Hi would like to provide some feedback for your consideration using this tactic.
So far very please attacking wise other the fact Rooney doesn't seem to score or be effective enough in the DLF position. Not consistency in scoring and providing goals at all. 15 games in ... score 4 goals 3 assist with average match rating 7.00
However I seem to have a major problem in defense as it's very leaky. Almost conceaded 2 goals every match even after following instructions on page 1. I tried tweaking the defensive line etc on my own but to no avail.
Alot of goals conceaded from open play and another which I'm not sure whether it's a ME bug but what happens is the defender just watches the striker run through him with no attempt to tackle to score a goal. It's very annoying.
I understand that the tactic is still in beta but here are some of things that I noted.
When would the full version of this tactic be released? I hope things are going fine
Also out of topic but would you be doing a Amazing tactic you used on yours spurs save for FM12? Because I rate it very highly in FM12 and I feel that it's better then Might and Magic FM12. I also prefer the lower defensive line in that tactic.
I've got the same problem with the leaky defence, My defenders just stand still and watch the attackers. I think it's ME bug though. As my team are 100% familiar with the tactic.
I've all so seen my defenders switching off when it starts rolling to the keeper only for the attacker to carry on a beat the keeper to the ball and score.
Sounds like a lot of things need to be adjusted game to game, and is this totally based on Man Utd's style of play ?
You couldn't really use this with smaller teams because you need to buy certain types of players
View attachment 280871
View attachment 280872
Like I said earlier, started using this tactic after my own saw us sitting 18th after 17 games. Tactic seems to work even better with the full version updates, the Chesterfield result was the first one since full version was released. Looks like you've created another winner. One note, I did as you recommended in your OP and made some adjustments to suit the games. Away games against teams with good offense I drop STL to AMC set to AP support and change from attacking to counter, which seems to work well (I also switch to that when leading in second half, usually in 70th min when up by 1, sooner if up by 2 or more). I fully intended on switching back to the tactic I created after the update but 7 wins in a row, think I'll stick to yours! Great work again.
Edit: Of course after posting about it, I end the 7 match win streak by drawing at home to lowly Barnet.
From the moment I found your Swoop tactic last year I used it 'til the day I stopped playing FM12. I've given this a download and pre-season has been very successful and with that enjoyable. I signed Fellaini (hefty £21m + £175k p/w) as you reccomended and it's paying dividends - he's scored in three successive games. The only thing I've changed is the AML role; I've changed it to Advanced Playmaker, Attack for Santi Cazorla to hold up the play a bit and it's working very, very well - he's got 6 assists in 4 matches in pre-season. Hope all goes well throughout the season.