In all honesty, both of your defences are fine the way they are. James, your instincts are correct, but an alternative would be Limited Defender for Vermaelen, and then Ball-Playing Defender, Cover for Koscielny. Not that much of a difference. And for Chris, Limited Defender for Vidic and Central Defender, Defend for Ferdinand.
The one thing people do is over-complicate their defence, or try to do things are unnecessary and wind up having an imbalance or leak a large amount of goals. The key is to keep it simple, or keep it to the tactic for which you are playing. Here's an example;
Lora - Godin - Dominguez - Lopez
This is my current defence with Atletico Madrid. I play the following; "Full Back (Automatic) - Limited Defender (Defend) - Central Defender (Defend) - Full Back (Automatic". Sometimes, I would switch it a little to have Dominguez drop deep and play Cover, so that he can sweep out passes retain possession. I am currently trying to make him into a Ball-Playing Defender via training schedules, but even then, his role would change to Ball-Playing Defender, Defend.
Everything in their Player Instructions is on Default usually, or I would make their Tackling, Normal or Easy - dependent on the tactic itself. So far, I have leaked few goals per game, as the defence has now matured and become better and more consistent. There are a few snags here and there, but there are no 3-2's, 4-3's or 5-4's. Simply because the defence has a simple job to do and it does it fine.
If you really want to alter your Player Instructions, then change your most aggressive defender's PI's to have no Creative Freedom, low Closing Down and Easy tackling. The other defender can have a little higher Closing Down, a small portion of Creative Freedom and Normal tackling. That should do fine. No "Stopper-Cover" system whatsoever. People need to snap out of that because it's not FM10 anymore.
Anyway, just play a normal and un-complicated set-up.
hey nick do you have some kick n' rush tactics ?? please tell me how to make kick n' rush
Nick I just wanted to ask your advice on closing down instructions for two central midfielders playing as deep lying playamkers. I will have one of my midfielders on support and the other on defend. I normally play a fluid control game. Song and Wilshere are my two central midfielders at the moment. Also what are your thoughts on Inside Forward with support duty would this help to protect the wings more and give my full backs more support
nick the dortmund tactic you uploaded is not the right one and you should use numbered sliders so you don't need to upload tactical templates for modern roles
Numbered Sliders : FM2011 Numbered Tactics Slider | FM Scout
in the dortmund tactic there has been no change in the sliders and there some roles differents from the ones that you showed us in the article like BWM-Defend is CM-Automatic in the tactic you uploadedI don't understand what you mean by 'right one'. I will download it but I don't really know what you mean by it.
in the dortmund tactic there has been no change in the sliders and there some roles differents from the ones that you showed us in the article like BWM-Defend is CM-Automatic in the tactic you uploaded
It's on the list of things to post as an article.
The DLP on support should be dealing with the attacking threat through the centre more than the DLP on defensive duty, who should be sitting back in his own area. The defensive DLP should have the far more defensive mentality than the supporting DLP, whilst having little creative freedom and just creating from deep with a shorter passing range. Basically a juxtaposition of the supporting DLP.
Thank you Nick. Sometimes a get dominated in midfield when I am playing two deep lying playmakers can you offer me any further tips on deal with this issue. I am playing a 4231 formation with my deep lying playmakers in the central midfielder position.
Great stuff however, still There are many problems with your screenshots. Most of them have gone.
Perhaps you should change web browser, as others have found using Internet Explorer and Mozilla Firefox the best way of viewing the articles with screenshots.
Is it impossible to keep a clean sheet against the top 4 in the premier league? every time i play either chelsea, arsenal or liverpool i leak goals, even against city and tottenham..