Top marks for the post mate but the tactic is absolutely awful...FACT, there is too many people on here that adjust player attributes and so on, truth is there is no killer tactic or anything suh as that since the introduction of the football manager match engine rather than the champ man one truth is the tactic has to be based on the team you have and player attributes also you can save a game 4 days before to play and try every one of the tactics on this and any other site and it will not make an ounce of difference and thats not because tactic has not had tiime to settle or any of that rubbish but because it depends on how good your players are compared to the oppositions. simple as if i am wrong then surely out of the hundreds of thousands or millions of people across the world that play this game would have inevitably developed "THE BEST TACTIC". Now i am not trying to put a damper on any one persons achievements within the game but keep one thing in mind it is not the tactic that is the most imnportant thing it is the team that you manage to build and the things that come with a good team are winning games and in turn improving clubs rep and potential to improve facilities etc that will enhance any players you buy.
1) thanks, clearly you do not know much about Fm to have that view on things
2) tactics are the most important aspect of the game
3) yes players need to have certain stats for certain tactics, that is why we as tactic makers suggest players and give a breakdown of the type of player you need to fill each position
4) there are many tactics over the years that are absolutely unstoppable! but they are match engine exploits most of the time and I dont make these type of tactics, I make real tactics that play good football and if it does not work for you and your team then that is a shame but say what you want on the thread and thats it!
5) as I mentioned in the OP this tactic is not for small teams, you need good players to fill each position in order for this tactic to work properly!
6) it also goes down to the manager! you can take a horse to water but you cant make it drink! tactics are templates/basis for members/managers to use and make the CORRECT changes in order to suit their own team, clearly you cannot do this correctly hence you suffered with it
as always mate, not every single member is going to have success with every single tactic ever made! yes I would understand if a lot of people came back and said, yo neil, losing a lot with this tactic etc.. not going to well! yet people beat Ac Milan, Chelsea, Real Madrid, Roma 6-8:0
Yes I do agree with you that players are important
if you take the time to search these forums and see the amount of people asking for help/tactics for their AWESOME Man City teams or Arsenal etc you will see that no matter how incredible your players are in your squad, with the wrong tactic and wrong roles you will not win a game!
yes, I know what you mean that a lot of people make tatics that work well for them then post it here and it does not work for others, that is why we say try and stick to the type of players that are similar to the players we used to make the tactic a success and make the necessary changes for your own team! this was a project I worked on personally and never intended to upload it, it just so happened that it worked really well and thought I would share it with the community so they could hopefully experience the same results I have had with it, so many people release one tactic and then have to make hundreds of changes to it
this was the 1st tactic that I have released that has not been (to me) 100% perfect! it is only about 80% completed in my eyes but thought I had to share it
As I said, I know where you are coming from but you are wrong
well partly