Tactic Testing League v1

[Will1981]

!!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!! Birmingham 1st in jan, pred 24th

drlw1980 uploaded !!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!! Birmingham 1st in jan, pred 24th Leave feedback below.

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC

PLD

WON

DRN

LST

FOR

AG.

GD

ENG

GER

PTS

YEL

RED

GFC

AFC

SPIELMACHER-by Vujevic Fm23 v7

176​

105​

32​

39​

435​

244​

191​

199​

148​

347​

465​

8​

26​

24​

Tornado

176​

99​

40​

37​

428​

235​

193​

171​

166​

337​

555​

7​

33​

25​

DawidPL 4231 GOAT v2

176​

95​

46​

35​

438​

254​

184​

171​

160​

331​

477​

8​

37​

25​

!!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!!

176​

94​

39​

43​

369​

207​

162​

169​

152​

321​

449​

8​

22​

12​

​

 

[Syorker]

!!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!! Birmingham 1st in jan, pred 24th

drlw1980 uploaded !!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!! Birmingham 1st in jan, pred 24th Leave feedback below.

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC

PLD

WON

DRN

LST

FOR

AG.

GD

ENG

GER

PTS

YEL

RED

GFC

AFC

SPIELMACHER-by Vujevic Fm23 v7

176​

105​

32​

39​

435​

244​

191​

199​

148​

347​

465​

8​

26​

24​

Tornado

176​

99​

40​

37​

428​

235​

193​

171​

166​

337​

555​

7​

33​

25​

DawidPL 4231 GOAT v2

176​

95​

46​

35​

438​

254​

184​

171​

160​

331​

477​

8​

37​

25​

!!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!!

176​

94​

39​

43​

369​

207​

162​

169​

152​

321​

449​

8​

22​

12​

​

Is this the test linked a couple of posts earlier? I'd be curious to see how my 3-4-2-1 fares against Spielmacher and Tornado in this test as I know they're both really effective in game.

 

[Will1981]

Colossus by Chocorelo19

WHY UPDATE deleted?? Because the 442 that I tried to tweak performs badly. Working on an update with the same formation.. Apologies for the inconvenience but it was better to delete it rather have people spending time in a tactic that underperforms. Colossus works great as it is but I am trying...

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC

PLD

WON

DRN

LST

FOR

AG.

GD

ENG

GER

PTS

YEL

RED

GFC

AFC

Colossus

176​

122​

28​

26​

530​

234​

296​

207​

187​

394​

545​

11​

48​

20​

SPIELMACHER-by Vujevic Fm23 v7

176​

105​

32​

39​

435​

244​

191​

199​

148​

347​

465​

8​

26​

24​

Tornado

176​

99​

40​

37​

428​

235​

193​

171​

166​

337​

555​

7​

33​

25​

DawidPL 4231 GOAT v2

176​

95​

46​

35​

438​

254​

184​

171​

160​

331​

477​

8​

37​

25​

!!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!!

176​

94​

39​

43​

369​

207​

162​

169​

152​

321​

449​

8​

22​

12​

 

[Tripoligate4]

Attention for all of u. I have figure out a serious bug in testings...... i lock the option use same tactic when is possible ect......when i do that at least in 3 teams , some of them or one of them it doesnt appear to work...and when u finish u end up with a ramdom tactic that u never apply..

 

[Will1981]

I tried to use this testing to compare, I started in Brazil on January 3rd going on vacation until november 20th. Also, I selected all the 12 countries with small data base. I don't know if these are the same stuff that you did, but these are the results I got:

TACTIC	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AGG	GD>	PTS
4141 zaz/will-casas	176	127	23	26	570	258	312	404

pretty much I use just the Irish league for the January start date.

 

[Will1981]

Attention for all of u. I have figure out a serious bug in testings...... i lock the option use same tactic when is possible ect......when i do that at least in 3 teams , some of them or one of them it doesnt appear to work...and when u finish u end up with a ramdom tactic that u never apply..

Yes I have seen this issue when testing with club teams but never with National teams

 

[Tripoligate4]

i dont know man...the game this year is total doisapointment for me.. not even the basics..

 

[Will1981]

2-2-6 Modern Attack Shape / Icardi 68 Goals

TACTIC

PLD

WON

DRN

LST

FOR

AG.

