Ok, hope this works!
I'm posting 2 tactics; One which is the same formation as 'Garbage' and one which I mentioned in my original post, ditching a WB and adding a 3rd centre back.
Both work equally well for me but as I said, give it time to settle if you've been using the Garbage tactic because the defenders now have to change the way they play entirely.
View attachment 791948View attachment 791951
View attachment 791944
View attachment 791945
Also, I forgot to mention I have been using Opposition instructions, basically:
Closing down 'Always' on every player.
Tackling 'Hard' on DR, DL, WBR, WBL, MR, ML, AMR & AML
Show onto 'Weaker Foot' for all except DR, DL, WBR, WBL, - These need to be show onto opposite foot (eg DL and WBL show into Right Foot).
Screenshot in case that didn't make sense:
View attachment 791947