On patch day I decided to stick with the "Tough" tweak for Home games, and the "Bermuda V4" for away games. Veez decided upon tweaking the Bermuda concept for a version compatible with 14.2.0. Personally I felt more confidence when using the "Tough" concept of the two (no disrespect intended).
Anyway, I have spent the afternoon and evening playing with the "Tough" tweak and decided to do away with the Shadow Striker. The first thing this does is drastically reduce your CCCs. So sadly, the creation becomes the anti-Christ of tactics in terms of this thread (as it re-introduces a forward man, and reduces your CCCs).
I decided to try it for Everton (a team unlikely to win the Premier League) in the FM13/14 season (default). I made one signing and made a few tweaks to Veez's "Tough" tweak. Here is the tweak I am working with at the moment:
View attachment 450241
Veez has done most of the work with this within the original tweak. I like it because I find it so completely solid defensively, even if the statistics don't fill you with complete confidence.
Before you use this for yourself, I must warn you that I am incredibly lazy. My testing of tactics is to save, load, test, load, test, load, test. I don't watch the ME. I look at that statistics. I get scared. I check the score. I am left with confusion as to how the **** we won.
Anyway this is how the current season is going:
Scores:
The first thing I notice is that the scorelines are smaller. I believe I am scoring less goals, but I may also have found a tactic that works home and away without any need for tweaking and swapping. In case the Man City and Arsenal results were flukes I tested each three times. Here are the results:
Arsenal Game 1:
Arsenal Game 2:
Arsenal Game 3:
My main concern here is the apparent inconsistency with the statistics. It does not fill me with confidence seeing both teams so evenly matched, but a win, is a win.
For the Home Games I use the exact same tactic, making no tweaks whatsoever.
Man City Game 1:
Man City Game 2:
Man City Game 3:
If it's any consolation the 1-1 draw was a Fernandinho 90+1 special.
Conclusion:
Statistics for Home games are looking a lot stronger, which is where I expected the tactic to be. I may have also produced better results with a Shadow Striker for a new save using the original "Tough" tweak.
I would implore anyone who knows anything about testing tactics to check back to the original "Tough" Tweak as it has worked so well for me since patch 14.2.
PSS: Gaining these results as Everton may not be as special as I am making out. Might test with someone like Crystal Palace.