Rate My Kit Thread - *Please Read Rules Before Posting*

  • Thread starter Thread starter StuW
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 625
  • Views Views 407K
can anyone help me i need a new dartford home away n 3rd kit home black n white away is blue 3rd is green thanks everyone any sponsor will do
 
rating Mike's kits, 7/10 for home and away,8/10 for the third,i like the blue color shade selection ! Below,a new template i've developed :

bayp.png
 
The template so far is looking good ^^ but I'd make the "body" of the shirt slightly wider, its quite curved and maybe fix the collar a bit?

As for the design it feels "flat" and that bright red is killing my eyes, maybe it should be less brighter?

Because I like the template 7/10

r4w9qyqimalob743vim.png
 
Last edited:
The design looks good with the Arsenal kit, but I'm not sure about the Southampton kit. The red white and black seem as if they clash a bit, especially on the adidas logo. Either way it's a good design, 8/10.
Jfb48vS.png
z6BQqxm.png
H134vwW.png

These are some kits for a Hyde United save I recently started on 09. (I dont really like the 2nd kit but i wanted to make it look quite close)​
 
5/10 6/10 and 6/10 because the shapes are too plain in general,they don't ''follow'' the template...

below,a new template i develope, ariston 7 :

hof_zps21ebb5f8.png
 
GGGG75 said:
below,a new template i develope, ariston 7 :

hof_zps21ebb5f8.png
Click to expand...

Still playing around with the template, and as you can see it's not the best and it's very edgy, but you're made the kit look so realistic. 9/10 for template and design, but 10/10 for effort.
 
The template with the guy in the Hoffenheim shirt is ugly as ****. I just don't like it. Would every kit have to have that guy in it, or could you make it more just like a generic mannequin look?

Some sexy kits I developed for a fantasy Cambridge United game, in the SS style:

View attachment 339434View attachment 339435View attachment 339436

The brief was to make three kits which I could use all the way from the Conference to the Premier League. The home kit I wanted something edgy so I added a little white. The away kit I wanted in the same style to the home, but more of a Napoli home kit feel. And the third kit was just a nice template I found. I am really happy with them overall, the only thing I intend to change is to thin out the collar on the third kit, as my friend implied that it looks like a polar neck sweater.
 
Adolfo said:
Some sexy kits I developed for a fantasy Cambridge United game, in the SS style:

View attachment 339434View attachment 339435View attachment 339436

The brief was to make three kits which I could use all the way from the Conference to the Premier League. The home kit I wanted something edgy so I added a little white. The away kit I wanted in the same style to the home, but more of a Napoli home kit feel. And the third kit was just a nice template I found. I am really happy with them overall, the only thing I intend to change is to thin out the collar on the third kit, as my friend implied that it looks like a polar neck sweater.
Click to expand...

Not really sexy if I'm honest. Maybe it's because the template is about 5 years out of date, they'll probably look better on a more up-to-date template. 6/10, 7/10, 7/10.

Arsenal 2005-06 kits remade.

arsenalhm.png
arsenalaq.png

​
 
9/10 for the first as it is quite simple and the granate color is strong,8/10 for the 2nd because it could be used a more deep yellow than the lemon alike.And additionally,as the sponsor is actually a logo and not a word,maybe the crest should go to the right-as i see it-side and not in center,as now it seems a bit ''stressed'' up...

below,a new template i made and cska moscow :

csk_zpsa76d811c.png
csk2_zpsfe4c377e.png
 
GGGG75 said:
below,a new template i made and cska moscow :

csk_zpsa76d811c.png
csk2_zpsfe4c377e.png
Click to expand...

Not bad. As for the template, it's a nice clean one, however it doesn't look right at the bottom because it sticks out a bit. The designs are quality though, big fan of both collars. 9/10.

More Arsenal kits, this time on a new template, a flat kit.

92796280.png
44728707.png

​
 
Last edited:
Germaniac said:
the club logo is not good enough, maybe because it's too small (it looks like barca logo) 5/10
Click to expand...
That's the actual logo from the real team, i suppose it does have the general outline of Barcelona's, but what about the kits themselves? I didn't think this was a rate my logo thead
 
Germaniac said:
OMG.png
OMG_AWAY.png

made in SmartShirtDesigner, design made in GIMP :)
Click to expand...
The home kit's alright, but I'd make the cannon on the front a bit more subtle.
As for the away kit, not a big fan of lime green and orange or the brown cannon. I like that the diagonal stripes follow the angle of the cannon, though maybe they could be wider. Neither design is bad, just mess with the colours.
7 and 6/10

Napoli kits (H/A/T)
oPOxy8a.png
nzvEM2X.png
Wg8Paxj.png
 
Yohan Cabbage said:
That's the actual logo from the real team, i suppose it does have the general outline of Barcelona's, but what about the kits themselves? I didn't think this was a rate my logo thead
Click to expand...
No, 5/10 isn't rate for the logo it's for the kits, if you're using SSD use lightning mode D and move the logo and brand a little lower
 
Napoli kits look nice and clean, the sleeves on the home kit have a little too much going on, I think getting rid of either of the white details on the home kit will tidy it up, but I do like the thick fading stripe where the sponsor and badge are. Not too sure on the double-coloured collar on the away kit, I think having it the same colour would make it look neater but the rest of the away kit is spotless. The third kit is nice but I don't think black details go with navy blue, maybe if they were white or even the same colour it would look a little better. Good effort nonetheless.
Home - 7/10 | Away - 8/10 | 3rd - 6/10

Here are my Bayern kits:
GK HOME AWAY
View attachment 347753View attachment 347754View attachment 347755
 
gaza019 said:
Napoli kits look nice and clean, the sleeves on the home kit have a little too much going on, I think getting rid of either of the white details on the home kit will tidy it up, but I do like the thick fading stripe where the sponsor and badge are. Not too sure on the double-coloured collar on the away kit, I think having it the same colour would make it look neater but the rest of the away kit is spotless. The third kit is nice but I don't think black details go with navy blue, maybe if they were white or even the same colour it would look a little better. Good effort nonetheless.
Home - 7/10 | Away - 8/10 | 3rd - 6/10

Here are my Bayern kits:
GK HOME AWAY
View attachment 347753View attachment 347754View attachment 347755
Click to expand...

Hi, I've only experimented with making kits for a week or two so I can't comment from much experience, but I think they all look great - my favourite is the away, I like the red trim on the collar and the overall dark blue colour. Home is great too, I like the diamond pattern. Not too keen on the GK colour, but I can see why you would choose it. Only other thing I'd say is that the badges look like they're floating a bit in the air!

GK - 7/10
H - 9/10
A - 9.5/10

Here are mine, I had a go with some slightly older templates for a Canterbury Reading kit, home, away and third:

View attachment 348649View attachment 348648View attachment 348650
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top