Hi, TBH! I am managing Millwall at the moment (December, first season) and using a flat 442 Balanced with standard mentality, shorter passing, more pressing and zonal marking. I tweaked only the Defensive line to the middle (10/20) since some neither D. Shittu nor M. Beevers are very pacey. The roles are as follows:
1. GK Ben Amos - GK defend
2. CB Shane Lowry, Danny Shittu, Mark Beevers, Stephano Denswil - CD defend
3. FB Matthew Briggs, Scott Malone - FB support
4. FB Adam Smith, John Pantsil - FB support
5. MCR Liam Trotter (tweaked his Run with ball to sometimes), Josh Wright - DLP defend
6. MCL Nadjim Abdou, David Davis - BWM support
7. MR James Henry, Liam Feeney - Winger Attack
8. ML Scott Malone, Chris Taylor - Wide Midfielder Attack
9. FCR Rob Hulse, Mamady Sidibe - Target Man Support
10. FCL Andrew Keogh, Nouha Dicko - Adv. Forward Attack
The results are excellent, currently first-placed in Championship. Strikers, especially Keogh (23 goals in 23 matches), are scoring like mad. Everybody is aiming his crosses to Target Man and when Sidibe is not injured (Natural Fitness 5) he is doing some very nice flick-ons (I did not check Target Man in team instructions). The Ball Winning Midfielder and the MR (Winger Attack) are also doing great. However, my DLP (Trotter) is not doing enough assists even though he is averaging ~7.15 rating. Also, the Wide Midfielder (ML) is doing below 7.00 - very disappointing. I watch some of the matches and the left flank just isn't working very well, it creates too few chances for the forwards. I also tried Scott Malone as Wingback Attack, hugging the line, and Matthew Briggs as Wide Midfield on Defend duty, holding the ball in the midfield while the wingback overlaps and staying back, providing a cover in the left midfield zone - the results weren't satisfying also. The only tweaks I did in the player instructions (aside from lowering the long shots and crossing intensity for these players with poor long shots and crossing stats) is to set man marking and tight marking (yes) for the ML and MR.
Could you please provide some advices how to improve the tactic? Thank you in advance!