My Huge Tactics Testing Project (FM 2012) !!!

[Tk1129]

Hey andy why don't you write up a short summary for each tactic, or just the ones that impress you the most. You've gone through a ton of tactics during the course of this project and I can't think of anybody more qualified (and impartial).

I think a 2-3 line summary of play style and general observations, like is it a posession or counter tactic - do goals come from crosses or through balls, etc.

I apologize if i'm burdening you with more work, i just think a little qualitative analysis would be nice to go with the numbers.

 

[gee_simpson]

ROUND 8 COMPLETED!

ROUND 8:
A Better Half 2 (GRANDEWIDE41221 - 3 - STANDARD (Everton, Oct 2010)
B Xenon 2 (XeNoN's_4-2-4_v1.00_(Man_Utd,_Dec_2011)
C Raikan 2 (new_classic_possession_amc_(Santos,_Sep_2011)
D Quilo (4 2 4 맨유 완전체 파이널 (Málaga, Jan 2011)
E Maxy 2 (The Invincibles (Juventus, Oct 2011)
F Vodu 2 (442 Vodu Caos V2 12.0)
G T-mo (Anderlecht_5 (Anderlecht, Sep 2016)
H Zero Sea 2 (Zero Sea's Wonderland V3)

THE LEAGUE:

THE CUP:

THE CUP FINAL:

THE PLAY OFF:

THE PLAY OFF FINAL:

Xenon dominates yet again in the league

Will his 4231 be in the next test?

 

[[T]-Mo]

If you do a next test, please try this tactic of me: http://www.mediafire.com/?jvyvlayr4cyl1mb

 

[cricketdave]

Respect goes out to everyone who's tactics make the test - well done!

 

[a_ilfandy]

Agreed on the narrow part. I'm trying to make some narrow tactics as overpowering as my tactics with wingers but I'm struggling.

keep trying, and lemme have the first bite when you are done..
your tactics yet to disappoint me.. ^^)

 

[a_ilfandy]

Hey andy why don't you write up a short summary for each tactic, or just the ones that impress you the most. You've gone through a ton of tactics during the course of this project and I can't think of anybody more qualified (and impartial).

I think a 2-3 line summary of play style and general observations, like is it a posession or counter tactic - do goals come from crosses or through balls, etc.

I apologize if i'm burdening you with more work, i just think a little qualitative analysis would be nice to go with the numbers.

if you havent noticed, this is the kinda of thing I'm trying to avoid.. my personal judgement..
which is why the project has always been results oriented and quantitative.. everytime someone ask me which one is the best tactic, I'll just give them the summary and let them make their own conclusion..

plus, I'm kinda clueless on the tactic criticism and stuff.. and about the goal analysis I'm ready to give it away if anybody asking for it.. like in ROUND 7 FINAL RESULTS..

 

[a_ilfandy]

Xenon dominates yet again in the league

Will his 4231 be in the next test?

surely I will.. still waiting for his 424 to be eliminated.. (6)
if you check round 9 update later, its gonna be awhile..

 

[a_ilfandy]

Respect goes out to everyone who's tactics make the test - well done!

and its an honor for me to have their tactics tested here.. ^^)

 

[a_ilfandy]

If you do a next test, please try this tactic of me: http://www.mediafire.com/?jvyvlayr4cyl1mb

still couldnt download it.. the link says mediafire but the page goes to megaupload..
anyway, your current T-MO 1 is still doing well, so I'll test this one once its got eliminated..
before that, make sure you put somewhere where I can download it.. megaupload is problematic here..

 

[a_ilfandy]

ROUND 9 RESULTS UPDATE!

THE LEAGUE:

THE CUP:

HEAD TO HEAD:

SOME MATCHES:
View attachment 213186View attachment 213187View attachment 213188View attachment 213189View attachment 213190View attachment 213191View attachment 213192View attachment 213193View attachment 213194View attachment 213195View attachment 213196View attachment 213197

 

[a_ilfandy]

"" ^^) HAPPY NEW YEAR EVERYBODY! WISH YOU ALL A BETTER YEAR IN 2012.. ^^) ""

 

[kaanoo29]

ROUND 9 RESULTS UPDATE!

THE LEAGUE:

View attachment 213197

again, my tactic score most in the league, but also against so many ... uh...

 

[XeNoNF50]

keep trying, and lemme have the first bite when you are done..
your tactics yet to disappoint me.. ^^)

Thanks! I'll try lol.

 

[IcyKillers]

Can you give me ross wonder tactic link to thread ?

 

[GobBluthJD]

This is an amazing project!

But...honestly, it's confusing as **** to try and understand. Any way we could get a listing of tactics in order of effectiveness? Overall wins? Anything to make it a little more easy to see which tactics are actually working?

Thanks so much!

 

[a_ilfandy]

again, my tactic score most in the league, but also against so many ... uh...

yeah, thats the case.. very offensive! if you can just improve the defence..
you almost made it to the play off, one point short of second place..
I'll post results later..

 

[a_ilfandy]

This is an amazing project!

But...honestly, it's confusing as **** to try and understand. Any way we could get a listing of tactics in order of effectiveness? Overall wins? Anything to make it a little more easy to see which tactics are actually working?

Thanks so much!

well, I hope you check the OP (first page) before you said that..
but, if you did, and still saying that, then I consider myself totally fail.. :'(

 

[a_ilfandy]

Can you give me ross wonder tactic link to thread ?

here you go: 4-2-2-2 Wonder Tactic
not sure if he has a thread in this forum..

 

[a_ilfandy]

ROUND 9 COMPLETED!

THE LEAGUE:

THE CUP:

THE CUP FINAL:

THE PLAY OFF:

THE PLAY OFF FINAL:

PLAY OFF MATCHES:
View attachment 213502View attachment 213503View attachment 213504

TEAM STATS:
View attachment 213505View attachment 213506View attachment 213507View attachment 213508View attachment 213509View attachment 213510View attachment 213511View attachment 213512

 

[wixta79]

where can i get krunccrni 2?