GD

ENG

GER

PTS

YEL

RED

GFC

AFC

Colossus

176​

122​

28​

26​

530​

234​

296​

207​

187​

394​

545​

11​

48​

20​

SPIELMACHER-by Vujevic Fm23 v7

176​

105​

32​

39​

435​

244​

191​

199​

148​

347​

465​

8​

26​

24​

Tornado

176​

99​

40​

37​

428​

235​

193​

171​

166​

337​

555​

7​

33​

25​

2-2-6 Attack Shape Main RoysRoyz V.3

176​

101​

34​

41​

434​

266​

168​

171​

166​

337​

391​

5​

48​

21​

DawidPL 4231 GOAT v2

176​

95​

46​

35​

438​

254​

184​

171​

160​

331​

477​

8​

37​

25​

!!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!!

176​

94​

39​

43​

369​

207​

162​

169​

152​

321​

449​

8​

22​

12​

 

[Will1981]

4141 Goal Machine 22.3 (Zaz - Blue 4.0 Tweak) FM23 Re-Release

Big shout-out to casas55 who informed me that the most downloaded FM22 tactic on FM-Base (40,000+ downloads and counting was still doing the business on FM23. So I ran the Tactic through my latest testing database with pretty sensational...

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC

PLD

WON

DRN

LST

FOR

AG.

GD

ENG

GER

PTS

YEL

RED

GFC

AFC

4141 Goal Machine 22.3 (Zaz - Blue 4.0 Tweak)

176​

123​

27​

26​

503​

233​

270​

210​

186​

396​

594​

14​

30​

22​

Colossus

176​

122​

28​

26​

530​

234​

296​

207​

187​

394​

545​

11​

48​

20​

SPIELMACHER-by Vujevic Fm23 v7

176​

105​

32​

39​

435​

244​

191​

199​

148​

347​

465​

8​

26​

24​

Tornado

176​

99​

40​

37​

428​

235​

193​

171​

166​

337​

555​

7​

33​

25​

2-2-6 Attack Shape Main RoysRoyz V.3

176​

101​

34​

41​

434​

266​

168​

171​

166​

337​

391​

5​

48​

21​

DawidPL 4231 GOAT v2

176​

95​

46​

35​

438​

254​

184​

171​

160​

331​

477​

8​

37​

25​

!!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!!

176​

94​

39​

43​

369​

207​

162​

169​

152​

321​

449​

8​

22​

12​

 

[DeliciousStory]

Just wanted to try out this test,did 4 fast run (the test is really fast it took like 15-20 minutes to run all of them),but my point is why at least you didn't boost the overall morale? Trying to find a tool that i can use for my test, even made a league but it's like when you compare it to others test league is totaly out of tune.

Btw really good job to even make it!


P.S.

Some players are disappearing, no clue when or where but as you can see from the screen i guess they got kidnapped or the club arrested them

 

[Will1981]

Just wanted to try out this test,did 4 fast run (the test is really fast it took like 15-20 minutes to run all of them),but my point is why at least you didn't boost the overall morale? Trying to find a tool that i can use for my test, even made a league but it's like when you compare it to others test league is totaly out of tune.

Btw really good job to even make it!


P.S.

Some players are disappearing, no clue when or where but as you can see from the screen i guess they got kidnapped or the club arrested them

I think Neuer and sometimes Muller retire at the end of the league but usually play all games.

I do not use any external tools for freezing morale etc. as I like to simulate a real save where I wouldn't use any external tools.

As for your results you got total points of 381, 396, 399 and 402 which I think is pretty accurate for the test over 176 games with a maximum of 21 point swing.

PS your PC must be a lot better than my useless one to run the test is 15/20 mins, my one takes 40 mins per test.

 

[Will1981]

Prometheus by Chocorelo19

Prometheus is an attacking 4-2-2-2 formation based on my successful Corsair IF. You will dominate your opponents and score a lot of goals along the way! In my tests I used Arsenal and I tried to beat the monsters (MAN City&Liverpool). Not only did that but I outscored them without any...

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC

PLD

WON

DRN

LST

FOR

AG.

