preferably with a good gd. You should try Danilo or Locksmith or any of the top ones, and you will see a big difference
I don't say that your tactic is bad, I'm just saying that it's just not up to par with the absolute top tactics here.
In any case, I have cross-checked all the settings in the tactic you uploaded now vs the one I downloaded earlier from your thread, and they are 100% equal. I'm afraid my test is a bit too hard for your tactic. Another thing is that my tactic test is set in England, and this says nothing about how your tactic does in other countries. Perhaps this does really well in let's say Spain or Italy, I don't know. But for the EPL, there are better tactics. I hope I didn't offend you or anything, cause that is really not my intention. I value all users at this great forum.