The Deal or No Deal Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lee
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 3K
  • Views Views 410K
Player: Van Persie
Team buying: Man United
Team selling: Arsenal
Price: value £20M (up front)
Season: 2011/2012
Other Info: I want to sell him and replace him with Dzeko. I know it's Man U but i want to sell

Your Opinions??

thanks
 
Last edited:
i would say no deal offer him to clubs but tick the box that says rival clubs
 
Player: Diogo
Team buying: AC Milan (me)
Team selling: Zaragoza
Price: value 2.4 mln euros
Jan. 2012
Other Info: He's got great stats and could back up my DC's and RB
 
Mason* said:
Player: Van Persie
Team buying: Man United
Team selling: Arsenal
Price: value £20M (up front)
Season: 2011/2012
Other Info: I want to sell him and replace him with Dzeko. I know it's Man U but i want to sell

Your Opinions??

thanks
Click to expand...
if you are sure you will get dzeko then sell him but if you're not then i don't think so because you won't have a reliable striker

---------- Post added at 05:37 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:36 AM ----------

stan23 said:
Player: Diogo
Team buying: AC Milan (me)
Team selling: Zaragoza
Price: value 2.4 mln euros
Jan. 2012
Other Info: He's got great stats and could back up my DC's and RB
Click to expand...
then deal! 2.4 seems cheap
 
Player: Gael Clichy
Team buying: Barcelona
Team selling: Arsenal (me)
Price: value £9M (up front)
Season: 2011/2012
Other Info: gibbs is at pretty much exactly the same level so I have a good backup, just want to know if this is good value or if i should try and get more?
 
pridders said:
Player: Gael Clichy
Team buying: Barcelona
Team selling: Arsenal (me)
Price: value £9M (up front)
Season: 2011/2012
Other Info: gibbs is at pretty much exactly the same level so I have a good backup, just want to know if this is good value or if i should try and get more?
Click to expand...

Only £9M? No deal. I will only consider if it's £15M or more.
 
Man v.1 said:
Only £9M? No deal. I will only consider if it's £15M or more.
Click to expand...

cheers il negotiate, should i ask for around 15-17 and see if they go for it or just push my luck and go for 20 do you think?
 
pridders said:
cheers il negotiate, should i ask for around 15-17 and see if they go for it or just push my luck and go for 20 do you think?
Click to expand...

I sold him for £24m in my save so I'd try and get £20m out of them.
 
Player: Robinho
Team buying: Liverpool
Team selling: AC Milan (me)
Price: 33 mln euros
Jan. 2012

Player: Dzeko
Team buying: AC Milan (me)
Team selling: Wolfsburg
Price: 8 mln euros
Jan. 2012

Other Info: I have a lot of class strikers that are sitting on the bench. I have Ibrahimovic, Pato, Robinho, Borrielo, Babacar. I play with Ibrahimovic and Pato up front so Robinho is a sub. I wanted to sell some strikers because of the lack of space for them all to play. Dzeko is unhappy so thats why its so cheap, (tottenham are after him too), and Robinho plays well when gets his playing time, Liverpool first offered 21 mln but I negotiated and to 33 mln. Im just afraid everyone in the team will get ****** because such a "star" left the team.
 
Last edited:
stan23 said:
Player: Robinho
Team buying: Liverpool
Team selling: AC Milan (me)
Price: 33 mln euros
Jan. 2012

Player: Dzeko
Team buying: AC Milan (me)
Team selling: Wolfsburg
Price: 8 mln euros
Jan. 2012
Click to expand...