GD

ENG

GER

PTS

YEL

RED

GFC

AFC

Prometheus 2.0

176​

128​

18​

30​

547​

238​

309​

190​

212​

402​

539​

15​

53​

21​

4141 Goal Machine 22.3 (Zaz - Blue 4.0 Tweak)

176​

123​

27​

26​

503​

233​

270​

210​

186​

396​

594​

14​

30​

22​

Colossus

176​

122​

28​

26​

530​

234​

296​

207​

187​

394​

545​

11​

48​

20​

SPIELMACHER-by Vujevic Fm23 v7

176​

105​

32​

39​

435​

244​

191​

199​

148​

347​

465​

8​

26​

24​

Tornado

176​

99​

40​

37​

428​

235​

193​

171​

166​

337​

555​

7​

33​

25​

2-2-6 Attack Shape Main RoysRoyz V.3

176​

101​

34​

41​

434​

266​

168​

171​

166​

337​

391​

5​

48​

21​

DawidPL 4231 GOAT v2

176​

95​

46​

35​

438​

254​

184​

171​

160​

331​

477​

8​

37​

25​

!!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!!

176​

94​

39​

43​

369​

207​

162​

169​

152​

321​

449​

8​

22​

12​

 

[DeliciousStory]

I think Neuer and sometimes Muller retire at the end of the league but usually play all games.

I do not use any external tools for freezing morale etc. as I like to simulate a real save where I wouldn't use any external tools.

As for your results you got total points of 381, 396, 399 and 402 which I think is pretty accurate for the test over 176 games with a maximum of 21 point swing.

PS your PC must be a lot better than my useless one to run the test is 15/20 mins, my one takes 40 mins per test.

I am using it for check even some tweak i do around the tactics! No mate, i did run 4 runs in 15/20 minutes xD! Btw good work, gonna use it to post some screen on my thread since i find vacation test totaly useless.

 

[Will1981]

Very good 442 Asymmetric

Hello, If you want try. It's a very good tactic, which goes from a 451 formation to a 433 in attack. 110 goals scored in the league for only 24 conceded in 38 games. I have win Ligue 1, French Cup and Europa Ligue with Monaco the first season.

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC

PLD

WON

DRN

LST

FOR

AG.

GD

ENG

GER

PTS

YEL

RED

GFC

AFC

Prometheus 2.0

176​

128​

18​

30​

547​

238​

309​

190​

212​

402​

539​

15​

53​

21​

4141 Goal Machine 22.3 (Zaz - Blue 4.0 Tweak)

176​

123​

27​

26​

503​

233​

270​

210​

186​

396​

594​

14​

30​

22​

Colossus

176​

122​

28​

26​

530​

234​

296​

207​

187​

394​

545​

11​

48​

20​

SPIELMACHER-by Vujevic Fm23 v7

176​

105​

32​

39​

435​

244​

191​

199​

148​

347​

465​

8​

26​

24​

Tornado

176​

99​

40​

37​

428​

235​

193​

171​

166​

337​

555​

7​

33​

25​

2-2-6 Attack Shape Main RoysRoyz V.3

176​

101​

34​

41​

434​

266​

168​

171​

166​

337​

391​

5​

48​

21​

DawidPL 4231 GOAT v2

176​

95​

46​

35​

438​

254​

184​

171​

160​

331​

477​

8​

37​

25​

!!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!!

176​

94​

39​

43​

369​

207​

162​

169​

152​

321​

449​

8​

22​

12​

NESS-ASYM-442

176​

97​

28​

51​

419​

244​

175​

160​

159​

319​

468​

15​

42​

29​

 

[Scooby1984]

Very good 442 Asymmetric

Hello, If you want try. It's a very good tactic, which goes from a 451 formation to a 433 in attack. 110 goals scored in the league for only 24 conceded in 38 games. I have win Ligue 1, French Cup and Europa Ligue with Monaco the first season.

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC

PLD

WON

DRN

LST

FOR

AG.

GD

ENG

GER

PTS

YEL

RED

GFC

AFC

Prometheus 2.0

176​

128​

18​

30​

547​

238​

309​

190​

212​

402​

539​

15​

53​

21​

4141 Goal Machine 22.3 (Zaz - Blue 4.0 Tweak)

176​

123​

27​

26​

503​

233​

270​

210​

186​

396​

594​

14​

30​

22​

Colossus

176​

122​

28​

26​

530​

234​

296​

207​

187​

394​

545​

11​

48​

20​

SPIELMACHER-by Vujevic Fm23 v7

176​

105​

32​

39​

435​

244​

191​

199​

148​

347​

465​

8​

26​

24​

Tornado

176​

99​

40​

37​

428​

235​

193​

171​

166​

337​

555​

7​

33​

25​

2-2-6 Attack Shape Main RoysRoyz V.3

176​

101​

34​

41​

434​

266​

168​

171​

166​

337​

391​

5​

48​

21​

DawidPL 4231 GOAT v2

176​

95​

46​

35​

438​

254​

184​

171​

160​

331​

477​

8​

37​

25​

!!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!!

