The Manchester United Thread

I like Maguire a lot. But some of the values rumoured are just excessive. Let's wait to see what we really paid.
 
That 's fair. I'm really happy with Maguire, just worried about the amount we'll pay. If we spend 90 million in Maguire, if someday a player like Varane or Kouli becomes available, they'll cost more for us.

Also, let's remember that Mourinho wanted Maguire when he was cheaper too. For all the (fair) criticism he gets for his time in Utd, he got a lot of things right.
 
brunoh said:
That 's fair. I'm really happy with Maguire, just worried about the amount we'll pay. If we spend 90 million in Maguire, if someday a player like Varane or Kouli becomes available, they'll cost more for us.

Also, let's remember that Mourinho wanted Maguire when he was cheaper too. For all the (fair) criticism he gets for his time in Utd, he got a lot of things right.
Click to expand...
BBC saying 80m which is still less than what Leicester wanted. And in today’s market honestly for a top CB that will dramatically improve us it ain’t a lot.
 
zzeezzy said:
One interesting thing about Maguire is when you look at the stats last season, him and Van Dijk are pretty much the same. ..... .
Click to expand...

van Dijk's defensive stats are never going to be high mate He's rarely if ever out of position that he has to defend like players who have high stats do. I saw some twitter comparison between Van Dijk and Vidic trying to show Vidic had a far better season in said comparison down to much higher tackles, clearances etc. Which was a terrible misuse of stats that was lost on the lad making them.

It's like the arl brilliant quote from Maldini- 'If I have to make a tackle, then I've already made a mistake.'
 
D_hV_QbW4AYo3ob
 
Scouseinthehouse said:
van Dijk's defensive stats are never going to be high mate He's rarely if ever out of position that he has to defend like players who have high stats do. I saw some twitter comparison between Van Dijk and Vidic trying to show Vidic had a far better season in said comparison down to much higher tackles, clearances etc. Which was a terrible misuse of stats that was lost on the lad making them.

It's like the arl brilliant quote from Maldini- 'If I have to make a tackle, then I've already made a mistake.'
Click to expand...

That's what interceptions cover...
 
Mike. said:
Except I'm using the same kind of model our analysts, professional analysts and scouts use.
Click to expand...

Not sure why you'd take that general point and comparison to a poor twitter post personally when I never referenced you once there like?
 
Scouseinthehouse said:
Not sure why you'd take that general point and comparison to a poor twitter post personally when I never referenced you once there like?
Click to expand...

I'm not taking personally. I'm pointing out that people arent wrong to promote Maguire. Because he stacks up, and the defensive models show it.
 
Sky and BBC talking about Mandzukic now. Hope it comes off would be an excellent option. Also sounds like it’s just the image rights to Dybala deal that needs sorting.
 
Theatre of Dreams83 said:
Sky and BBC talking about Mandzukic now. Hope it comes off would be an excellent option. Also sounds like it’s just the image rights to Dybala deal that needs sorting.
Click to expand...

More than happy to take Mandzukic off their hands, great person I believe to have in the dressing room and he never stops running.
 
This sounds mad but Mandzukic is one of the best defensive strikers out there still... even at the age of 33. Not sure if it will happen, but the guy literally never stops running and pressing.
 
zzeezzy said:
This sounds mad but Mandzukic is one of the best defensive strikers out there still... even at the age of 33. Not sure if it will happen, but the guy literally never stops running and pressing.
Click to expand...

Probably one of the best pressing attackers in football
 
glad we got maguire over the line eventually and glad we didnt also pay above 80m because i would of been ****** if we paid 85m rather then 80 as leicester kept moving the goal posts... next up dybala really tho he looks like he has the ability to score from distance as well as poacher goals will be an amazing signing
 
On Amoyals latest CalcioLand podcast still saying Fernandes will join after they play Benfica in there version of the Portuguese Charity Shield this weekend.
 
So after 1+ month of top negotiating, we finally land Maguire......for what Leicester originally asked for. Like Mike has said on here on numerous occasions, it’s annoying when clubs waste so much time on the fee. Could’ve been integrated with pre-season mins by now.

Content with the signing. I don’t think he elevates us, and we’re getting our pants pulled down unless we recoup 30-40M from 2 of Rojo/Smalling/Jones, but he’s better than what we have - even if it isn’t by that much. Should complement Lindelof well. Let’s give him a chance.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top