Deal for both.
 
stan23 said:
Player: Robinho
Team buying: Liverpool
Team selling: AC Milan (me)
Price: 33 mln euros
Jan. 2012

Player: Dzeko
Team buying: AC Milan (me)
Team selling: Wolfsburg
Price: 8 mln euros
Jan. 2012

Other Info: I have a lot of class strikers that are sitting on the bench. I have Ibrahimovic, Pato, Robinho, Borrielo, Babacar. I play with Ibrahimovic and Pato up front so Robinho is a sub. I wanted to sell some strikers because of the lack of space for them all to play. Dzeko is unhappy so thats why its so cheap, (tottenham are after him too), and Robinho plays well when gets his playing time, Liverpool first offered 21 mln but I negotiated and to 33 mln. Im just afraid everyone in the team will get ****** because such a "star" left the team.
Click to expand...


I would sell Ibrahimovic while he has value left and Robinho for 33m. Then buy Dzeko and put him up front with Pato for sure.
 
Player: Alexandre Pato
Team buying: Liverpool (me)
Team selling: AC Milan
Price: value £38.5M (upfront), £4M installments (48 months)
Season: 2013/14
Other Info: Need a good striker to support Torres as Lavezzi is out for campaign. Maybe a 3 striker formation once he's back?

Player: Danny Welbeck
Team buying: Real Madrid
Team selling: Liverpool (me)
Price: value £55M, £27M (after 50 league appearances)
Season: 2013/14
Other Info: I am stalled on this, Welbeck's a player I rotate every 2 matches and he's been classy for my team since joining from Man U for £10M in 2012 and has scored 18 in 24. Inter is also chasing.
 
Surely deal for welbeck, not sure about Pato. A 3 striker formation is risky and 42mln in total is too much for a player thats just to support torres for a year. If you were to sell Lavezzi for a good price, then it may be a deal. If you choose not to sell Welbeck he may Torres's partner for the year.
 
Player: David Silva
Team buying: Liverpool (me)
Team selling: Man City
Price: £9.5M (He's unhappy XD)
Season: Season 2, still in transfer window
Other Info: His wanted wage is incredibly huge, about 180,000+...The top earner is Gerrard whom recently signed a new contract,120,000..and I dont want to change that. Also, I'm Liverpool lol, is it worth to pay him that much wage?My other option is Adam Johnson and he might be more expensive than 9.5M..Ibrahim Afellay will come soon on a free transfer. Who do you think I should choose between this three (need a left winger)? I know it's a bargain for David Silva but I still need to sign other players with big wage demands too..
 
daisuke - Personally the wages put me off, but if you really need Silva get him otherwise sign another player like as you said adam johnson



Player - Samir Nasri
Team Buying - Napoli
Team Selling - Arsenal(me)
Price - £15M
2011/12

He is one of my subs.. not used much tbh , I might get Pastore as a replacement

opinions?
 
I'd be tempted to try for 20m but if he's not used much then maybe he's not performing and is only worth 15.

Deal at 15 but I'd want some goal or appearance clauses just in case he performs well at Napoli.
 
daisuke said:
Player: David Silva
Team buying: Liverpool (me)
Team selling: Man City
Price: £9.5M (He's unhappy XD)
Season: Season 2, still in transfer window
Other Info: His wanted wage is incredibly huge, about 180,000+...The top earner is Gerrard whom recently signed a new contract,120,000..and I dont want to change that. Also, I'm Liverpool lol, is it worth to pay him that much wage?My other option is Adam Johnson and he might be more expensive than 9.5M..Ibrahim Afellay will come soon on a free transfer. Who do you think I should choose between this three (need a left winger)? I know it's a bargain for David Silva but I still need to sign other players with big wage demands too..
Click to expand...

No deal for Silva even though it's a bargain. His wages is just too much imo. Go for Afellay but if you want other LW, try Barnetta, Mollo, Balázs Dzsudzsák, Roland Lamah or Adam Hlousek.

Mason* said:
daisuke - Personally the wages put me off, but if you really need Silva get him otherwise sign another player like as you said adam johnson

Player - Samir Nasri
Team Buying - Napoli
Team Selling - Arsenal(me)
Price - £15M
2011/12

He is one of my subs.. not used much tbh , I might get Pastore as a replacement

opinions?
Click to expand...

No deal! £20M or more.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top