176​

94​

39​

43​

369​

207​

162​

169​

152​

321​

449​

8​

22​

12​

NESS-ASYM-442

176​

97​

28​

51​

419​

244​

175​

160​

159​

319​

468​

15​

42​

29​

You got a link to the latest zaz blue please

 

[Will1981]

You got a link to the latest zaz blue please

no sorry

 

[Will1981]

300+ GOAL MACHINE 4-2-4 GROGU Tactic

This is without a doubt one of the best Goal Machine tactics in FM23 right now! When creating this tactic, I wanted to be able to score goals at will while also making sure the goals were coming from all areas of the side, and this tactic did not...

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC

PLD

WON

DRN

LST

FOR

AG.

GD

ENG

GER

PTS

YEL

RED

GFC

AFC

Prometheus 2.0

176​

128​

18​

30​

547​

238​

309​

190​

212​

402​

539​

15​

53​

21​

4141 Goal Machine 22.3 (Zaz - Blue 4.0 Tweak)

176​

123​

27​

26​

503​

233​

270​

210​

186​

396​

594​

14​

30​

22​

Colossus

176​

122​

28​

26​

530​

234​

296​

207​

187​

394​

545​

11​

48​

20​

4-2-4 Grogu

176​

111​

27​

38​

488​

304​

184​

185​

175​

360​

405​

11​

55​

32​

SPIELMACHER-by Vujevic Fm23 v7

176​

105​

32​

39​

435​

244​

191​

199​

148​

347​

465​

8​

26​

24​

Tornado

176​

99​

40​

37​

428​

235​

193​

171​

166​

337​

555​

7​

33​

25​

2-2-6 Attack Shape Main RoysRoyz V.3

176​

101​

34​

41​

434​

266​

168​

171​

166​

337​

391​

5​

48​

21​

DawidPL 4231 GOAT v2

176​

95​

46​

35​

438​

254​

184​

171​

160​

331​

477​

8​

37​

25​

!!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!!

176​

94​

39​

43​

369​

207​

162​

169​

152​

321​

449​

8​

22​

12​

NESS-ASYM-442

176​

97​

28​

51​

419​

244​

175​

160​

159​

319​

468​

15​

42​

29​

 

[Will1981]

ZaZ - Water

Water is a high intensity defensive tactic based on Fire, but with wingers and attacking midfielder dropped to a deeper position. For tips and extra information, check the Fire thread. When in possession, inverted wingbacks cut inside to become...

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC

PLD

WON

DRN

LST

FOR

AG.

GD

ENG

GER

PTS

YEL

RED

GFC

AFC

Prometheus 2.0

176​

128​

18​

30​

547​

238​

309​

190​

212​

402​

539​

15​

53​

21​

4141 Goal Machine 22.3 (Zaz - Blue 4.0 Tweak)

176​

123​

27​

26​

503​

233​

270​

210​

186​

396​

594​

14​

30​

22​

Colossus

176​

122​

28​

26​

530​

234​

296​

207​

187​

394​

545​

11​

48​

20​

ZaZ - Water 2.0

176​

111​

31​

34​

478​

248​

230​

181​

183​

364​

647​

14​

53​

30​

4-2-4 Grogu

176​

111​

27​

38​

488​

304​

184​

185​

175​

360​

405​

11​

55​

32​

SPIELMACHER-by Vujevic Fm23 v7

176​

105​

32​

39​

435​

244​

191​

199​

148​

347​

465​

8​

26​

24​

Tornado

176​

99​

40​

37​

428​

235​

193​

171​

166​

337​

555​

7​

33​

25​

2-2-6 Attack Shape Main RoysRoyz V.3

176​

101​

34​

41​

434​

266​

168​

171​

166​

337​

391​

5​

48​

21​

DawidPL 4231 GOAT v2

176​

95​

46​

35​

438​

254​

184​

171​

160​

331​

477​

8​

37​

25​

!!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!!

