I've found a formula that works great for me using only the v2 tactics with the DM's. I'll try to summarize my approach the best I can. The main thing that's helped is making adjustments on the fly during the game using shouts and opponent instructions.
-I've set everyone's long shots to rarely, for one my players aren't great shooting from range and secondly it seems like there's still plenty of long shots taken (maybe a ME thing, but who knows)
-I use the counter version away always and at home when odds are against me
-Always start with your recommended shouts for v2 but depending on how the game is going I've found some shouts that seem to really help:
Evaluating match stats 20-30 min in- If not having enough shots but decent possession I'll add Get Ball Forward and Play Through Defense (this one seems to really kill it with your tactic). If not enough shots and less than 40% possession I still use those two shouts but replace Pass into Space with Pass to Feet.
-I start every match with no OI, then at half time I ask either my *** man or defending coach for advice. For some reason asking them at the start doesn't seem effective but giving them the first half to see how things are going really seems to help limit opposing players.
-Finally, the fullbacks seem to be crucial to this tactic (at least for me). I've noticed that anytime I'm down at half or I really haven't been getting forward enough there's almost always at least one fullback with a 5.9 rating or less. In this case, depending on his body language I'll usually substitute him. If both fullbacks are 5.9 or under I substitute the one that is doing worse or has the worst body language indicator.
Hope these pointers help some people that might be struggling. Of course, what you do and don't do should depend mostly on your squad. Here's my results after making these changes and while sitting in 23rd midway through the season:
View attachment 282076View attachment 282077
The reason I posted the results now and not when the season is completed is because I'm planning on giving some youngsters a run in to prepare them for next season. I'll finish 18th at worst so results aren't really that important to me now.