176​

94​

39​

43​

369​

207​

162​

169​

152​

321​

449​

8​

22​

12​

NESS-ASYM-442

176​

97​

28​

51​

419​

244​

175​

160​

159​

319​

468​

15​

42​

29​

 

[Will1981]

ZaZ - Blue 4.0

Blue 4.0 is a high-intensity tactic based on the successful Blue 3.0 from FM21. When in possession, inverted wing-backs cut inside to become midfielders while shadow striker becomes a third striker. Roaming playmaker is one of the most important...

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC

PLD

WON

DRN

LST

FOR

AG.

GD

ENG

GER

PTS

YEL

RED

GFC

AFC

Prometheus 2.0

176​

128​

18​

30​

547​

238​

309​

190​

212​

402​

539​

15​

53​

21​

4141 Goal Machine 22.3 (Zaz - Blue 4.0 Tweak)

176​

123​

27​

26​

503​

233​

270​

210​

186​

396​

594​

14​

30​

22​

Colossus

176​

122​

28​

26​

530​

234​

296​

207​

187​

394​

545​

11​

48​

20​

ZaZ - Water 2.0

176​

111​

31​

34​

478​

248​

230​

181​

183​

364​

647​

14​

53​

30​

ZaZ - Blue 4.0

176​

113​

22​

41​

558​

312​

246​

183​

178​

361​

608​

16​

31​

34​

4-2-4 Grogu

176​

111​

27​

38​

488​

304​

184​

185​

175​

360​

405​

11​

55​

32​

SPIELMACHER-by Vujevic Fm23 v7

176​

105​

32​

39​

435​

244​

191​

199​

148​

347​

465​

8​

26​

24​

Tornado

176​

99​

40​

37​

428​

235​

193​

171​

166​

337​

555​

7​

33​

25​

2-2-6 Attack Shape Main RoysRoyz V.3

176​

101​

34​

41​

434​

266​

168​

171​

166​

337​

391​

5​

48​

21​

DawidPL 4231 GOAT v2

176​

95​

46​

35​

438​

254​

184​

171​

160​

331​

477​

8​

37​

25​

!!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!!

176​

94​

39​

43​

369​

207​

162​

169​

152​

321​

449​

8​

22​

12​

NESS-ASYM-442

176​

97​

28​

51​

419​

244​

175​

160​

159​

319​

468​

15​

42​

29​

 

[Will1981]

#The Assembler FM23

DeliciousStory uploaded #The Assembler FM23 Leave feedback below.

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC

PLD

WON

DRN

LST

FOR

AG.

GD

ENG

GER

PTS

YEL

RED

GFC

AFC

Prometheus 2.0

176​

128​

18​

30​

547​

238​

309​

190​

212​

402​

539​

15​

53​

21​

4141 Goal Machine 22.3 (Zaz - Blue 4.0 Tweak)

176​

123​

27​

26​

503​

233​

270​

210​

186​

396​

594​

14​

30​

22​

Colossus

176​

122​

28​

26​

530​

234​

296​

207​

187​

394​

545​

11​

48​

20​

4132 Poirer XII

176​

120​

29​

27​

589​

280​

309​

189​

200​

389​

414​

13​

67​

34​

ZaZ - Water 2.0

176​

111​

31​

34​

478​

248​

230​

181​

183​

364​

647​

14​

53​

30​

ZaZ - Blue 4.0

176​

113​

22​

41​

558​

312​

246​

183​

178​

361​

608​

16​

31​

34​

4-2-4 Grogu

176​

111​

27​

38​

488​

304​

184​

185​

175​

360​

405​

11​

55​

32​

SPIELMACHER-by Vujevic Fm23 v7

176​

105​

32​

39​

435​

244​

191​

199​

148​

347​

465​

8​

26​

24​

Tornado

176​

99​

40​

37​

428​

235​

193​

171​

166​

337​

555​

7​

33​

25​

2-2-6 Attack Shape Main RoysRoyz V.3

176​

101​

34​

41​

434​

266​

168​

171​

166​

337​

391​

5​

48​

21​

DawidPL 4231 GOAT v2

176​

95​

46​

35​

438​

254​

184​

171​

160​

331​

477​

8​

37​

25​

!!!!!drlws-4-3-3!!!!!

176​

94​

39​

43​

369​

207​

162​

169​

152​

321​

449​

8​

22​

12​

NESS-ASYM-442

176​

97​

28​

51​

419​

244​

175​

160​

159​

319​

468​

15​

42​

29​